Is there anything 'wrong' with the SW99 series...

dogsoldier

Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2006
Messages
359
Reaction score
89
Location
Heart of Dixie
...that would automatically rule one out as a CCW piece? When I was an LEO I briefly carried Walther P99s(100% German-made) in 9MM and in .40S&W. The 9MM was 'scary' accurate and I miss it. I heard 'tales' about the SW99 and am curious as to whether the years have changed the 'negatives' that were floating around re: the SW99 vs. the P99 10 or so years ago. TIA
 
Register to hide this ad
I have 3 of the 99's........a full size 45, full size 40 and the compact 40. The compact 40 is one of two guns that I CCW with. I have never had any problems with my three.
 
I had a SW990L compact in 9mm for a while. I wasn't wild about the lack of a decocker, and no manual safety. Not all of the SW99's are set up the same way. It was light, accurate, and for a polymer pistol, I think attractive (stainless slide). I've never been one for striker fired pistols though, and in the end, I just didn't like the trigger. My only other complaint was it is a tad bit wide.
 
My daily CCW is a SW99-40. Great gun, accurate and moderate in weight, if that is a concern.
 
Is there anything 'wrong' with the SW99 series...

No.

I didn't particularly care for the 990L's. They were essentially QA models without the field-stripping button incorporated into the slide. I prefer the standard sear action (Walther's Anti-Stress action).

I still own & use a couple of SW99's, a full-size SW9940 and a compact SW999c.

S&W made the slides & barrels for their licensed 99 models, with Walther providing the frame, frame parts and the parts that went into the slide (other than the barrel).
 
My department issued us our 99's in 40 cal in 2001 or 2002. Since then, it's been beat pretty badly. Only the right rear night sight still works. It's scratched and gouged. Still runs, never failed.
 
One of the most comfortable carry guns I own.

IMG_2915.jpg
 
I am considering one now. However, could someone explain the differences in the AS, QA, OL designations? I like the feel of the gun but I am not sure if I understand the operations of the multiple variations. I would rather know for sure what each operation type is before I make an offer.

Thanks for your time.
 
i have the SW99c and i have what is referred to as the AS or anti stress fire control. The AS is a SA/DA variant, where upon the slide being manipulated it places the gun in the SA mode, although the trigger remains at the DA point, the pull is light and is a two stage trigger, meaning that although it is a SA light pull it is as long as the DA length pull, one can pull on the trigger to the first stage which is a shorter pull, the only way to make the striker/ trigger back tot he DA heavy pull is to manipulate the slide de-cocker, upon manipulating this it de-cocks the SA back to DA, from there it is a heavy pull again, if you had not staged the trigger the trigger will not move, but if you did stage the trigger to the SA half way mark, the trigger will return to the longer DA or first SA stage.

The SW990 is a true DA pistol, which every pull is a DAO and is uniform, no de-cocker as there is no need for it.

Now the "QA" is something else, it is similar to the "AS" and fires SA only, because once you use the De-cocker it de-cock's the pistol completely and manipulation of the slide is required to bring it back into operation, why this was done is a mystery to me, and i would far prefer the "AS" which is why i bought the SW99c in 40SW and in the "AS" guise, it is by far the most desirable as far as i am concerned...
 
You can download the SW99 series owner manual from the archived section on this page. Owner's Manuals - Smith & Wesson It will describe the operation of each model.

The standard SW99 was essentially the Walther AS.

The SW99 QA would have been similar to the Walther P99 QA, in which the striker is partially pre-cocked when the slide is retracted (like when chambering a round), and then the trigger completes the process of fully cocking and releasing the striker to fire the gun. The pre-cocked striker in the QA is released via a field-stripping button located in the slide (same location as the AS decocking button, but smaller).

The SW990 would have been the DAO model. (Like the original P99 DAO was first called the P990)

The SW990L was a unique model for S&W, with the smooth slide of the DAO, but the trigger/sear action of the QA. We were told in one of the armorer classes that the "L" was tentatively going to stand for "Lightning", for the short & fast trigger of the QA sear action. The 990L's partially-cocked striker had to be released for field-stripping the gun by pulling the trigger on an empty chamber (like the Sigma). It lacked the field-stripping button on the slide of the Walther QA model.

The SW99NJ was a very limited run of guns, and one of my armorer manuals was printed to include info about it after that model had been produced (I think it was at the time of my second class), since it differed slightly from the regular model (at the request of the NJSP ... which is another story in itself ;) ). I've wondered if that armorer manual listing the SW99NJ model might become a collector piece among armorers. :)

Now, while S&W originally planned to release QA & DAO models, I never saw any of them myself. I rather wonder if they ever saw production. The only models used in the armorer classes I attended over the years were the standard AS-type guns.

There are some minor differences among the models/calibers, but those are only important to an armorer/repair tech, as they aren't anything an owner would normally be concerned with for normal field-stripping & cleaning. Different sear blocks; different trigger bar guides (although there's actually a range of them listed in the German tech/armorer manual, in case a particular gun has a "timing" issue regarding striker travel distance and the release point of the striker in DA mode); trigger bars; a couple of extractor springs; extractors; a couple of striker springs (standard/AS v. QA/990L): a couple slide stop lever springs: different locking blocks in the full-size & compact models ... just off the top of my head.

The bottom line is that the SW99/990L series were pretty good pistols, like the Walther models. Just different slide & barrel manufacture.
 
Last edited:
I have the AS model in .40 and it's been either in my nightstand and/ or in my waistband since the day I bought (almost 2 years now). It was a police trade in, but the night sights still glow strongly, and it came with 3 mags, plus I've fired an assortment of .40 S&W ammo and it had endured nicely!
This is one of those "sleeper" pistols that you hear about, there plain, common, working pistols that are dependable and accurate...but let's keep a secret anyway!;) Dale
 
Back
Top