John Sayles film "Amigo" - Philippine/American War

sigp220.45

US Veteran
Joined
Dec 19, 2005
Messages
8,611
Reaction score
36,329
Location
Colorado
I haven't seen this, but thought some folks here might like a heads up on this film.

John Sayles did a great job with "Matewan" and I've enjoyed some of his other films.

Its good to see the Philippines campaign of the Spanish American War getting a little screen time. I like both Chris Cooper (July Johnson from Lonesome Dove) and Garrett Dillahunt (Deadwood), so maybe it won't stink.

'Amigo' Sends John Sayles to the Philippines (TIFF 2010 Review) - The Moviefone Blog

http://www.slashfilm.com/amigo-trailer-john-sayles/
 
Register to hide this ad
Probably worth a look.

The gun nut in me points out that it's an offshoot of the Spanish/American war in the Phillipines - the so-called Moros Rebellion - that was the driving force behind the U.S. Army's effort to develop a better handgun, and that handgun turned out to be John Moses Browning's 1911.
 
Wish I knew more about the conflict...

... but based upon the admittedly interesting trailer it looks like another Anti-American Revisionist Hatchet Piece... trying to wake the snakes of Vietnam and put it in the Phillipines...

Hope the film is different.

I didn't see and Spanish Colonial Atrocities or Moro (Muslim) Butchering of Christians, but then again, that may not have been convenient to the story line....
 
Based on the trailer, it's a cable watch or, maybe, buy the DVD used from Amazon. Don't know if it would even make cable.

But, the movie may turn out better than it looks, I hope.

Bob
 
Forgotten Phillipine-American war

I've spent years researching the history of Corporal Alfie Colley, 38th US Volunteers-died 1902-buried here-in Waynesville, Missouri.
The US Volunteers were rated as some of the finest soldiers the country has fielded. It's fascinating that this young man was somehow motivated to join the volunteers-get shipped around the globe-to fight in a war without glory. He died of some exotic illness-probably malaria.
Many of these troops were issued Trap Doors-the war was not popular-the press turned against the military (surprise). Even Mark Twain protested. Yet thousands volunteered!
 
The only other film I am aware of about the Phillipines/American conflict is the 1939 Gary Cooper/David Nivens "The Real Glory" also starring Boderick Crawford.
I love that movie! When I was a kid, I used to stay up til the middle of the night in order to catch it on Channel 9 in Chicago.

By way of clarification, the Philippine Insurrection and the Moro Uprising (Jihad) were different conflicts. The Insurrection was about the majority Christian Philippinos trying to achieve independence from the US, having just achieved it from the Spanish. It was defeated when Frederick Funston(?) captured the leader in a daring special operation.

The Moro Uprising is just another example of extremist Muslims wanting to rule over the "dhimmis" in a Caliphate. They considered it their right to have Christian Philippinos as slaves. The Uprising lasted until right around the start of WWI and was EXCEPTIONALLY brutal on both sides.

It was the REAL impetus for the adoption of the M1911. The Moros used to wrap their testicles with wet leather and go "juramentado" (Philippine term for the Indonesian "amok"). When it started to dry, they didn't even NOTICE a .38 Long Colt to anywhere but the head or heart. The conflict also saw widespread use of Colt-Browning M1895 machineguns and Winchester Model 97 riot guns.

I believe that the last major battle was at Bud Bagsak, an extinct volcano where the US brought to bear, machineguns, artillery and shotguns to virtually wipe out the Moro force.

Abu Sayyaf and company are just more of the same.
 
That was a dark time in American history. Essentially the people of the PI felt that they were double crossed by the Americans. After being freed from the Spanish as a colonial power, they had the idea that they ought be left in peace and to their own devices. Instead American foreign policy took a turns towards imperialism and instead they were told "Silly brown people, you're our colony now."

This was the war that spawned the phrase "Civilize them with a Krag".

Press reaction in the states was mixed. Some papers considered the PI's inhabitants to be savages and encouraged men to volunteer on grounds of fighting what amounted to a race war. What were mainstream papers of the time made reference to Filipinos with openly racial slurs.

Some criticized the idea of America having an empire, then and now. Among them were populists and yes, Mark Twain.

That what now would be regarded as war crimes took place was well documented at the time and fairly well known. Water boarding, concentration camps, the burning of crops - no secret was made of it. Opinion in the US was divided. Some thought the Filipinos were savages and deserved it, others were horrified by what began to take place.

Eventually it became too much for even the Army, Google "Samar campaign" and "howling wilderness". At one point explicit orders were given by an American Army General to kill all male inhabitants ten and up. Much of this was publicized when a court martial was finally convened. Only the disobedience of subordinate commanders in NOT killing everyone someone mitigated the violence. (The initial order was pretty much literally to "kill them all", the concession to kill only males ten and up actually toned down the initial order and was seen as making it more humane...)

In the end there was a peace, and American colonialism took a somewhat light handed approach - schools and hospitals built etc. So much so that by the time of the Japanese invasion some 40 years later, the PI sided with the United States and fought convincingly against the Japanese. But... if you watch even the relatively period (1945) John Wayne film "Back to Bataan", it was widely acknowledged that the guerilla tradition and heroes of those times were something to be drawn on to once again inspire resistance.
 
you can bet it will show the spaniards (whites) abusing the filipinos....but the muslim moro filipino's murderous rampage of the inocent will be glazed over......
 
Only the disobedience of subordinate commanders in NOT killing everyone someone mitigated the violence.
I used this case as an example of the importance of disobeying illegal orders, in my Law of Land Warfare and Geneva Convention classes to my basic trainees.
 
you can bet it will show the spaniards (whites) abusing the filipinos....but the muslim moro filipino's murderous rampage of the inocent will be glazed over......

Different war. This one is about the initial nationalist uprising by the Filipinos against American forces becoming a colonizing power instead of a liberating power. The Moro rebellion was later and Filipino constabulary forces - ie other Filipinos - served alongside American troops in fighting the Moros. (Muslim rebels continue to be a problem there to this day.)
 
Back
Top