There's a local LH 29-4 3" for sale. It has a pretty worn finish. Someone carried this thing holstered and probably shot it quite a bit. There is even a touch of superficial surface rust in spots. Would sending it back to SW to get refinished hurt any collector value or help things out?
Lew Horton 29-4 refinishing
- Thread starter CarNDrvr
- Start date
Register to hide this ad
Having it refinished will not help its "collector value," but in poor finish condition it has very little anyway, IMO. If you particularly like that model and would be happier with it if it had a nicer finish, I'd send it in for a tune up and refinish, but it's your revolver and only you know whether the expense is worth it. I certainly cannot claim to be innocent in such decisions. 
Refinishing does not improve collector value or appeal as a refinish destroys the originality of the firearm. The cost of refinishing rarely improves the shooter grade value enough to cover the cost of refinishing, so refinishing is purely to satisfy the current owner's desire to have a nice looking firearm.
FORDS in Crystal River, Florida is excellant in refinishing but also "Expensive".
Are you sure that it's a 3" bbl. Model 29-4, and not a 29-3? I can't claim to be an expert, but I don't recall any Lew Horton models being based on the Model 29-4. S&W made 5,000 Model 29-3 Lew Horton Combat Magnums (3" bbl., RB, contoured wood stocks, etc.) in 1984-85, but that's it. I did a quick check in the SCSW 4th Ed. (including Performance Center models) and couldn't find any other Lew Horton 3" bbl. 29s. S&W did make a 29-4 with full lug 3" bbl. and unfluted cylinder in 1989, but it wasn't listed as a LH. GB has a very nice one of these that they're calling a LH, asking $2800!
Now back to your original question...I would not mess with that revolver if it were mine. Any 3" bbl. Model 29s are relatively rare and desirable. You didn't mention its mechanical condition or what type of stocks, but if it's smooth and tight action that's great. In its present condition, you probably couldn't hurt the finish much more by carrying and shooting it, and it would make a fine defensive revolver for hiking in the woods or carrying in your vehicle. But as others have said, if you decide to buy it then it's your revolver. If it will make you happy to have it refinished, go for it. You also didn't mention the asking price, but "as is" it would be an $1K revolver to me. Asking prices for LH 29-3 revolvers in VG condition on GB are $2500-$3000. Good luck with your decision.
Now back to your original question...I would not mess with that revolver if it were mine. Any 3" bbl. Model 29s are relatively rare and desirable. You didn't mention its mechanical condition or what type of stocks, but if it's smooth and tight action that's great. In its present condition, you probably couldn't hurt the finish much more by carrying and shooting it, and it would make a fine defensive revolver for hiking in the woods or carrying in your vehicle. But as others have said, if you decide to buy it then it's your revolver. If it will make you happy to have it refinished, go for it. You also didn't mention the asking price, but "as is" it would be an $1K revolver to me. Asking prices for LH 29-3 revolvers in VG condition on GB are $2500-$3000. Good luck with your decision.
OP
Not bad looking at all. I don't believe I would want to refinish that one.
Lou_the_welder
Member
I like it. My 29-3 has rust under the right side grip. I think mine may have been stored that way. But I got mine cheep , so I don't complain.
- Joined
- Sep 14, 2021
- Messages
- 272
- Reaction score
- 901
Unless the finish looks a lot rougher in person than the photos show, a unique piece like that is going to be worth less after refinishing than it is currently. "Leave it alone" gets my vote as well.
I'd leave it alone too. Doesn't look abused, just used.
My LH 3" is a 29-3. Lucked out as they're a rare bird up in Canada & the only one I've seen.
Didn't take long to make up my mind on that one.
Good luck,
Al
Didn't take long to make up my mind on that one.
Good luck,
Al
OP
So I suppose my next question would be what's a good price to pay? Looks like it may not be a Lew Horton after all based on what some of you have said.
In that shape you might get it for under $1k. Hard to say. Most are safe queens asking twice that.
That gun is perfect on the outside, worn enough that you won't mind shooting it, nice enough to be proud of! The more important thing is how it functions, like carry up, hand ratchet interface smoothness, forcing cone integrity, b/c gap!
Ivan the Butcher
Member
DeSantis makes a few styles of holster for those. I liked them so much I got both tan and black. I prefer speed strips for spare loads, but only have a black carrier.
Ivan
Ivan
The perfect shooter! Just clean her up with CLR and carry/shoot her until your heart's content.
Last edited:
That's a nice gun. If you like it, buy it and shoot it.
But, I have to say, it's amazing how often the same question about refinishing perfectly good shooter grade revolvers comes up, over, and over, and over again.
With that said, I'd like to recommend the search tool on the S&W forum. There's a ton of great info already posted. Some of the best posts are quite lengthy and members may not want to rewrite the same stuff repeatedly.
Example, (just two weeks ago!):
https://smith-wessonforum.com/s-w-r...2583-rebluing-cost-quality.html#post141994743
But, I have to say, it's amazing how often the same question about refinishing perfectly good shooter grade revolvers comes up, over, and over, and over again.
With that said, I'd like to recommend the search tool on the S&W forum. There's a ton of great info already posted. Some of the best posts are quite lengthy and members may not want to rewrite the same stuff repeatedly.
Example, (just two weeks ago!):
https://smith-wessonforum.com/s-w-r...2583-rebluing-cost-quality.html#post141994743
Last edited:
Honestly, it shows honest wear and use, rather than spend money on refinishing, I'd spend that money on a good holster and some ammo. Either swap the rubber grips for some wood stocks or keep the metal under the rubber clean and well oiled or waxed. Rubber stocks have no wicking ability, so any moisture under the rubber gets held against the metal of the revolver.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
