Kp321 hit the nail on the head, in my opinion. The market looks a little more fondly on the dash-2 because of the extractor update.
Me? I have a lot of hands-on experience with multiple 52-2's. I have never had the pleasure to shoot or handle a 52-1. I'd love to own one. I definitely agree (with all semiauto pistols but especially long extractor S&W 39's and 52's) that all rounds chambered always need to be stripped from a magazine with no exceptions.
Here's something I definitely do know about 52's and 52-1's...
Lots of folks ordered a spare replacement long extractor when the revised 52-2 came out. It seems to make good sense that if S&W thought it might be a weak link that owners should cover themselves with a back-up extractor.
AND... maybe you can guess the next bit. -MANY- times we will see for sale someone's old 52-1, and tucked away in the box is a spare, never used, extra long style extractor!
I have also heard shooters from the last generation prefer the 52-1 trigger to the 52-2, but I haven't had a chance to compare them. It seems to me that you could grab any two random 52's from any era and find a difference in the trigger feel.
Can you tell that I love the 52?
