OP
tdan, I got the M696 cylinder assembly (including extractor) and 5-shot hand from S&W. Shipped them along with the M681-3 off to David Clements, and the revolver above is what he sent back. David did relate that the new 5-shot cylinder from S&W was incompletely reamed for .44 Special, but he remedied that...
RidgwayCo,
That's very interesting! I fit the 44 cylinder to my 586 today. It was basically a drop in. I had to do some slight fitting of the new hand I bought with it, and that would have been all. Except, the extractor star was missing the final machining step on the hand notches!
I had to compare to my other newer Smiths to see what was wrong, then, I had to modify one corner of each ratchet notch to match my other guns. Then it worked fine!
Although my cylinder was correctly reamed to chamber 44 Spls. which I already knew, having used it in my 296. But I had used the original star from the 296 cylinder so I didn't discover the 44 ratchet problem until just today.
Thanks for that additional info!
Last edited: