New..Don't own a handgun .. wish to hunt deer

Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Location
Canandaigua, New York
My closest hunting possibilities allow shotguns, muzzleloaders or handguns; and I did get a deer with the muzzleloader. Don't want to use a shotgun, but would like to use a pistol during the shooting season.

I had planned to buy a .22 S&W for economical practice, but thought about it and realized that I could buy a lot of practice rounds in .38 or .44 special and just buy one quality revolver. My thinking that I could 1000 rounds of .38 special for about $350, considerably less than I am thinking about spending on the .22.

My Internet researches and gun shop conversations have pointed me to a S&W 686 in .357 magnum.

Let me add that my only shooting experience with a handgun is three times over forty years with 1911 Colt, and I am an athletic and healthy 200 pound, six-one, sixty-three year old.

Does it seem reasonable to buy just that one handgun for practice and the deer hunting? I've got a couple more months to think likely as I wait for my permit in Canandaigua, New York.
 
Register to hide this ad
the 686 is a great 357mag.with proper shot placement it should be o.k.for deer...were it me...i would use the 657,41 magnum...drawback to this caliber is...unless you reload ammo it can get way pricey....welcome to the forum and keep us posted!merry christmas!
 
Hello 2Lloyd & a big WELCOME ABOARD from Michigan!!

There is nothing unreasonable about practiceing with the same handgun you would be hunting with, in fact it would be highly recommended.

By doing it that way you should be fully aware of how it shoots with different brands of ammunition & bullet weights. There can be quite a bit of varieation along these lines.
 
Welcome from Texas 2Lloyd. Great forum for all things S&W, have fun, learn lots, share what you know.

My choice would be the Model 29 or variation thereof. My opinion, the .357 is marginal for deer. It can be done, but all the planets need to be aligned just so.
 
Back
Top