This is an old thread, but a fun one. I would have to go with what a member requested earlier. I have a 44 special model 696. For those who aren't aware, it is an 'L' frame, 3", five round, ss, with round butt and factory Uncle Mike's combat grips. It fits the hand like no other, is compact enough to slip in your pants (not for extended carry), and the grip is arguably the best rubber grip ever. I wish for the same identical gun with a 5" barrel. IMO it would be the perfect 'modern' 44 special. With the current popularity of the 44 special, regardless of what Mike Venturino says, I am surprised Smith has not renewed its production. I realize 'light' is in with CCW permit holders, but as a shooter, it would be superior.