What do you think? The 686 came with rubbers which I didn't care for. I like the combats a lot better. The combats came on a 17-6 that I didn't care for, so it went down the road wearing rubbers. I bought the holster for a 6" 29-2, but after some thought, probably never would carry the 29. El Paso Saddlery just gets some things right! The holster fits the N frame and L frame both pretty well. Click on the photo to enlarge.