Kinda depends on what your end use is.... the comp II is a good choice for speed, durability and tactile feel. But they are hard plastic/polymer and, unless carried in a speed pouch, are bulky in the pocket. The speed strips are easy to carry in the pocket but are much slower to reload the revolver.....and rounds can come out of the strip if they are subject to any really rough handling. I carry a Model 66 2 1/2” off duty and carry 2 Comp II loaders as reloads. I would rather have the speed in reloading rather than some minor convenience in carry. I carry in a Bianchi IWB Pocket Pistol pouch (I think that is what it’s called). Very concealable and fast if needed. It has a very thumb break retaining strap. I like it over all other concealable carry holsters. It has worked for me for many, many years. Hope this helps.