Plowed up relic. Real or toy?

Joined
Apr 17, 2019
Messages
246
Reaction score
874
Location
Indiana
This was turned up in a plow furrow probably around '67 or '68. When Dad was plowing, I used to walk behind the tractor and look for arrowheads. I had found a beautiful large one there a year or so earlier so I always looked closely in that part of the field. I remember having to use my pocketknife to free this from the furrow. I showed it to my Dad and he said it was probably a toy gun that some kid had lost years ago. It was hung up on a nail in an old tool shed and remained there for almost fifty years.
A few years back I was looking for my grandfather's old corn sheller when I saw the gun and looked at it real closely for the first time.
The first thing you notice is that obviously non standard machine screw in the barrel pivot. That, and the need to finish plowing, is probably why my Dad dismissed it as a toy years ago. But some features make me think it may have been a real top-break revolver.
The good:
It has what appears to be the latch at the top of the frame.
It has a slot in the bottom of the grip frame for a hammer spring.
It has a trigger and the stub of a hammer.
The five shot cylinder has flutes.
It appears to be chambered for a .38. (A .38 S&W seemed to be the closest fit to the end of one of the chambers that I was able to somewhat clean out. A .32 was too small.)
The only picture I found on the internet of a toy top break looked nothing like this.

The not so good:
As it is, the gun weighs 13.1 oz. Even accounting for metal loss due to rust, that seems a bit light for a revolver.
The barrel has a narrow rib on the top but no front sight. The barrel does show signs of damage at the end and may have originally been longer.
That big stainless steel screw!

Two of the cylinders appear to be empty but I can't be sure about the others. If ammunition were present it's likely inert after all this time but until that can be determined, it's treated with respect like any other gun.

The spot in the field where this was found was about forty feet from an old county road that was abandoned when the state highway was built in the late thirties. It's possible someone could have thrown it from a car or a buggy but that's only conjecture.

There's a lot of knowledgeable folks on this forum and we all love a mystery so what do you think?
 

Attachments

  • DDE8A00A-B77B-44E6-BA61-15C8AF6DF238.jpg
    DDE8A00A-B77B-44E6-BA61-15C8AF6DF238.jpg
    50.3 KB · Views: 953
  • 25AFD5CE-8728-4933-89B6-AAE4ED32A987.jpg
    25AFD5CE-8728-4933-89B6-AAE4ED32A987.jpg
    48.2 KB · Views: 794
  • 55622210-5D0A-4397-9CD5-264555468FCA.jpg
    55622210-5D0A-4397-9CD5-264555468FCA.jpg
    49.9 KB · Views: 756
  • 044C5940-E074-4DBA-97EA-60765D80FA7A.jpg
    044C5940-E074-4DBA-97EA-60765D80FA7A.jpg
    21 KB · Views: 636
  • 822D1AFD-AAB9-431E-9FD9-D885FC83D951.jpg
    822D1AFD-AAB9-431E-9FD9-D885FC83D951.jpg
    42.5 KB · Views: 640
Register to hide this ad
I'm going to assume that it's real, and here's why...Rust. Most toy guns were made of zinc or some other cheap non-ferrous alloy, whereas this is clearly made of a ferrous metal like iron or steel. Older toy guns were typically made of wood.

The screw is most likely just a quick and easy replacement for the original screw which may have been lost or damaged. (Bubba can trace his ancestry straight back to the Mayflower, and came from a long line of amateur kitchen gunsmiths.)

I presume that the gun was discarded in a ditch either because it was discarded evidence used in a crime of some sort. A firearm that had accidentally fallen from a carriage or something would have been recovered by the owner or found by someone much sooner. That gun was most likely deliberately buried so that it wouldn't be found.

Granted that is all purely theoretical conjecture on my part, but it's just too corroded/degraded for anyone to be 100% sure of what it is they're looking at.
 
Given the degree of corrosion, even if this was a hot firearm, I don't think there is now any way of linking it to a crime. I think it is real, it might still be loaded. Soaking it in automatic transmission fluid is a good idea.
 
Check for loaded!

Just thinking out loud, once you identify it... the gun plus a reasonable estimate for ground time before you plowed it up gives you a time window... ask LE or scan old local papers for a shooting with that caliber in that time frame... is your road an old route leading from any old major city?

This hinge screw looks rather non-corroded for a ground gun.

I'd also check with previous owners of the land; is there a story about gr-grandpa losing his gun in the field while plowing? Fell out of his pocket and stepped on? Probably a long shot.

Cool story however it turns out! I'll be interested to see the post-soak version.
 
Last edited:
I would say it's a real gun, the shape of the frame looks a lot like an Iver Johnson or an H&R hammerless model. The fact that the trigger is all the way back indicates it likely went into the ground with a broken trigger spring. Those guns were double action only and the trigger goes forward as soon as pressure is released. Also the odd screw indicates it may have had other issues.

It's possible the gun was discarded as broken and useless by whoever had it back then. Another possibility is that someone turned a broken gun into a toy for their kid to play with. Who later lost it..... To modern folk that might seem strange but I have known of several cases of just that happening in the old days. I have personally handled a number of "family guns" that older family members recalled using as toys for years. Some were just broken, some deliberately "fixed" so they were safe (though one old muzzle loading shotgun turned out to have a load in it, with the nipple hammered flat it wasn't likely to go off though!).

If it was a "crime gun" it likely was discarded because the trigger spring broke, whether it was used to shoot anyone or not.............. Overall condition says it was a long, long time ago. Not likely to be of any use for forensic examination at this point. Just an interesting old relic now
 
Looks like a Meriden Arms Company top break hammerless. They made firearms for many different distributors with various brand names. One brand name was Eastern Arms sold by Sears Roebuck and Company.
 
It sure would be cool to know the story behind that gun. If it was used in a crime, tossed from a car, or just dropped from somebody's pants as they walked through the field.
 
My old college room mates dad plowed up an Indian grave that was lined with slate. They looked at it, then covered it up and didn't tell too many people about it.
Your story reminded me of that.
 
Last edited:
My best bet.

Chicago arms.

attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • 13064764_1.jpg
    13064764_1.jpg
    37.9 KB · Views: 803
Back
Top