Reading is dangerous

Joined
Nov 16, 2009
Messages
11,830
Reaction score
18,101
Location
Republic of Texas
Because reading leads to thinking.
Anyway, I was reading the latest "Shooting Illustrated" and there was an article about a new EAA 1911 gun. It's different from the 10,000 other 1911s out there in that the frame is polymer.

I haven't read the whole article yet, but it got me to thinking about the possibilities of polymer framed 3rd Gens.

Other than the pesky fact, that S&W has no interest in making them, why not?

Making a polymer frame 3rd Gen removes one of the arguments about the machining costs of 3rd Gen frames. The upper assemblies on M&Ps and Glocks still have to be machined, so there's not cost different in that part of the gun.

Just a random thought after reading about the polymer framed 1911. Which I'm sure that 1911 purists will absolutely hate.
 
Register to hide this ad
Speaking purely from an aesthetics point of view... yuck!

I suppose you COULD make a polymer framed anything. We've seen the EAA Witness series have both metal and polymer, recently.
 
If I remember, (?), twenty years or more ago, there was a
company making polymer framed 1911's. Maybe STI, (?), they
were expensive, but I guess worked well.
Anyway, I like it when you read. Something to think about, right?
 
If I remember, (?), twenty years or more ago, there was a
company making polymer framed 1911's. Maybe STI, (?), they
were expensive, but I guess worked well.
Anyway, I like it when you read. Something to think about, right?
Kimber

Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk
 
... And Wilson Combat (KZ-45), and Rock River...

Sent from my Note 5, which thinks it can spell better than I can...
 
the mention of polymer framed 3rd. gens. came up in a thread some time back I recall....I for one touted the prospects of a poly frame 4513 TDA with all the usual attributes but just a poly frame;)...since such a weapon will never be made by S&W....the closest I could come up with was an HK 45c....poly frame,hammer instead of a horrid striker, and slide mounted safety/decocker:D
 
Speaking purely from an aesthetics point of view... yuck!
Yeah, this idea is a non-starter. :o The simple truth is that plastic gun design & engineering... whether you like the guns or not... has taken its own separate path and there is little or nothing to gain by trying to make S&W or any other manufacturer "go retro" in plastic. :o Business decision-wise, I think it would be a disaster.

As has been stated before, the M&Ps are the best S&W could do with semi-automatic pistols in plastic. Like it or not, they are our "4th Gen" S&W pistols... well, that's if you don't count the Sigma/SD and SW99 lines, of course. ;)

All-metal or plastic... take your pick. I have plenty of both. But do I want to see a classic all-metal pistol remade in plastic? Nope. It does nothing for me. :cool:
 
I just spent a second trying to imagine a polymer Browning High Power. After an involuntary shudder, yeah, I agree: some things should be left to exist only in metal.
 
Metal-frame handguns, to me, are still examples of craftsmanship. Something you fiddle with to admire the precise machining, something you painstakingly care for the finish and consider refinishing (or, conversely, admire the smooth wear it develops over time and use). A family heirloom, or an example of a foreign industry.

A plastic gun is a soulless tool.
 
Back
Top