Resizing New Brass

ColColt

Member
Joined
May 2, 2010
Messages
1,304
Reaction score
289
Location
TN
It's always been a practice of mine to resize new brass but I don't know just how necessary that is. I recently bought some new brass(Starline) and figured why break the habit? I measured the top part of the case and the middle of a few just as they came out of the package and they pretty much(within .0005") were the same measurement as after I resized them.

Does anyone do this but me and is it really necessary in light of the aforementioned measurements?
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
When I first bought new brass for reloading I ran a few through the sizing die and they went in and came out so easily with no indication they where worked that I didn't do it any more. Haven't had any issues with unsized new brass in over 30 years of reloading. The only thing I do is inspect them, chamfer the case mouth to knock off the sharp edges, and resize only the occasional one that has a visible neck or case mouth dent or out of round.
 
It is a good precaution to take. If the cases, or case necks on a bottle neck, are a little out of square your sizing die should straighten them out. I think it is more of a thing to insure consistency rather than safey.
 
This batch of brass may be fine, the next, not so much.

EVERYTHING made by man has tolerances. This week, it is all at the top, next week, all at the bottom, the next week, from one end to the other, next week, smack dab in the middle.

So, the reason I resize is because my die is the same size every time. That way my rounds are consistent and as consistent as this fallible human can make them!

Resize them, you would if they were used brass.
 
I guess I'll carry on. It's no big deal to resize just takes a bit more time...maybe 8-10 minutes per 50? It couldn't hurt anything.

I have about 100 rounds I bought some years back of primed Winchester brass. Of course, you can't resize them and destroy the primer so, I've yet to use them yet. Moreover, that could prove dangerous knocking out a live primer. They have the red sealant around the primer as well. They're still good I'm sure as primers last nearly indefinitely if stored properly.
 
resizing new brass

Pull the decapping pin and rod out and then size the primed brass. works great. I always size new brass just to make sure every thing is true.

snoopdawg45
 
It doesn't cost a thing to run new brass through the sizer. In fact, I reccomend it, as every batch of new brass I have ever bought has had at least a few cases out of round.
 
Good idea, snoop. See what happens when you get old? You forget things you use to do decades ago. I've done that in the past but didn't think of it this time. It's probably ok as is but for safe measures it's a good idea.
 
I find several with out of round case mouths in new brass, and like to run them all through the resizing die. You know what you've got that way. I also like to trim them, or spin them with the trimmer if they don't need trimming. I like for all of my ammo to be as close to the same as the others as I can get them, within reason of course.
 
I use a turret press, so every case, new or used, gets resized since not resizing would disrupt my rhythm. ;)

FWIW & YMMV - On the rare occasions I've deprimed cases with live primers, I've soaked them in a water based washing solution and deprimed them wet using a universal depriming die in a single stage press. (Damp rather than dripping wet and without a sizing mechanism in the die, there is some blow-by space.)

Long story short: Back in my early bottomfeeder days I "inherited" a bucket of primed .45acp cases and loaded a few.
They must have not been stored properly since I got 3 FTF out of the first 7 and I recovered the powder and bullets from the rest of the 50 I had loaded.

Not wanting to take the risk of depriming live primers and not knowing a good way to dispose of them safely, the cases lurked in my reloading stuff until I watched a documentary on the manufacture of rimfire cartridges. They load the primer material wet and then let it dry thoroughly before adding powder and bullet.

Using reverse engineering logic, I soaked a few primed cases in water with some dishwashing detergent added to reduce the surface tension of the water so if it would soak into the primer material better. I let them soak overnight and very carefully and slowly deprimed them.
Nothing went bang, so I eventually deprimed the rest of them that way.

Whether the primer material being wet or being very slow and gentle kept them from going off, I'm not sure.
But I am pretty sure that getting the primers wet doesn't make the dangerous process any more dangerous.

Keep safe, whatever you do,
John
 
I find several with out of round case mouths in new brass, and like to run them all through the resizing die. You know what you've got that way. I also like to trim them, or spin them with the trimmer if they don't need trimming. I like for all of my ammo to be as close to the same as the others as I can get them, within reason of course.

+1 Out of round case necks are common and I always size new cases. Ditto on trimming to length although I sometimes wait until after they have been fired once. I can't remember ever having to trim revolver cases because of stretching. It is something that helps keep everything uniform and contributes to consistent crimping.
 
Always full length resize rifle brass especially and normally will do pistol brass. When working up a supply of new Winchester 243 brass (400 rounds) there were "several" cases with split/overlapped case necks. One with no flash hole, several with body dents, etc. My normal procedure is to full length resize, then trim, then champfer & de-burr, then uniform the primer pocket. Only then do I load it.
 
Does Winchester or Remington or Hornady resize their brass before loading it?
I don't know, but I'd be real surprised if they don't. I imagine they also bell the case mouths as well, because the new brass you buy isn't belled. It could be that the new brass you buy isn't made in exactly the same fashion as the brass they use for new ammunition. Interesting question. I'd like to know as well.
 
Back
Top