S & W 945 vs Colt Gold Cup National Match 70 series

The 945 is a niche gun these days largely due to magazine and parts availability. At $2,300 I would likely pass unless I was wealthy or absolutely needed it to complete a collection or lifetime dream. Regardless, they are fantastic shooters and as mentioned above, boringly accurate. Here's a short video of mine.


Smith and Wesson 945 - YouTube
 
Regardless whether they sell for $1300 or $2300, they are still beautiful, very high quality firearms.

I'm fortunate enough to have four different models of the 945. I sure wish that I had purchased a few more spare magazines years ago.
 
What are your reasons for interest?

Cool factor? Pick the one that tickles your fancy. They're both quality.

Competition use? The GC no doubt. Entirely due to the Colt still having product support. The 945's a dead end in that regard.
 
Everyone, thank you for the replies. I already own the Gold Cup and saw the 945 in local store and was wondering how it compared. Never heard back on my offer, so I will keep looking.
 
IMHO the Gold Cup NM blows the 945 away! I have shot one in competition since 1990 and it is about the most accurate pistol I own!

Damn Chief, that's some excellent shooting. Thanks for the dime for perspective. I thought the grouping was larger from the first photo.
 
Last edited:
I've never shot a 945, but I am the original owner of a Series 70 Gold Cup. My observations are as follows: The GC trigger always left something to be desired. It has about 1/8" of take-up. While I like the wider target trigger, I could never find a replacement which the adjustable wings on the stirrup to eliminate the take-up. Many criticize the collet bushing as being prone to break. I never broke mine, but I did replace it and the barrel early on with a fitted barrel / solid bushing. Whichever barrel / bushing set up you use, the barrel throat needs to be ramped to reliability feed something other than hardball ammo. The recoil spring also needs to be replaced because the OEM is intended for light loads. The recoil will damage your receiver if you shoot higher velocity ammo. I replaced mine with a heavier spring and steel spring guide. I am indifferent about the target-style hammer, but it needs to be replaced if you want to install a beavertail grip safety. My original Patridge front sight fell off as it is only held with silver solder (ie: no pins). I replaced it with a ramped front sight. I do like the OEM flat mainspring over other Colt Government models. Finally, I replaced the thumb safety with an oversized one because the original is too small to operate quickly and reliability. That being said, I would never sell nor trade it.
 
I agree. You don't see many in competition, probably because of lack of parts and aftermarket support. 1911 components / parts are everywhere.

But as the OP ask, i believe the 945 will be more accurate out of the box than the Colt.


The 945s, like the 845s before are great shooting guns but the lack of any support, aftermarket or otherwise is going to really limit their appeal in competition circles.
 
I have long since lost round an exact round count however if I had to guess I'd say my 1974 Colt GCNM has at least 40,000 - 45,000 rounds through it. I have not replaced anything with the exception of the recoil spring a few times. In all those rounds I have never had any FTF or jams either.

The trigger pull comes in at a crisp 2 3/4 lbs. and will use any old magazines, even beat up GI mags.
 
Back
Top