Small wonder Sears is struggling to stay in business

Florida Guy

Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2011
Messages
1,548
Reaction score
1,140
Location
Fort Lauderdale, FL
I was recently made aware of how much of a rip off Sears prices are.
I compared 3 items in the automotive section and found this:
1). I recently bought a 5/16" open end wrench at Home Depot made by Husky for $2.49. It's equal at Sears was priced at $4.99. And the Husky looked nicer with its chrome plating compared to the dull finish on the Craftsman.
2). Meguire's car wash soap (64 oz.)... $4.00 at Target, and $5.49 at Sears.
3). Turtle Wax chrome polish: WalMart $2.27.... Sears $3.99

I don't think I'll buy anything at Sears without price shopping first. I can probably beat their prices anywhere.

Just my 2 cents.
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Advance Auto sells tools individually or in sets with the same lifetime warranty for much less. Sears became famous for their tools and warranty back when imported tools were junk, not the case anymore.
 
Prices can always be beat by shopping around. It's not just Sears, you can find the same thing in all stores. Sears doesn't try to compete with Target, Kohl's, Walmart and others like them, they depend on customer loyalty.
 
I haven’t shopped at Sears since I quit working in the Machining industry. The only thing I ever bought there was Craftsman Tools and now those are made in China.
 
I was recently made aware of how much of a rip off Sears prices are.
I compared 2 items in the automotive section and found this:
1). I recently bought a 5/16" open end wrench at Home Depot made by Husky for $2.49. It's equal at Sears was priced at $4.99. And the Husky looked nicer with its chrome plating compared to the dull finish on the Craftsman.
2). Maguire's car wash soap (64 oz.)... $4.00 at Target, and $4.99 at Sears.

I don't think I'll buy anything at Sears without price shopping first. I can probably beat their prices anywhere.

Just my 2 cents.

Craftsman Tools are NOT in the same class as Husky - at least to me. Craftsman is certainly NOT Snap-On, but they're a lot better than Husky and the Sears stuff is replaced 1,2,3 when broken or worn out at ANY Sears location without questions, hassles or receipts. To the best of my knowledge, the Craftsman hand tools for the most part (screwdrivers, sockets, wrenches, etc. ) are STILL made in the USA while I do not believe Husky is.
That is somewhat important to me.

Maquires Products like any other large selling products are always cheaper at the Big Box Discount Stores (Target, Costco, Wal-Mart, etc) - just a fact of life as they are in vogue now and buy in massive quantities. Sears and other older Retailers simply can't sell them for the same prices.

Stores like JC Penny, Sears, Macy's, blah blah blah are all doomed not JUST because of Costco, Target and Wal-Mart, but the Internet is where so many people shop now. Shopping on the internet is a whole different ball game. There are "store fronts" on line that sell all types of goods that operate from someone's Bed Room computer and they never even touch or see the goods they are selling. They simply get a small percentage of the selling price as a commission and go on their merry way. They have no employees, no over head, no liability or compensation or health insurance to pay, no light, heat or rent to pay and simply can beat out the big retailers. The goods you buy are drop shipped directly to you the buyer.

Somehow even though for 200 years we payed higher prices in the Sears, Penny's etc. type stores, people had jobs, everyone profited, and the store was usually there and stood behind their products when you needed them too.

Not saying you are right or wrong to stay out of Sears, but I am just voicing my opinion as I see it. It is what it is...........
 
Amazon is the new Sears.

And join the smiles program and they donate to a charity of your choice, for me it's the Second Amendment Foundation.

Sears does have a great replacement program on hand tools. No matter how old they replace it on the spot if it's in the store. Works great when you put a 6 foot pipe on a 1/4 ratchet or mess up that screwdriver. Plus they are everywhere.
 
Craftsman Tools are NOT in the same class as Husky - at least to me. Craftsman is certainly NOT Snap-On, but they're a lot better than Husky and the Sears stuff is replaced 1,2,3 when broken or worn out at ANY Sears location without questions, hassles or receipts. To the best of my knowledge, the Craftsman hand tools for the most part (screwdrivers, sockets, wrenches, etc. ) are STILL made in the USA

I don't think they are anymore. It came up in another thread
 
40 years ago everyone went to Sears.................

Stoves, dishwashers, dryers and washers, tools, tires, lube & oil and auto repairs............

I don't get there as much as I did but they still back their items better than any other store.
I just had a nightmare with RC Willey on my 80" tv..... trying to get it fixed !! After you pay them , you have no backing or support. They could not even get me a small "junker tv " to watch the super bowl !!
 
The last time I was in a Sears was about four years ago. I was looking for a basic electric kitchen range. They had one there on sale that I liked for $500 plus a $55 delivery fee. I bought the exact same range at Lowe's for $450 with free delivery and haul off of the old range. My 40+ year old Craftsman hand tools are great and I have a 27 year old Kenmore chest freezer that is still going strong, but Sears is not the first place I think of to buy things today.
 
I recently was looking for a small axe or boys axe for my BOB. I searched online and lo and behold I found one at Sears. My local store did not have any in stock, but I was able to order it online and they shipped it to my local store for free. About a week after placing the order, I got an email saying that I could go pick up my new axe.

Comparable axes were as much as $65-$150 at other locations. My new axe from Sears was $15.99. It has a smaller head more like a hatchet with a 24" hickory handle. Should be a great camp or BO axe and weighs much less than a full size axe.

Sears was once the original big box store offering a catalog filled with almost anything anyone could need. Other stores have now come along offering similar items, most made in China, so the competition is fierce.
 
I haven't been in Sears in ages and then it was for lawn tractor parts at an outlet. I used Craftsman tools at work for ages but went to Home Depot mainly for them later.
Sears lost it for me soon after they quit on their sporting goods department and I no longer had a reason to shop there. Too bad as I remember back when and enjoyed going there. I don't do malls either and the big one here is in one.
 
SEARS (AKA K-MART) is not what they were in years past-- there are better choices, almost everywhere. JMHO-- last thing I bought there was a riding mower, some 15 years ago-- when service was needed, I went back, which was the only reason I went there at all in the first place. They wouldn't service, and had not a clue-- and NO all tools are not guaranteed, if you read the fine print-- :rolleyes:
 
Sears and tires. 2 sets of tires from the same Sears Automotive store, 2 different results.

I put new rough tread 10.50x15 tires on my Jeep. It has replacement mags and had one set of tires on them with no slow leaks. All the new tires developed slow leaks, I would go back and sit for hours while they tried to fix one. On about the 4th trip I pulled the manager aside, I explained that growing up I had worked in a real gas station and have mounted many tires. One has to clean the rim on tubeless tires to get a good seal. I told him I was unimpressed with their service and they had better get it righjt or I'm calling Mr. Roebuck. He was a younger guy, in his mid 20's and in charge. He had a constant blank stare, he sure as the heck did not know who Roebuck was, I asked. I gave them my number, walked around the mall, bought some jelly beans, read all the hunting, fishing and Antique iron magazines in the book store and bought the tractor one. Went and ate at the food court. Sat in the middle watching mallers walk by, went and checked on the jeep. Finally took a nap in a corner of the Sears Auto lobby. Around 5 PM they called. In a week I found 2 of the tires still had slow leaks. I took them to a "Tire Shop" and they fixed them, I could look through the window and see them clean off the rims, Sears said I could not go in the back due to insurance....

A few weeks later the other 2 had lost air, I put a can of green slime in them. One of these has a slow leak that needs aired up every month or so. This set of Sears tires has been the biggest pain in the rear of all the tires I have owned.

At the same time frame I had the same Sears shop put on a new set of Michlen 6 plys on my Super Duty. Not one issue, not one slow leak. Balanced right and wear right. It too has Mag wheels. My thought is a different guy mounted these.

But, the Sears store never made it right on the Jeep. We've bought several sets of tires for other vehicles since, elsewhere of course.

Part of the higher cost for tools is to defray the cost of the it's guaranteed for life replacement policy. You pay upfront. You didn't think Sears was really going to pay, right?

I too miss the old Sears and Roebuck, JC Penny's and Montgomery Ward.
Like Turnerriver says, it was a place to look at guns and buy ammo.

For you younger gents the old catalogs had guns, ammo, fishing gear, sporting equipment, Outboard motors and camping gear. How many on here instantly went to the gun section? Like an old Herters catalog it was a dream land of goodies.
 
Sears and tires. 2 sets of tires from the same Sears Automotive store, 2 different results.

I put new rough tread 10.50x15 tires on my Jeep. It has replacement mags and had one set of tires on them with no slow leaks. All the new tires developed slow leaks, I would go back and sit for hours while they tried to fix one. On about the 4th trip I pulled the manager aside, I explained that growing up I had worked in a real gas station and have mounted many tires. One has to clean the rim on tubeless tires to get a good seal. I told him I was unimpressed with their service and they had better get it righjt or I'm calling Mr. Roebuck. He was a younger guy, in his mid 20's and in charge. He had a constant blank stare, he sure as the heck did not know who Roebuck was, I asked. I gave them my number, walked around the mall, bought some jelly beans, read all the hunting, fishing and Antique iron magazines in the book store and bought the tractor one. Went and ate at the food court. Sat in the middle watching mallers walk by, went and checked on the jeep. Finally took a nap in a corner of the Sears Auto lobby. Around 5 PM they called. In a week I found 2 of the tires still had slow leaks. I took them to a "Tire Shop" and they fixed them, I could look through the window and see them clean off the rims, Sears said I could not go in the back due to insurance....

A few weeks later the other 2 had lost air, I put a can of green slime in them. One of these has a slow leak that needs aired up every month or so. This set of Sears tires has been the biggest pain in the rear of all the tires I have owned.

At the same time frame I had the same Sears shop put on a new set of Michlen 6 plys on my Super Duty. Not one issue, not one slow leak. Balanced right and wear right. It too has Mag wheels. My thought is a different guy mounted these.

But, the Sears store never made it right on the Jeep. We've bought several sets of tires for other vehicles since, elsewhere of course.

Part of the higher cost for tools is to defray the cost of the it's guaranteed for life replacement policy. You pay upfront. You didn't think Sears was really going to pay, right?

I too miss the old Sears and Roebuck, JC Penny's and Montgomery Ward.
Like Turnerriver says, it was a place to look at guns and buy ammo.

For you younger gents the old catalogs had guns, ammo, fishing gear, sporting equipment, Outboard motors and camping gear. How many on here instantly went to the gun section? Like an old Herters catalog it was a dream land of goodies.

YEP-- THOSE WERE THE DAYS-- :)
 
Back
Top