The quest for a holster--advice from a new guy

Joined
Mar 17, 2013
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
After a grueling month long search for a holster, I thought I would offer some advice to any first-time holster buyer.

Buy a proper belt. Before you even attempt to try on a holster, you should be wearing the right type of belt. I probably returned 3 or 4 good holsters, not realizing that it wasn't the holster, but the belt that was the culprit.

Keep in mind that I had a leather "gun belt" all along. However, this particular brand was too thick and too heavy. You don't want something too heavy. You want a belt that is strong and rigid, but not heavy. On thickness--not too thick but not too thin. Thickness is important for the effectiveness of the clip on a clip-type holster. Also, a too thick belt may keep some OWB holsters from cinching in close to the body. Finally, I think the wider the better. However, it obviously should not be too wide for the slots, snaps, or the clips on the holster. In my case a 1.25 inch was not enough.

My solution was a wider, lighter, and thinner belt that is also very rigid and strong--characteristics I found in a heavy duty NYLON belt. A belt made by 5.11 Tactical--the heavier duty version, the cheaper version (the TDU) is too thin, and the holster won't stay clipped if given a good enough tug. The Wilderness company is another nylon belt manufacturer.

Obviously leather belts are fine, but if I was was going to replace my nylon belt with a leather one, I would want it to be fairly light and not super-thick. Anyway, I turned what felt like a heavy awkward holster into one that I barely notice is there by changing to a different belt.

Again, this is what worked for me. I do not claim to be an expert on this matter, as I just settled on my first ever holster today.
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
My solution was a wide, light, and thin belt that is also very rigid and strong. The answer for me was a heavy duty NYLON belt. A 5.11 1.75" TDU belt from Gander Mountain for 15 bucks.

I dislike those belts. I find it very difficult to fit the belt through the slots of many pancake holsters. They are also very ugly and look like gun belts. They are not "low profile" at all. Instead, I choose to use a kydex reinforced leather belt from Comp-Tac. I have standardized on 1 1/2" wide, but they offer 1 1/4" and 1 3/4" wide belts.
 
I agree, they are too tactical looking, but I wear my shirts out. No one will see the belt.
 
I found that a black, nine ounce leather NRA belt with a basketweave pattern holds my 442 in a homemade holster up just fine and looks good doing it.
 
Last edited:
Update.

I had to edit my original post. I changed it, and it now has me recommending the more expensive thicker version of the 5.11 belt. The cheaper TDU belt proved to be a little too thin. Although the holster felt great with the cheaper TDU belt, I found that when I positioned the holster behind the hip (4-430) the clip would break free of the belt if I gave it a decent tug.

My apologies. So, in the end, what I learned was that SUPER-thick, heavy, and narrow does not make a good combination, but at the same time you do not want a belt that is too thin. Also, I found that 1.75" is pushing it for my clip. 1.5" might be the optimum width.

I guess there is a happy medium in there somewhere. Something like that. :)
 
Last edited:
Haven't tried it yet as my holster is on order and hasn't arrived yet, but I bought a leather belt made by Carhartt. It's all leather and 1 1/2 inches wide, will be using it on a Desanti leather belt holster for my M&P 45. Cost was $29, plus tax.
 
I have found that OWB & IWB have entirely different belt requirements. Also, the body shape of the individual has a lot to do with how a holster fits, and the belt may sometimes be relevant to this.

IWB, I have found that any belt that fastens in front will work. Of course, I use Summer Specials, so the holster doesn't have much trouble staying in place. Pants will affect this more than a belt will.

OWB, stiffness (which usually comes from thickness, I think) counts A LOT. It may also help even without a holster. thebeltman.net offers stiff holsters that don't look like gunbelts, and I had minor back problems go away when I started using one.
 
Yep, type of holster/carry can make a big difference. I have a reasonably sturdy Dickies leather belt from Wally World. Bought it prior to getting my CC permit. Paid something like $10 for it. I carry my compact 9mm in a small Tagua leather holster IWB. I cannot pull the holster off the belt without releasing the clip. I cannot imagine a sturdier belt would make any difference in how the weapon feels or rides. If I were carrying OWB, I'm not sure this belt would be appropriate.

The finish on this belt is starting to suffer after a year of hard use, and I will be replacing it in the near future. Not sure what I will end up getting, but may just get a sturdy "normal" belt. I will stay away from the finishes that look more like they were sprayed on, rather than a dye. The clips and holster wear appears to do a number on the former type of finish. Iwould imagine the dye type of finish can probably be successfully touched up.
 
Got my ancient digital camera working, The belt is an inch and a half wide NRA belt with one of my homemade molded leather holsters. This combination is very comfortable for everyday wear.
 

Attachments

  • Belt.jpg
    Belt.jpg
    37.1 KB · Views: 40
I use a 1.5 inch LL Bean sturdy brown-dyed "one piece monotone" leather belt, pretty much every day for everything. Winter carhartts, summer carhartts, construction for 6 years, rolling under the cars, pouring concrete. Cost me $30 on sale at the store, best $30 I have ever spent.
 
I prefer a belt that does NOT look like a gun-belt and so I use a Kramer Horsehide 1 1/4" belt with a dress style gold buckle. From the front it does not scream "gun-belt" and is small enough to fit all my pants and jeans, but it is more than stiff enough for proper holster support because it is made out of very stiff Horsehide leather.

I personally hate the 1 1/2" to 1 3/4" belts that LOOK LIKE they are just what they are and also dislike the basket weave belts or models that have stitching in a fancy stitch patterns. To me it just screams "GUN-BELT". The whole idea is to look normal and not stand out as a person carrying a weapon. I also associate the basket weave and pattern stitched belts with off-duty LEO's and so I like my belts to look as inconspicuous as possible while doing the job I need them to do.
 
What exactly is an "NRA Belt"? It looks like a regular old basketweave police duty garrison belt. How much did it cost?
 
What exactly is an "NRA Belt"? It looks like a regular old basketweave police duty garrison belt. How much did it cost?
I wanted a nine ounce leather, one and a half inch wide, black basketweave belt. I found just what I was looking for at NRAstore.com for less than half of what it would have cost for me to get the stamps to make one. It's twenty four dollars and ninety five cents plus shipping. The final price was around thirty one dollars.
http://www.nrastore.com/nrastore/ProductDetail.aspx?c=1&p=CM 331
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top