I bought one new when they came out and unfortunately it was a nightmare. I sent it to Smith twice and an independent gunsmith another time. I changed springs, replaced the barrel, ejector, extractor and used 4 different factory mags with no luck.
I kept it spotlessly clean and oiled but no matter what ammo I fed it it would stovepipe about every 3rd round, fail to eject and feed a second round over the spent case
in the chamber and if it did eject it would just just barely get the casing out of the gun. If I wore a long sleeve shirt, it often ejected the hot case into my sleeve cuff. It was rare that I could fire a 12 roubd magazine without a failure.
I know a lot of people that love theirs and the idea was great but my particular one was a lemon. So I traded it and a Ruger Bearcat for an excellent condition Winchester 62A. No regrets.
As far as Ruger, I've owned 2 first gen, 2 2nd gen and 1 4th gen and never had a problem.
I also own a Smith Victory tricked out. It had its issues too after about 700 rounds and stopped ejecting. I sent it to Smith and no luck with it when it was returned. Meanwhile I found the fix on line, slightly bending the ejector, and have had 100% reliability since. Since bending the ejector I've probably put 3500 rounds through it and no failures to feed or eject.
Id rank the Victory and Ruger equally. Both are excellent.
Edit: I inherited my uncles Browning Challenger II and shot it a few times. While it was a good pistol I just didn't warm up to it and traded it. No issues, just not excited about it.