I'm on the other side of the fence with Top Shot. I absolutely love it.
I like Colby (he's a big pro-gun guy and a shooter since he was a kid) and I like the way he calls the action. If he wasn't there, you wouldn't even know what was going on. I like his jabs that get the competitors' blood boiling ("Jay! Misses! AGAIN! He hasn't hit a single target yet!"
I've watched coverage of other shooting events (SASS, American Shooter, FN 3 Gun) and despite my enthusiasm for shooting (it's the biggest part of my life next to family), I find myself fast forwarding due to boredom.
While I don't like the attitude and behavior of some of the participants on Top Shot, I do like the "drama." If everyone on the show just shot and there was no interaction, you couldn't find someone to root for. Or against.
The fun of the show is how much I like or hate someone.
I still feel bad for Tara on Season One because she had to leave because of her dad's illness (and he passed away before she could make it home). She never missed a shot and she kept herself out of the drama and was well liked by everyone in the house. I think she would have been hard to beat. Rooting for a Marine and Police Officer and one of the nicest people you could ever meet (I met her a few times when the show was airing) was wonderful.
Iain is also one of the greatest guys you could ever meet. His backstory on leaving England for the US because of the UK's stupid and ridiculous gun laws makes him a guy to look up to. He's also extremely personable and smart.
I just hope that this season's competitors learned from last season that the nice guys and girls who shoot well may not win, but they can get some good contracts in the shooting industry that will pay them well. The jerks don't get anything. (Although I think the 3rd Season was filming while the 2nd Season was still airing, I'm not sure.)
I look forward to tomorrow's first episode! The show has portrayed the shooting sports, the history of firearms, and the competition in a 100% positive manner. It has brought untold numbers of non-shooters into our fold.