Trade a K-31 for a Marlin Guide Gun - y/n?&what about this other straight pull M95...

GatorFarmer

Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2003
Messages
5,332
Reaction score
3,887
Location
Sheridan, Wyoming
Trade a K-31 for a Marlin Guide Gun - y/n?&what about this other straight pull M95...

So... I ended up with an instant collection of milslurps again. A friend of mine is a Marine armorer and is laid up from a leg surgery. He's long wanted a customized Ruger single action that I have (with S. African buffalo horn grips), but never had anything to trade for it.

Anyway, since he won't be riding it for a while, he traded his old dirt bike for someone's else assortment of old rifles. Which I then ended up with in trade for the Ruger (since he can at least shoot a handgun while he heals up).

I ended up with an Albanian SKS, a Budapest made M95 carbine in 8x56R with 20rds on chargers (old Nazi marked ammo), and a rather nice Swiss K-31 with 50rds of Swiss surplus.

Having no use for any of these really, I promptly asked another friend if he wanted an Albanian SKS (I knew that he had had one before.) Found that a home. Then talking it over we discussed trading my Swiss rifle and its ammo for his unfired, unused .45-70 Guide Gun (which I'd never use either probably, but it amuses my wife to have a big bore owing to her fear of large man eating feral hogs...).

I never paid any attention to these rifles when they were more commonly to be had. I already checked and mine lacks the ID paper under the buttplate. This one actually has nice wood, I understand most do not, and the metal and bore are pristine.

I don't really want another oddball caliber, but I have to admit that the rifle does balance well and I know that they have a reputation for accuracy.

Is the K-31 something that is worth hanging on to and stocking another caliber, or should I just turn it into a fine piece of protection from errant man eating hogs? (I've come close to buying a Guide Gun several times, and this one is the easier to find .45-70 chambering.)

Yeah I don't know what to do with the Budapest made 95 straight pull carbine either. The wood was refinished at the arsenal, it has the "other" kind of rear sight - the one not in meters but in shritts or whatever it is - that the Bulgarians liked. Does anyone even make a scope mount for these? I know that Prvi sells the ammo under their own name, and Hornady also sells it. Ergonomics on it make my Carcanos seem refined though. My first thought was to have it Duracoated black, stick a flashhider on it, and try to rig up some kind of scout mount to which I'd attach one of the cheap (but supposedly functional) Centerpoint red dots from Wallyworld. (Oh, and a recoil pad. Yeah, I had one of these before...)
 
Register to hide this ad
You really, really want to keep the Guide Gun. You have a rifle there that will stop, properly loaded, anything on this continent. It can also be loaded down and be really fun to shoot.
 
That's a hard call! I have a K31. I load for it. It is extremely accurate. I really like it.
But, I also like 45/70 and the Marlin is a neat gun.
Currently the Marlin is probably worth about half again as much as the Swiss, but IMHO nice K31's are going to continue to appreciate. (They've gone up from the $90 I paid for mine several years ago to around $250-300 currently) I don't know if the Guide Gun will gain except in the very long run.
Glad I don't have to make the decision..:D

BTW, I've owned several of the M95's. They're a clunk, the action is stiff, the recoil is unpleasant and are in no way comparable to the K31.
 
Make the trade for the Marlin 45-70, especially now that the Marlin Factory is having so many problems!! The rifle will only go up in value.
 
I've shot some of that Nazi marked 8X56R in my M 95s. It is good stuff, but corrosive, so clean accordingly. The recoil in that light carbine isn't gentle, either. If you reload, be aware that the groove diameter is around .329", not .323".

Many of the carbines are cut-down rifles. The cut down rifles have the front sight on a band, while on the original carbines, the front sight is on a little ramp. Many of the cut down rifles have the long rifle rear sight, too. There are a jillion varieties of those things, too; interesting collectibles.
 
Last edited:
I love K31s. They are the finest military bolt gun ever made, IMHO. The scoped one I have is easily as accurate as my .308 heavy barreled Howa.
 
Back
Top