A few of my gun nut Buddies and myself came to a realization over many years of trading and selling.
GENERALLY...Commemorative means; LOSE MONEY.
IMHO your into a commemorative the best possible way...it was free. Keep it and be happy with it.
Frank237,
The problem here is that you do not understand the purpose of a commemorative. As you state, you and your gun nut buddies do "trading and selling" you made no comment on collecting.
It sounds like you are looking at a commemorative purchase and figuring out how much money you can make on it.
As a collector, I never look at a purchase and say to myself, "Can I make money selling this if I pay his price?" That is because I have no intention of selling it. I want to collect it, I want to preserve it, I want to protect it. Now that does not mean I over pay just because it is a bit embellished. I admit there are a few that I paid a premium for, but not many.
I own MANY, many commemorative firearms at this moment. Each and every one can be sold for more than I paid for them. Some for considerably more. That is because it has been 5 - 10 - 15 - 20 - 25 or more years since they were purchased. However I do not primarily use my commemoratives as a method to make money. No serious collector does.
I use commemoratives as displays, I use them to spark conversations, I use them to catch the eye of the non-shooter or the young person that has a fascination. I use them to promote the shooting heritage of our nation. I use them to teach. I use them to share a passion with my fellow collectors. Occasionally I even loan them out for display. Most importantly I use them for my own enjoyment of the artistry of arms.
Both my home study and my office have several commemoratives on display at all times. Even lefty liberals visiting my office will often start up conversations about the pieces and/or the events or organizations commemorated. Sometimes they will just ask "Is that real?" All of these are openings to educate someone.
On multiple occasions, my commemoratives have created a situation where I was able to get a lefty liberal or two over to the range "to see what target shooting was all about." There are now several gun owning lefties that are no longer so liberal.
To me, that alone is priceless.