What should go??

[PackN]

I know I will get flack from most of you BUT I have 3 .357's and would like to keep one! Which one wins?? Thanks for all advice!!

4 screw 5" Model 27
5 screw 6" Pre-27
NYSP Model 28-2

PackN

 

[PackN]

I know I will get flack from most of you BUT I have 3 .357's and would like to keep one! Which one wins?? Thanks for all advice!!

4 screw 5" Model 27
5 screw 6" Pre-27
NYSP Model 28-2

PackN

 

[july1952]

I would keep the 5" model 27.

 

[kwbikr]

Keep them all but use the 28-2 and the pre-27 to defend the 5" 27 to the death...

 

[whitecoyote]

Originally posted by july1952:
I would keep the 5" model 27.

I agree with Tim.

 

[yugolovr]

Keep the 5 inch model 27.

 

[HEADKNOCKER]

We need Pics Mike

Just from the List I'd pick the 4 Screw 5" Model 27 too.. The Odd barrel Lenth would be the main reason..
Enjoy!!

 

[Vanman]

I've always lusted after a 5" Mod 27 that I could shoot.

 

[PackN]

Headknocker

You know I am so antiquate my camera has a Floopy Disc!!

 

[Ron H.]

Sir, tough choice. I'd be torn between the 28 and the pre-27. If I had other guns suitable for carry, I'd go with the pre-27; if not, then the 28.

JMHO, FWIW.

Hope this helps, and Semper Fi.

Ron H.

 

[riptrack44]

Get a part-time job and keep all three.

Seriously, all three are different even though they all shoot the .357. I would have a tough time picking a "red-headed stepchild" from any you've listed...

 

[spearcrow]

5 screw pre-27, the quality of these old revolvers are not seen in newer generations.

 

[Bear4570]

Personally I would keep both the 27's and sell the 28. If I HAD to get rid of two I would keep the 5 screw, as was said, they just don't make them like that anymore.

 

[blairgarber]

the 5 inch

 

[jeremyws1]

I'd keep the 5 screw.

 

[38-44HD45]

5" pre-27.

 

[PackN]

38-44HD45

The Pre-27 was born in 1954 and is Six Inches.The 27 was born in 1959 and is the Five Inch one. Still going with the Pre-27?? Your opinion is very valuable to me not to say you alls isn't also!!

Thanks for chiming in!!
PackN

 

[Lenshappy]

"My sister, my daughter...my sister, my daughter"