Which J-frame to keep?

[smithman 10]

I'm trying to decide which of my two J-frames to keep. There's just one of me (wife never carries anymore) and I have K-frames in 2,3 and 4 inch iterations.

Got a 60-7 and a 60-9. Here are a couple photos.

60-7 has some sentimental value and a story, 60-9 is newer and more versatile.

Which one would you unload?

 

[dcopper]

60-9 would have to go before the 60-7 all day everyday. I think, but not sure that the -7 has a plus p rating also, and no lawyer lock. I am biased, because I have a 60-7 as my everyday carry. Just my .02 cents worth.

 

[smithman 10]

Which J-frame

60-7 is rated for +P

 

[Cal44]

I'd keep the 60-9. It's a 357 Magnum, and also has no lock.

There aren't many no lock 357 mag m60s around.

 

[colt_saa]

I would keep the J-Magnum Model 60 with the -9 engineering revision without hesitation

I switched to carrying a J-Magnum as soon as they were released. These are VERY strong little revolvers

HOWEVER, if you have no pressing need for the cash, and no pressing need for the space where it is stored, I would just keep it until one of those two events occurs. Either firearm will be worth more money down the road

 

[otis24]

Keep the .357. Unless you feel .38 +P is sufficient. Then keep the one you like best.

 

[mikerjf]

Neither is easy to find. I'd keep one, and use the other as a backup.

 

[two-bit cowboy]

I'd keep both!

Each offers its own unique esthetic.

I don't have either in my Chiefs hoard, but one day I will.

 

[Injunbro]

One has sentimental value, keep it for that reason alone. You can't replace sentimental value. The other is more versatile... why sell either unless you're in desperate straits?

 

[jack the toad]

Which one would you unload?

Neither, as I can almost assure you, you'll regret it.

 

[Benton Quest]

I would unload the -9 without hesitation.

My 60-7 has done a lot of things with me, so I would never unload it.

The -7 has the classic j frame lines.

And I have become smart enough to realize that 357's out of a J frame suck immensely. The juice is not worth the squeeze.

Sent from my SM-T510 using Tapatalk

 

[HorizontalMike]

I keep my 642 on the bike, however I MUCH prefer my Kimber K6S snub. I am sorry to have to "jump ship" but this thing is a 6-shot, .357 capable, revolver at just 23oz. I have never used .357 in it and stayed with .38+P... and all I can say is WOW! Totally worth my personal investment. Love the trigger... smooth and accurate.

If S&W comes out with a similar one, THEN I AM ALL IN! ...Waiting!... BTW, got bigger guns for different needs...

 

[smithman 10]

You folks bring up all the things I ponder about.

The 60-9 is the better choice because of its strength and ammo versatility.

The 60-7 looks nicer, is a bit lighter and has some personal value to me. And I wouldn't normally carry .357 loads in the 60-9, so the only advantage is that I could use them if that were the only thing available.

I don't need the cash to help pay the mortgage (already paid off years ago) or anything else for that matter, but I must admit we have been on a "get rid of stuff we don't need" kick here recently with all the extra time we have. And believe me, we have a lot of stuff we don't need! I have always been a fan of the KISS (keep it simple, stupid) principle as well.

Thanks for all your replies.

 

[cadmike]

Sell both and go polymer. No just kidding, really.

You mention you have k frames and I'm guessing at least one is in .357. If so that's more versatile than the -9 so sell the -9. You can't replace sentimental.

I shot magnums in a j once. I didn't think it was very versatile after that.

 

[38SPL HV]

Keep em both

 

[jimbo728]

Hope one of your 60`s gets reconsidered as to the "get rid of cut".
Both would be off that list to me because of their value. You do not need to sell for financial reasons, as you stated.
Jim

 

[BigBoku]

Keep both, they are paid for, don't take much room and don't eat much.

Seriously, if the wife changes her mind both will cost a nice penny to replace.

BB

 

[wproct]

You just asked for opinions. I would personally keep the -7.

 

[Mike SC Hunter]

Keep "em" both........They won't rust.

 

[GCF]

60-7 has some sentimental value and a story, 60-9 is newer and more versatile.

Which one would you unload?

Personally, unless I needed the dough, I'd carry the -9 w/ +P spl's, & keep the -7 for backup / special occasions.

There's a good bit to be said for both...