Why Floral Carvings on Holsters?

Joined
Jan 14, 2013
Messages
1,485
Reaction score
2,033
Location
North Carolina, USA
I’ve just got an honest question about holsters. I have a ton of them and was wondering how did the floral design/pattern start out on leather? Was there a particular maker who started the trend and others copied it? Or was it something that just evolved from another pattern, like say the basketweave design?

I don’t know how true this explanation is as it was told to me through word of mouth. An older gentleman I know says that the patterns came from guns that were engraved. A lot of engravings used a leaf and scroll design. When someone had an engraved gun they wanted a holster for it that was just as detailed. And so the carved patterns came to be.

Anyway just want to hear thoughts. If you have a nice carved up holster, share it!
 
Register to hide this ad
I would think that your explanation is as good as any. Have heard the practice may have started in Mexico as they seem to have a good handle on leather crafting.
Not only is it attractive, I wonder if the carving also strengthened the leather?
 
Good post, I've often wondered the same thing.
I'm not into any depictions of floral anything on my gear, but keeping in mind, in the late 19th/early 20th century, it may have been a small representation of an appreciation for 'finer things'.
 
I've wondered the same thing before, it's pretty odd and kind of funny when you think about it.
 
From The History of Western Gunleather page at Cochise Leather Company.


Slim Jim or California
The Scout Slim Jim Holster This open-topped pattern commonly known as the "Slim Jim" established a design/construction style for the frontier west. The holster came in two versions but the popularity of the open-topped over the full-flapped variation showed the vast differences in conditions and usage between the civilized east and the wild and wooly frontier west. The guns of this time were extremely susceptible to moisture due to the percussion ignition of firing and thanks to the hundreds of miners living in the sometime lawless mining towns in California, Montana and Colorado who needed ready access to their firearms the open-topped design was the most popular even if it didn't protect the gun from moisture. Being able to pull your gun more quickly than the other guy was much more important than the flap covering the entire upper body of the gun to keep it dry. The holsters almost immediately were designed with a variation that added curves to the design which was intended to shroud the revolver's cylinder and percussion caps which helped keep it dry but still allowed ready access to the grip and trigger. The percussion cap revolver was the norm until well into the 1860's.

The "California/Slim Jim" design is the first holster to incorporate decorative elements, initially with just decorative toe plugs in brass, silver or gold. Then elaborately hand-carved detailing started appearing of animals, patriotic themes and fern patterns which is believed to have come from the Mexican influence. By the mid 1860's floral and border motifs were common, and later still many holsters started featuring a simple stamped or rolled border with a single design element in the corner such as a rosette. The "California/Slim Jim" pattern started appearing more eastward around this time, becoming popular not only in the mining camps of the Rocky Mountains but also throughout the Southwest and Great Plains. Eventually during the Civil War it appeared as far east as Kansas and Missouri. By the 1870's the "California/Slim Jim" holster began being replaced by the new "Mexican Loop" holster designs that came out with the introduction of the metal cartridge and cartridge belts. *Note: Although the "California" is similar to the military holster it evolved independently and earlier than the official military version. The two holsters do have similar features such as a deep, contour-fit body, riveted and/or sewn belt loops and toe plugs.

The Slim Jim Holster and Gun Belt was also known as The California. In the early days of the west guns were usually carried in a pommel or saddlebag holster. But as revolver advancement were made and they became more manageable saddle makers designed a more accessible and efficient hip holster. The first true western style holster was the "California". These were slender in profile and had a deep form-fitting body with sewn in toe plugs to keep debris out and help secure the gun. The holster was mounted on a belt by a leather loop sewn on the back. The "California" was also known as the "Slim Jim". Most of these western holsters were embellished. Designs went form plain to heavy complex carving or stamping. The "California" was replaced in the 1870's with the advent of the cartridge for hand guns.
 
The answer is actually pretty simple. Read the stuff above and realize, quite obviously, that since guns were worn openly back in the day the gun wearers were none too shy about decorating their leather. Floral or any kind of carving, conchos, whatever. It likely started in Mexico but it's just art - it's not particularly useful - it just looks good. Carved leather saddles looked good - why not gun leather? It wasn't rocket science or the 19th century equivalent to figure out that guys like fancy stuff, not all guys, but a lot of them.

Being able to pull your gun more quickly than the other guy

That's historical fiction for the most part.....
 
Perhaps they use a different thickness of leather for carved holsters but I always thought the few carved holsters I've handled felt stiffer than plain leather holsters. I presume carving the leather presents more surface area, would the added ridges, lines, valleys, etc. make the holster stiffer?

Just wonder if perhaps this was really a case of form following function, or vice versa, as it may?
 
Stamping designs in leather compresses the fibers in the hide and makes the piece stiffer, so it holds it shape better, in addition to adding some artistry. Adding carving to the stamped piece allows more detail in the design. When you combine the two you get the beauty in the pieces like those that Turnerriver has shared.
 
The answer is actually pretty simple. Read the stuff above and realize, quite obviously, that since guns were worn openly back in the day the gun wearers were none too shy about decorating their leather. Floral or any kind of carving, conchos, whatever. It likely started in Mexico but it's just art - it's not particularly useful - it just looks good. Carved leather saddles looked good - why not gun leather? It wasn't rocket science or the 19th century equivalent to figure out that guys like fancy stuff, not all guys, but a lot of them.

I agree. I have theorized that it was popular in a time frame when gunfighters tended to be more gentlemanly. Days when men wore hats and suits with ties as normal fashion. How do you think gunfighting legend Delph Bryce got the nickname "jelly"? I really think floral leather was also a way for a pistolero to impress the ladies. I own a couple of the holsters 05CarbonDRZ posted, and the reddish and black floral one for the 4" N frame caught my girlfriends attention immediately. I am a hobby gun writer and professional firearms trainer as well as a leather snob. I have guns and holsters all over the house. Seeing that floral holster was the first time she ever said "wow, that is a gorgeous holster"....which I translated into "chicks dig it". This is a good thing in my book.
 
Thanks for the Story,That made my Day.The fact that my Leather is good enough for a self confessed Leather Snob AND his Girlfriend puts a smile on my Face.I think the Floral carving is also like a Pink Shirt,It says "I am comfortable enough with my Manhood to have a Flower on my Holster".
 

Latest posts

Back
Top