Why I think new reloaders should start with a single stage

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Feb 23, 2008
Messages
22,681
Reaction score
16,433
Location
Florida
OK, this is JMO. Not starting a debate over brands or styles of presses. That has been hashed and beaten to a pulp!:D

You are spending you beginning learning curve time on the function of the dies, powder measure . seating, crimping etc, not learning how to operate a press that spits out ammo.

Too many new reloaders just want a press now that ammo is expensive and want to crank out lots of it without knowing the basics. I see a lot of it on another forum that has a lot more reloading questions than here.

Buying a single stage press or turret costs very little and can always be used or sold. Call it training wheels for reloaders:D
In the overall price tag of getting into reloading it is pennies well spent. I also think it is best to start with a straight wall revolver round like 38 Special/357 Mag or if you do not shoot revolvers 45 ACP is easy also.(low pressure big bullets)

Use one for while, get the basics down then you have a better idea of what you need in the future. Maybe it's all you need. Or you become obsessed and shoot more and more and need high production!. So buy the biggest and baddest press you can afford ;)

Don't forget there are many other items to buy other than a press.!!

You can disagree all you want, just stating my view. Yes, it is slow production but if it's a hobby who cares?, if you need tons of ammo for competition , then no it's not for you.

With a SS (single stage) you are batch loading. The main advantage I see is you are handling the one piece of brass many times (3-4) It's all repetition. You get to look at case mouths, primer pockets etc.

You get to check and recheck every piece. Yes,it's redundant but that's the point. Then comes the Well I have done this 200 times and folks become complacent.

You learn how to set the dies how they work, re adjust them if needed for different bullets.

Sit and resize/de prime 100 rounds. You get the flow. Stop when you want.

Now learn to flare correctly, test a bullet to see how it seats. (handguns)

Learn how to prime either by hand or on the press. Stop when you want.

Now most important. get a loading tray, your powder measure and a quality scale (most important tool)

Drop your powder, weigh it. Do it again and again. Drop the powder in a case and set it in the tray. Check on the scale every 10th round or so. Load 20 rounds for testing. If you load more and there is an error it's more work to break them apart. Once you establish it's a good load than load whatever you want 50, 100 etc.

Now put your glasses on and use a flashlight and scan every case, do it again! They all look the same? All have powder?

OK, now put a bullet on top of every case.

Back to the press, first make a dummy round (no primer or powder) Learn how to set your seating/crimping die. If you use lead bullets it pretty easy seat to the cannelure (groove)

Most seating dies when set to crimp will seat the bullet a fraction more so watch for this.

Seat your bullet and learn how to adjust the crimp. If you use Lee FCD than that's a separate step (please no debate)

Check OAL (for revolvers and lead it's gonna be different than the manual) if it crimps in the groove no doubt you are fine.

Look at your finished dummy round. Check it in your gun, does it chamber?

Now go ahead and seat/crimp your rounds from the loading tray and put them in you ammo box or bag.

After you do this for 100's of rounds you understand all the little steps and it is actually therapeutic to do. Play some nice music (no commercials!)

When loading SD test loads and rifle loads I still single stage them.

I started with a single and still have it. My Lee turret serves me well for my needs now, It can still be a single stage. I can load about 150 rounds an hour on the turret and about 100 per hr single stage taking my time, so no big difference.

Sure I have missed some steps but this is the gist of it .

Everyone is in a hurry these days and want the easy way for everything. Learn the basics, read manuals (the front part, not the load data!) Get 3 manuals and the powder companies online data. Read, review and read some more.

Be safe and ask questions if you are unsure.:)
 
Register to hide this ad
I couldn't agree more on the single stage press. I have a RCBS jr that I bought in '79 and still use it. I like the idea of having each brass in my hand for inspection of each one.

I have a friend that has a Dillon progressive and loaded some on it several months ago but have never invested in a progressive type reloader.

Some old habits and likes are hard to break.
 
All I've ever used is the single stage press I started with 20+ years ago. I've never had a problem producing an adequate volume of reloads with it. I always worked in batches a step at a time; de-cap and re-size a bunch of brass at one sitting, hand prime at another, flare the case mouth at another, and then comes the serious part of measuring the powder and seating the bullets. The final step would be done from three case blocks holding 50 rounds each. Granted my highest volume of production was never over 2,000 rounds per month. In the past I probably have loaded all the steps from fired case to reloaded round all in the same session, but my normal process is to do all of the brass needing a step, set up to do that step, then go on to the next step if I feel like it. I have rejected some of my hand-loads, but the rejection comes at the bench not because of issues when I go to shoot.
 
I will add that I prefer a dillon, especially for handgun rounds. The single stage press made me appreciate and understand it form the beginning though and the RCBS Rockchucker still has many uses in the reloading room.
 
OK, this is JMO.
---snipped lots of stuff---

Nope. Wrong. An auto-indexing progressive is the safest press. Single-stage is great for blowing up guns.

I've never met a noob yet who couldn't learn to turn out quality ammo on a progressive. A Dillon machine holds it's value much better than any single-stage.

If you like fondling each cartridge more than shooting - a single-stage is the right press for you.
 
Last edited:
I agree 100% on starting out with a single stage!!!!!!!!
this is what I have been doing for a little over a year now.

As you learn more and gain more experience - you realize how much more there is to learn. No its not rocket science - but there are a whole bunch of little details. They're not too complicated but at a nice, slower relaxing pace - you can pay attention to those details and address them as they come up.

I like to say this is a craft more than just a hobby. Developing the skills and experience first and understanding why, like an apprentice, is more important than getting into mass production.

As a side note: stuff happens - I saw in one of the cases in the loading block the powder looked a little high, I dumped it and in the bottom was a pretty big spider - not sure if you use a mag or standard primer on spiders - but remembering that instance - keeps me looking - if it had been all powder ?????
 
Last edited:
Started out on a single stage. Still using it, some 30 odd years later. Loads all the ammo I need.
 
Nope. Wrong. An auto-indexing progressive is the safest press. Single-stage is great for blowing up guns.

Never mentioned what is or is not safe.

As I mentioned, it's not a debate, but that is one bold statement with no basis in fact.

Also mentioned the value or resale has nothing to do with it which was addressed.
 
Nope. Wrong. An auto-indexing progressive is the safest press. Single-stage is great for blowing up guns.

I also agree with rule3 100%. The single stage is a model of simplicity.

How a single stage is great for blowing up guns, compared with a progressive, is beyond me.

I've got about 50K rounds on a single stage without blowing anything up.

Care to elaborate?
 
As I have said in other threads, I also recommend a new reloader to start with a single stage press. I have a single stage and a Dillon 550B. For our shooting needs, I use the single stage more.

Again , Just my opinion. Not arguing with anyone. I agree with you Rule3.

Cheers,

Rick
 
I reload an average of 5000 per year and have done so for over 7 years on a Forster single stage. I must be really lucky cause I haven't blown up any of my guns.

Rule3 has it nailed.
 
Worthwhile points. I started on a Dillon 550B about 25 years ago, and it worked out fine. Just used it as a turret press until I could grasp everything that was going on, which didn't take very long at all.

I was sure I was going to keep handloading and shooting for years to come, and didn't want to put money into something that I would outgrow or find lacking for my needs down the road. The 550 has turned out many thousands of quality rounds for me, and continues to be everything I need for .223, .38, .357, .40, .44mag, and .45acp.

Just a different perspective.

ETA and nothing's blown up......;)
 
Rule3 - Thanks for sharing your experience and thoughts. I have wanted to start reloading but when things went crazy, I decided to wait until supplies were more plentiful. I haven't checked recently but this post will help to clarify what to look for.

Thanks - Mike
 
I'm new to reloading and I opted for a lyman turret. What I like is I can use it as a single stage. So far the only multiple stages I have done is seating and crimping.
 
I've been loading on an RCBS Jr., for some fifty years.

Although I use a Dillon SDB for some handgun loads, never felt the need for anything else.

That old press is ALL original, never replaced a single part. I have no idea, how many thousands of rounds, I've put through it.
 
Well said Sir! I started out many moons ago at the tender age of fifteen with the old Lee Loader, ya know the one where you use a hammer to drive the cases in and out of the dies. As money became available I progressed to a C frame type press then an O frame press learning as I went. Then the IPSC bug got me and I got me a Dillon Square Deal press to keep up with my now voracious ammo needs and later the CASS shoots. Well that competition thing sort of went away and I retired the Square Deal and have been loading on an RCBS Rock Chucker ever since. Being able to inspect each case four times through the loading cycle is a good thing. Last year I went through six thousand small pistol and five thousand large pistol primers (a rough round count) one at a time and now and again a bad case is discovered and discarded. Of course being retired now helps with the time thing and saving empty's for the winter doldrums are a big help getting through to spring. Long story short I feel safer doing them one at a time.
 
Nope. Wrong. An auto-indexing progressive is the safest press. Single-stage is great for blowing up guns.

Please provide data to quantify this statement. While necessity is the Mother of invention, complexity is the father of disaster and a progressive press to the uninitiated is a prescription for just that.

I've never met a noob yet who couldn't learn to turn out quality ammo on a progressive.

The problem with idiot proofing is that God keeps making better idiots. I have had three separate instances where individuals have brought their new reloads they just made to the range that scared the hell out of me. Most were seated too deeply (OAL? What's that? You have to measure them?). Some were loaded with the wrong powder and charge for the particular round (I couldn't find any Blue Dot but they had Bullseye and I just used it instead). I've seen more primers in sideways or backwards than I care to remember. All that progressive press does for these folks is allow them to produce more chances of blowing themselves and the people around them up faster.

A Dillon machine holds it's value much better than any single-stage.

If you are worried about resale value, you are obviously not committed for the long haul. I have a single stage. If I get another press, I will task this one to a more specialized role.

If you like fondling each cartridge more than shooting - a single-stage is the right press for you.

If you are not fondling your cartridges, you have no idea if you have a good one or one that is about to fail you, possibly catastrophically. I will touch, fondle and finger every cartridge to make sure I always have fingers left to do so with.

Reloaders throw rounds together as a mass production activity. Handloaders develop loads for various scenarios and conditions in small batches working through various combinations until they find what is right for their weapons. Reloading is work. Handloading is art.

One additional point - I am not opposed to the use of progressive presses -- BY EXPERIENCED PEOPLE. People just starting out need to understand the science of load ONE round well enough before they start cranking them out in volume.

My opinion. Deal with it accordingly.
 
Last edited:
C'Mon guys
its like we're in a bar and we're discussing tools:D geesh!!!!

single stage and auto progressive presses - its not like its religion or politics
it doesn't call for hopping off your stool and getting in someone's face

its Ginger or Marianne

now if I say Marianne and you say Ginger we're good

but if you say Marinanne too - now we got a problem

its a real shame - we can't just go to the lounge and have a few beers electronically
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top