Anyone who expects the ATF to be consistent or logical in their rulings is likely to have to answer question 21g affirmatively.
i might be crazy but it was never adjudicated,.

Anyone who expects the ATF to be consistent or logical in their rulings is likely to have to answer question 21g affirmatively.
Am I reading these posts correctly? Dropping a pistol into what
amounts to a pocket flap holster suddenly shifts to AOW?
If I carry a 1911 in a concealing flap holster under a coat is that AOW? Seems to be the same thing to me.
I truly understand jumping through the AFT hoops because of
their ruling, but this is a very slippery slope.
Sorry. Conspiracy rant off.
Not exactly. The point is that the holster is designed for the gun to fired while still in the holster. There was a similar holster back then that was designed to be "permanently" attached to the derringer using the grip screws. The maker was on ATFs radar already and they considered the modification of removing the grips and replacing it with an attached "concealment device" to be the same as a pen gun or briefcase gun a la the Man from UNCLE and decided it was AOW. That was in the 80s. The *******/GALCO holsters continued to be used until someone at ATF still pickier decided any holster designed to be shot through was AOW.
Mine went away, ******* holster and all before 1997, for those from BATFE monitoring this traffic.
I see DeSantis is marketing a "Pocket Shot" holster for small autos that looks much like the banned holsters except for the fact that the entire slide is visible. Maybe that makes the difference, or maybe the regulators are too busy with bump stocks and wrist braces to bother with it.
Here's mine. Pretty sure guns disguised as anything else, including wallets aren't legal but not sure how to go about making it so.
See post #37 above.