a factory 10mm in a Semi-Auto compares to what Revolver caliber ?
I have carried each, and shot critters with each of them. It is a little bit better than a .357, but it ain't no .41 magnum.
a factory 10mm in a Semi-Auto compares to what Revolver caliber ?
a factory 10mm in a Semi-Auto compares to what Revolver caliber ?
Much of the "like a 41 Magnum" chatter that goes on around the internet is a mis-quote from an article that John Taffin did on the 10MM Magnum cartridge about 20+ years ago. In that article he did say the 10MM was on par with the 41 Magnum. However he was not referring to the 10MM Auto, it was the 10MM Magnum. Folks have just ended up dropping that last part. . .thus an Internet Urban Legend is bornWhenever this discussion pops up (I think it’s already been a couple months since the last .41mag vs. 10mm debate), I break out the popcorn. The fact is: 10mm will always fall short of .41 magnum. The hottest loaded 10mm may just approach mildly loaded .41 mag ballistics, but just barely. Factory .41 mag has at least a 200 ft/lb MV advantage over factory 10mm out of the same length barrel. Don’t believe me? Go over to ballistics by the inch and see for yourself.
I agree with this as long as we can all agree that while this is totally accurate... it doesn't tell the entire story when the rubber meets the road.Whenever this discussion pops up (I think it’s already been a couple months since the last .41mag vs. 10mm debate), I break out the popcorn. The fact is: 10mm will always fall short of .41 magnum. The hottest loaded 10mm may just approach mildly loaded .41 mag ballistics, but just barely. Factory .41 mag has at least a 200 ft/lb MV advantage over factory 10mm out of the same length barrel. Don’t believe me? Go over to ballistics by the inch and see for yourself.
10 mm factory depends on which factory. The usual range ammo is 40SW
"+p".
For practical purposes 10 mm is equivalent to 357 magnum.
If 41 mag means the old "city load", a 210 gr bullet at about 1000 fps from a service length barrel, then the 10 mm can easily best that.
That old school print ad is most excellent!
Exactly!
The only 10mm factory load that is anywhere close to where it should be is the "SIG" branded 10mm. Otherwise, roll your own or you really are getting a .40cal that is 65fps faster than .40cal factory ammo is loaded.
To answer the OP's question: The 10mm, hand loaded ammo is comparable to a very, very warm .357Magnum factory load. I'd say even the 10mm is a hair or two more potent even.
The poster that points to the thump/knock down power at 100 yards between the .41Mag and a 10mm brings up a darn good point! The .41Mag is going to have much more kinetic energy at 100+Yards than 10mm can for sure!
That said, .44Special/.44Magnum is my favorite handgun load. I've seen people on this very forum compare the 10mm as equal to the good ol' .44Magnum; which is a total joke! I like 10mm and all but it's certainly NO .44Magnum no matter how you slice it!
The 10mm and 41 Magnum will always be the "rounds that were to be Kings" of 70's and 80's lore and theory, if never all that much practice.