• Update – 12:30 PM EST
    Attachments are now working, and all members can once again upload files.
    We are currently testing URL redirects and other miscellaneous features across the site.
    Thank you for your continued patience and support during this migration.

    Prefer a darker look? You can switch between light and dark modes in your account settings:
    smith-wessonforum.com/account/preferences

4" N Frame CCW

mc5aw

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 28, 2008
Messages
5,224
Reaction score
8,587
Location
The free state of PA
I'm interested to hear from anyone who carries a 4" lightweight N frame as a CCW ... 325PD, 329PD, TR325 ... and the practicality of doing so. Not interested in hearing about Night Guards, just 4" Ns.
 
Not as a Rule, but a good pancake style rig is concealable & comfortable.
 
I use a cross draw clam shell outside waist band for a S&W mod 29, 4" whenever I fear serious social work is possible, a light jacket, sport coat, roomy sweatshirt or loose/roomy un-tucked button up shirt does well, but I'm now 5'11" 240lbs. I carried a full sized 1911A1, Browning High Power, or a Colt Combat Commander all in inside the waistband rigs for years too, as I've gotten older, I carry the revolvers more.
 
Not light weight, Model 28 4" OWB under a shirt or jacket. Also like to carry my 1917 same way but a little longer jacket! I'm 5'11" and 265+/- and never found the weight a problem, I have been keeping my eye out for a lightweight 25 in ACP or 45 Colt. Ivan
 
Not lightweight but I've been known to use a 29 or 58 4" in a Milt Sparks IWB. Using a proper holster, they aren't hard to tote.
 
A 4" N frame is easily carried in a pancake holster (e.g., Alessi CQC), and easier yet in a shoulder holster (e.g., Alessi Bodyguard). So far, I've only carried it in bear country, west of the Mississippi - .44 Magnum, naturally.
 
I carried a 329PD in an IWB Galco holster. It carried and concealed very well. Weight was not an issue. Same holster fit my Model 25. Using a high quality belt and holster will make all the difference in the world in your comfort and confidence.
 
Again, not a light weight, but I am currently carrying a 4" Model 28 in a Theis hybrid holster: Theis Revolver Holster

I have been wearing it every day to work for at least a month now. No problems.

A good belt sure helps, too. I am wearing a Triple K Garrison belt that holds this thing just fine. Looks nice, too.

Triple K garrison
 
The closest I had was my 25-13. For a steel Nframe it was fairly light. I carried in in a Roys Original pancake and never had any trouble concealing it. It rode quite well on the belt, too!
 
Come on, guys, its winter. You could haul around a sawed off shotgun under a winter coat! If you're wearing a 3/4th length jacket like an old field jacket, its just not a problem. Common sense dictates that maybe its not real wise to carry a large handgun into a very crowded place, particularly a place where you may get jostled or bumped some.
 
Come on, guys, its winter. You could haul around a sawed off shotgun under a winter coat! If you're wearing a 3/4th length jacket like an old field jacket, its just not a problem. Common sense dictates that maybe its not real wise to carry a large handgun into a very crowded place, particularly a place where you may get jostled or bumped some.

I don't really see the difference between carrying a large or small handgun if you are getting bumped and jostled. If someone is bumping into your carry piece, they are bumping into it, regardless of size. I carry my 28 at work under an untucked polo shirt. Nobody is rubbing up against me there.

If I ever go to a rave, I'll carry something other than my N-frame.
 
Model 10 Daily

Not an N frame, but my usual EDC is my 4" Model 10 in a DeSantis thumb break scabbard, owb. Any light coat or vest is fine to conceal it. As others have said, quality holster and belt are the keys to making it work.
 
I can easily conceal my 4" 686 using a Lobo pancake holster.

However, my 4" 629 in a Bianchi 111 Cyclone is a different story. It's great for woods carry, etc, but not easy to conceal without a long heavy coat.

I know that's not exactly what you asked...
 
The 329PD is the revolver I carry into the 'Outback' on hiking, fishing, or camping trips. I always have a cover jacket, or fishing vest when I carry it. I use a shoulder holster, or a cross draw holster depending upon the outer garment.
 
Back
Top