Thank you.
Everything in your post above is 100% however. It's can be applied to virtually every form of carry ever devised by man. We're these uniformed officers wearing a sidearm? If so exposing an ankle rig only exposed their BUG, duty side arm was already in plain sight. From my personal experience, an ankle holster is about the only form of concealed carry I haven't seen exposed at one time or another by an inadverdant or unintentional action.
As far as going hands on with a suspect goes I'd wager the majority of officers disarmed in a physical confrontation loose their side arm from their holster 1000 times more than from an ankle rig. As I said. Both instances are applicable just not solely to ankle carry.
I did title my post "If it's good for you, go with it" and in the narrative only gave two of the reasons I have chosen not to ankle carry. Anybody else may ankle carry at their pleasure with no problem from me.
At the trainings and conferences I referenced, it wasn't uniformed officers I was talking about, but the "civilian attire" officers I was talking about. Sorry I didn't mention that. I've never seen my chief in anything other than a suit. He carries his "duty" handgun in an ankle holster and I've seen him on a couple of occasions inadvertently expose his ankle gun while sitting/seated. He still prefers ankle carry for himself, and I'm fine with his decision - he's the one that needs to be comfortable with his carry decision, not me.
In that warrant service above, duty handguns are normally in retention style holsters and close to the officer's hands for additional handgun retention defense. I haven't seen an ankle holster with anything more than a thumb-strap for retention (often not even that) and in this case the ankle gun ended up some distance away from the officers own hands and very close to the BG's hands - it made me uncomfortable, and my partner uncomfortable also after I pointed it out to him.
"I'd wager the majority of officers disarmed in a physical confrontation loose their side arm from their holster 1000 times more than from an ankle rig."
I agree with you (maybe not the 1000 times, but I don't know for sure so I'll go with it), but then every uniformed officer I've seen has had a handgun on their duty belt, but I only know a few who carry a back-up gun on their ankle. Sheer numbers alone would make a snatch from a duty belt many, many times more likely. I wonder how many BUGs have been taken from under a uniform shirt or from a uniform pocket, like I prefer, versus from an ankle holster?
Bottom line? If it's good for you, go with it. I don't mind at all.
You take care now.