Question on COLT Single Action Army? Value?

wheelgun28

wheelgun28

Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2009
Messages
2,400
Reaction score
3,022
Location
SW CT
A friend that is trying to shrink his gun collection has a Colt Single Action Army. Its in the brown wood grain card board box. The gun is mint, truly never taken out of the box till last week. Its still got the factory oil on it and in the plastic bag. Has all the papers and so on. The box is weak has tears, I think one end flap is gone. The thing is its a 44 special, I know it was cataloged. I just cant find them to get a estimate on value.

I dont know anything about these critters. I looked on line and dont find many and even less in 44spl. I am hoping some of you folks have some expertise on these.

Thanks!!
 
Register to hide this ad
Not an expert at all,but I don't think the 44 spec. caliber affects value very much.The barrel length would,and whether it might be a second generation or third generation would.A serial number would help to date it.I do know that the woodgrain box was used in 1981,as I have a New Frontier from that year.
 
The shorter 4 3/4" barrel is slightly more desireable. Don't know what length this is. But they go for about $1100 to 1250. There's one on Gunbroker right now with a 5 1/2" barrel. Yours, or his, might go for $100 more if it's all oily and completely virginal, but prices have dropped a little lately. I just bought a mint ten year old .short .45 in nickle with a tuned action for a grand. The caliber is more common than the .44, but the nickle finish is a little more pricey. The reason I know about the .44 Special is I want one real bad and it's next on my list. I just couldn't resist this shiney one. It's a really great gun. how long is the barrel?
 
Last edited:
Thanks guys!!

The barrel is not in the 4" range its around 6" didnt measure it, I didnt even know they came in different lengths. This just has the proper cowboy gun look. Truth is I didnt even know they came in anything other than 45lc or 22 rimfire. :)

I am slowly learning. This gun actually peaked my interest in SAAs.

I was worried that it not being 45lc would hurt it?

As far as age goes Id guess late 1970s to early 1980s. Thats when he was buying this stuff it seems. The box has a big "union made" label on one end if that helps.

I hope to get back over there in a week or two. Hes not always free.

Tom
 
Last edited:
wheelgun, the 'woodgrain' boxes were used for the late 2nd generation gun, so may put the price a bit higher, but for the most part you find these for sale in like the 'Gun Digest (List) and some distributors have the "new" (3rd gen & current production) fairly reasonably priced, around $1000, 1100.....its the 'early guns,, that fetch the BIG bucks, as welll as the early 2nd gen,. guns, in the "stagecoach boxes".......serial number and condition is everything................
 
dant said:
wheelgun, the 'woodgrain' boxes were used for the late 2nd generation gun, so may put the price a bit higher, but for the most part you find these for sale in like the 'Gun Digest (List) and some distributors have the "new" (3rd gen & current production) fairly reasonably priced, around $1000, 1100.....its the 'early guns,, that fetch the BIG bucks, as welll as the early 2nd gen,. guns, in the "stagecoach boxes".......serial number and condition is everything................
Click to expand...
I'm not too sure about the wood grain boxes used prior to 1976 but they were used on 3rd generation guns. I bought them that way in the eary 80's. But 2nd gen .44 Specials were stopped in 1966. I just bought a mint NIB nickle Colt .SAA .45 from 1970 in the original stagecoach box. I'm sure this is a fairly common 3RD gen gun he's got here. And stil a desirable gun.
 
You didnt mention the type grips or exact barrel length. Also could this be the new frontier? They have a adjustable rear sight. Assumeing it a standard blue and case hardend SAA with the black gutta percha grips Anywhere from $1,100 to $1,400. Maybe walnut grips?
 
the wood grain boxes were used later in the 70's, and even into the 80's for some models, till the mid 80's and the so called reddish "anniversary" ( 80 series guns) came in and had the "transition" models in them,those had the early two part cylinders before they went to the One piece, solid ones...as I said , the serial numbers were the determining factor, and just where the "SA" went in the number.
 
My 1978 Colt Series 70 GM came to me with that type of box and the Union Made endorsement. New ones are maybe 1200 unless they're quite fancy. Sounds like a 5.5" barrel which is what I had for a while, though mine was in .45 Colt and left the factory circa 03. I can't remember what I paid, maybe 1200?
 
Here is mine. It is in .44 special, likely the same vintage.

Guns136-1.jpg
 
I have a .44 special Colt SAA, 5 1/2" 3rd generation, in the woodgrain box. This one was made in 1980, and is unfired, new in the box. I've evaluated this one at $1475, being complete and unfired in a not-so-common caliber. Of course, I might or might not get that for it, if I chose to sell it.

SAA.jpg

COLT-SAA-SMALL.jpg
 
IF the one you are looking at is a 1980s 3rd generation and priced over $1,100-1,300, I would recommend buying one of the new ones out of the Colt Custom Shop. In my opinion, much higher quality for about the same price.

However, if it is a later 2nd generation and priced <$1,500 go for it.
 
I was thinking a 2nd Gen in a short barrel length, unfired in the box would be closer to $1500 plus in my neck of the woods....
 
Thanks Guys!!!

I wish I paid a little bit closer attention to it. At the time I wasnt all so interested in it but, after I left it kind grew on me.

I would say that the barrel is at least the 5 3/4 as shown perhaps a bit longer? Yes it is black and case color. I am almost sure it had wood grips on it. He felt it was worth $700 to $800, I guess hes a bit low. I guess it safe to say it worth $1K anyway?

It looked alot like the above pic, but with wood grips(I think, minds playing tricks on me)

Thanks
Tom
 
If it is in very good shape its easily worth a grand no matter the caliber, barrel length, time of manufactor, type finish or type grips if it is orginal and looking new as you say.
 
Well I finally got this gun. It turns out its a New Frontier Model

DSC00091.jpg


DSC00093.jpg


DSC00094.jpg


Any marks you see in the photos it just oil. I am missing the plastic bag that the papers came in and perhaps a hang tag?

I got a very good deal on it I feel, the previous owner wanted me to have it so he made me a deal I could not refuse :)

I wont shoot it, I will oil it up good put it back in the plastic bag and lock it up for a while...

The problem is that I might want to buy one to shoot now...

I keep a spread sheet on values (in case the wife needs to sell them) I list retail and blowout prices on everything. What do you think is a good range on this.
 
If you got it for a good price, than good for you. The New Frontier Models do not command the values that the Single Action Army's do, but being a 2nd generation gun helps a bit.

Congratulations.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

P
  • Locked
(Sold Elsewhere)1964 Colt Single Action Army .45 Colt Sam Colt Sesquicentennial Model
Replies
1
Views
842
Punisher0822
P
G
  • Locked
**SOLD** Colt Single Action Army .45 Colt - P1840 4.75" Case Colors - Unfired - $2000
Replies
7
Views
3K
Xfuzz
Xfuzz
George_in_SD
  • Locked
Factory Engraved S&W's, 38/44 OD Pre War, Multiple Colt SAA, US Army K38 & More!
Replies
2
Views
2K
Fullmetaljacket
F
D
  • Locked
WTS: Stainless 5 1/2" Old Army, Colt 2nd & 3rd gen. SAAs, S&W 29-2 4 (SOLD)
Replies
3
Views
2K
Model29-26.5
M
I
  • Locked
SOLD: Taylor's & Co. Smoke Wagon Deluxe, 357 magnum SAA
Replies
7
Views
3K
Idiocyabounds
I

Latest posts

Back
Top