Any recommendations for a Derringer?

TheHobbyist

Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2009
Messages
2,534
Reaction score
3,709
Location
Midwest
Greetings,

I have been entertaining the thought of a derringer; any recommendations?

I'm not a big fan of the .22 or .22 mag in this platform; accordingly, I am interested in .45 LC or .38 spl or 9 mm.

Ideas? Experiences? Pictures ? :)
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Avoid them. They are dangerous if dropped. Rex Applegate told me that he tested a Remington one in WW II and was underwhelmed with the penetration. That was in traditional .41 RF, of course.

I doubt the locking systems are really strong enough for modern ammo, although steels have improved.

Get a small .380 auto or a snub .38 instead. Accuracy will be better, especially beyond armslength distances, and they are simply safer.
 
Last edited:
Hobbyist,

You will get almost nothing but negitive responses here about derringers. Filled mostly with opinions, and mostly not based on facts. Or based on experience with the really poor brands of derringers, not any of the good ones.

The American and Bond derringers are quality firearms. The American has been chambered in .30-30, 45-70, 223, 45 Win Mag,almost any caliber you can name, they would do it.

They both have excellent safetys and are quite drop safe.

Accuracy can leave a lot to be desired. Best I've been able to do with my American in 45 auto/auto rim is four rounds in about three inches at seven yards.

The large bores are not for the recoil sensitive. Very small grip. My 45 auto weighs one pound loaded. Will easily send a 260 grain bullet out the barrel at over 900 fps.

A derringer can have a place in the tool box. They are excellent as a 'get off me' gun. There are no accuracy worries in such a situation and the bullet and all the combustion gasses are directed into the enemies body if you've pressed the barrel up against him. They also won't jam in such a shot.

Very slow to reload and of course only two rounds.


Cat
 
Try Bond Arms. I used to have one. They - and I think the American Derringer Corp models - are drop safe when used correctly if I recall. Though check your owner's manual.
 
I took a look at American Derringer and Bond Arms...

...several years ago. At the time, I carried a Charter Arms Tracker .357 snub concealed. This was long before the LCP hit the scene.

Built like tanks and with the weight to boot, I found that both, while well built, gave only two shots in a package that was almost the same size and more weight than what I was packing, but with less rounds.

I like them, but have no real use for one and I passed. Since the LCP came out, even the Charter has gone to "sometimes" carry.
 
Thank you to all who replied for the objectivity; it is sincerely appreciated.

The Ruger LCP is of interest, and I will further research. I'm not very familiar with these compacts.

Kind regards,

Hobbyist
 
Special thanks to the mod who showed me how to edit the title. Guess i'm not as computer savvy as I thought!

Kind regards--
 
I'm interested in this platform more on a historical note, not for CCW, really.

While I have been considering a Bersa, Shield, or LCP, my interest is more of a historical nature with these arms.

I enjoy reading on the "Old West" and thought it would be interesting from a collectible or historic aspect, primarily.

Just wanted some opinions from "those in the know".
 
I have an American derringer in .41Magnum. It's plenty accurate out to spitting distance. Don't load anything but my .41Specials in it. My small defense gun is a Glock 26 (10 shots are better that 2). Friend had one in 5.56x45 that was interesting. Carried it with 40gr. Hornady V-max in it.
 
Hobbyist ... As your interests are more from a historical perspective, definitely visit the SASS and CAS websites/forums for info and feedback. Really good people with lots to share.
 
Hi:
In the 1960s I carried a "Great Western" (West Germany?) in .38spl caliber. It was unbelivable accurate. Both shots in the "Kill Area" of a B-27 target.
In the 1980s I carried a "High Standard" in .22 magnum. At any range accuracy was "Wanting".
I think the limit in caliber for a weapon of this type should be .38spl standard velocity.
Jimmy
 
My recommendation is be absolutely sure of where your fingers are before you pull the trigger on any Derringer :eek:
 
My recommedation - do not get one.

I may have had bad luck but after three (3) tries I either have the world's worst luck or the world's best advice.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top