The man who didn't speak, a true story.

geoff40

Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2005
Messages
1,171
Reaction score
841
Location
New Hampshire
A long time ago, back when I was just 19 and 20, I worked my first of 2 stints as an aid at a State Hospital in New England. My job as an aid was hands on, working directly with the patients on an elderly resident unit, not a very glamorous place to be, but really at a State -run psych facility there isn't much glamour to be found anywhere. Especially back then. The unit had 35 or so patients on it, took up an entire floor of an old brick, mid 1800s asylum type of building, and in those days the patients were all long term patients who had been locked up for many years. 5 or more decades wasn't uncommon. Built in 4 stories of bricks like a mid 1800s mill building, it was hot in the summer, windows open and big floor fans blowing. No a/c in those days. In the winter, the steam radiators hissing steam from the nearby steam plant would heat the entire building up to about the mid 80s.
On a given day there would typically be 4 or 5 of us aids and 1 nurse working an entire floor for an 8 hour shift. Taking care of the patients, be it feeding, dressing, getting them cleaned up, and more. A mix of patients with varying levels of functional ability, a lot of them obviously crazy. Others, maybe not so obvious, for back when these patients were locked up, society often locked up those with severe physical defects along with the insane. Many of the patients would never know their own name, but some of them were sharp as a tack. We were assigned certain patients as "contacts", patients we were told to spend one on one time with, when we had time to spare. It wasn't easy, but we did manage to make it happen.
There was this man on the unit, and his first name was Wilbur. That's not his actual name
but it is close enough to be it. Medical confidentiality extends infinitely and I can't tell you his name even today.

Wilbur's evident main issue, when I first met him, was that he was mute. He could walk around and pretty much care for himself in most ways, and he could follow directions to a T. He just never spoke. Wilbur was around my height probably, but it's hard to tell because he always walked a bit hunched over forward. He was a good sized man, well built and not slender or a lightweight. Stocky, broad shouldered, strong. Bald on top, not so on the sides. His eyelids had a bit of a droop to them, bloodhound eyes, with the red inner lids exposed along the bottom. Wilbur would walk and pace the unit for hours at a time. He was, by a long shot, the one man in the best overall physical condition on the entire unit. Sadly there was nothing else for him to do really, so I guess he paced out of boredom. Sometimes, I could get him to sit down in front of a TV for a minute or so if I asked him to, but he would soon get up and go off pacing. I remember I used to wonder and comment out loud to other aids, wondering how far he walked a day. How many miles? The other patients there needed a lot more help than Wilbur, and so getting any time to deal with him was often difficult. Most often, when there wasn't much to do it was because the patients were all sleeping, including Wilbur. In my memory, I can see him clearly right now, I remember his face very well, and the way he would look right in to my eyes while I spoke to him. I remember like it was last week.
At first, I didn't really know how to talk to him, as he never said anything back, but soon enough I just rolled with it and spoke normally to him. He of course never said a word back, but he would stare at me intently, and if I'd suggest he do something, or outright ask him to, usually he would comply, while watching me, in his silence.
There was this child's plastic bowling set with colored pins and a couple of 3 holed balls, and though he was way too old and large to be playing with this kid toy he loved to bowl with it. So when I had even 10 minutes to give him, I would get out the pins and let him bowl while having a one-sided conversation with him. And he would bowl and listen. He also liked cards, although trying to get him to actually play a game with cards was impossible. He would just hold them, and apparently make a game of trying to hold on to them no matter how hard I was pulling on them, trying to get them out of his hand. On his forearms, each had a good sized tattoo, old, indistinct. Wilbur never smiled, he never laughed. He always had the same expression on his face, looking empty and sad. Only his drooping eyes changed. He always looked right in to my eyes, intently, and there was obviously a lot going on behind them. His eyes in general watered up a often, he often looked on the verge of tears. His hands shook slightly, but I don't know if with a palsy, a side effect of medication, or simply his nerves. And he liked to arm wrestle. I could easily beat him arm wrestling, but I would usually let him win. He had a surprisingly strong grip. He stared in to my eyes when we arm wrestled. As I've grown older, it has occurred to me to wonder if he was letting me win. Though there were 34 other patients on that unit, it is Wilbur I remember best of all.
One evening while arm wrestling, I remarked about his tattoos on his forearms, asking him for probably the 50th time what they were. His answer of course, was more silence. I was able to hold his arm in my hands and turn back and forth, looking carefully at the ink, while he just stared at me. The blue colored ink was along the outside edge of his forearm, the ink old and starting to fade, blurring out in his skin. Once or twice I had looked at these tattoos, but on this day I had one on one time with him on my side, and I was able to really get a good long look. And after a little time, the first thing I made out was some sort of battleship, something like 6 inches long. Underneath the ship, some lettering. I bent over, looking intently, studying the blurred letters, and after a couple of more minutes or so, I finally made out the slightly smaller, blurry line of letters underneath the ship:

USS INDIANAPOLIS

My shock was complete, taking over my body and my mind for a moment. I remember my own hands beginning to shake a little while holding his. Here I sat, holding the hands and arms of a WW2 Navy Vet, and a survivor of an event that words don't exist to describe. Suddenly a lot of things became obvious and clear to me. I was speechless, and didn't know what to say to him. Not that he would have offered any answer.

A little later on during that shift, during my lunch break, I ate in the chart room while looking through the personal history section of Wilbur's several inch thick patient record. The records were all on paper, contained in a loose leaf binder something like 4 inches thick. The pages were old, the typed ink a bit faded and sometimes hard to see, but there was enough there to see he was indeed on that ship when it was attacked and sunk, and that he was one of the survivors of a very famous and horrifying true story. I stayed in the chart room after my shift ended, reading his life story carefully, and later that night I laid in my bed a long time, unable to sleep.
What a ****ty thing to do to a Navy Vet who survived one of the worst Naval disasters in history. Lock him up on a psych ward for the rest of his life. But that's how things were done in those days. That's how they dealt with things they couldn't fix. It wouldn't surprise me a bit to find out that other survivors of the sinking of the Cruiser USS Indianapolis were also locked up for life in a similar asylum, in other States.
There wasn't anything wrong with Wilbur before the Indianapolis sunk, and it seemed he had been a pretty normal guy. But during the entire time I knew him, he didn't speak, ever. I can tell you however, if you spend enough time around someone who never talks to you, you can start to learn things about that person, and start getting to know them, at least a little bit. That's how it was with Wilbur. By today's standards, he would for sure be diagnosed with severe PTSD, and treatment would likely be far better for him. He would have had a better life.

This happened 35 years ago as I type. And the Indianapolis sinking happened about 35 years before that. Wilbur is no doubt long resting, hopefully in the eternal peace he so deserved. I think of Wilbur often, a man likely long forgotten by any relatives he might have had, unknown to any descendants he might have around today. A man who never had anyone visit him during the time I knew him. I think of Wilbur every Veteran's Day, every Memorial Day, along with other Combat Vets I have known. In the years that have passed by since I knew Wilbur, much has changed, including the oncoming of the web. With it, the information super highway. There is a website all about the USS Indianapolis, complete with a list of every crew member on board when she was torpedoed and sunk. The survivors each have an asterisk next to their names. Wilbur's name is there, I have seen it, and I am glad that somebody somewhere remembered his name when this tribute web site was created. A lot of years have passed by since July 30th of 1945.
I feel honored to have known this man, as best as I could, even if he never said a single word to me. I wonder what his voice was like.
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
That is a very emotional story . I hope he had some peace in his life.
 
Thank you, geoff40, for sharing something very personal with us. Wilbur is not forgotten by you and I think will be remembered by many of us with whom you shared.
 
You still remember this man many years later. That's a great tribute to
him.
You wrote "What a ****ty thing to do to a Navy Vet who survived one of the worst Naval disasters in history. Lock him up on a psych ward for the rest of his life. But that's how things were done in those days. That's how they dealt with things they couldn't fix." Yes it is very sad,
but is turning vets out on the streets now where many are homeless,
conned out of the little money they may have, and not able to handle
their meds really any better? Some die a lonely, cold, miserable death
on the streets with no real place to go. Neither option is a very good one.
 
For those of us who knew fighting men of that era, who know the many stories of bravery, self sacrifice, and unspeakable horror they endured for the country they all loved, never doubt that they were the best generation this country ever had. My father was such a man, and to be sure, after his service, his life would never be the same. Duty, Honor, Country. I will never forget that every day I live as a free man, I owe a dept of gratitude, to such men. Every day, I strive to be worthy of their sacrifice.
 
I am glad that you wrote your post but it is pretty hard to handle towards the end. You tried hard and for that I am thankful. If one could have known what he was thinking.
 
This is what I'm going to do.....

Great story, but very sad for 'Wllbur' and his shipmates. It seems that other people should know this story and that it didn't end when the survivors were rescued. This is what I'm going to do. Whenever it's Veterans or Memorial Day or some National holiday, I'm going to remember 'Wilbur'.

PS: It wasn't too hard to find his real name, so at least I'll be able to remember it right.
 
Last edited:
There is always the hope that survivors are driven like Robert Shaw's character in Jaws but your experience is probably closer to the truth of how it is for many. A touching story, thank you.
 
Thanks for sharing! Just an old Viet Grunt, son of a WWII Vet, grandson of a WWI Vet.

There are graveyards of family going long past that as well.

This We'll Defend!

You write well, but you're not a Veteran are you?
 
He passed 8 Feb 1975. He was a Coxswain. God Bless him.

I kind of anticipated this, that someone would look through the list of crew and survivors. Being that you're a Navy Vet as well I will answer. The man I am quite sure you're referencing isn't him. If he died in 1975 it could not be the same man, as I am not off on the years in my story, and also in picking my name to use for him I would not come that close.

Thanks to all for your comments.

I also meant to include one more detail about Wilbur, which I left out: when I read through the history section of his chart thoroughly, I learned that during the attack and his escape, Wilbur received terrible chemical burns on his face and especially his eyes. The burns caused considerable damage and nearly blinded him permanently, and he spent some time in a Navy hospital with his eyes bandaged up after being rescued. The burns left him with the red, droopy looking eyes I described, for the rest of his life.
 
Many Thanks!

for an inspiring story and for not forgetting Wilbur.
 
He knew you were there and was very grateful for your compassion and gentleness, and most of all for your company.

I have mute patients. I also talk to them and look into their eyes. They need to know someone is still aware of their existence.
 
What a sad story. Thank you Geoff. I will always remember.

Barb, I spent the last year or so going to see my mom at a memory care center. I made sure I acknowledged all of the patients and even had conversation with a few. Funny thing is my Mom would always try and help the others too. I get a lot of that kinda stuff from my Mom.

Mom's gone for almost two months now but sometimes I want to go back to see the others.
 
Back
Top