Ethics of using canines in war

Joined
Feb 1, 2011
Messages
6,866
Reaction score
17,186
Location
PRNJ
Human soldiers, especially today, know the risks and volunteer anyway. Thank you for protecting the life and liberty of me and my family.

Canines save many human lives at great risk and I am grateful to them too.
But a well trained dog doesn't have a choice.

How do handlers, especially the ones who truly love their canine partners, deal with this issue?
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Dogs have been used in warfare in various capacities for hundreds if not thousands of years. Wasn't it Shakespeare that said "it is time to cry havoc & let slip the dogs of war"? I'm sure that the handlers form quite a deep attachment to these amazing animals & when worst case scenarios happen, mourn the passing of their beloved partners as much as they would a human comrade in arms.
 
A friends brother was a scout dog handler in Vietnam.He had to leave his dog behind and learned the army would destroy it.Or worse give it to the south Vietnamese .I think he still misses it to this day.
 
A dog being sent into a house that is probably booby trapped does not know what it is being sent to do.

Does the handler feel like a betrayer?

=================================

Some might, I think they would be wrong to do so, it's a dogs life, they serve at our will.

We all love our dogs, but most would agree they are dogs and not the equal of a human life.
 
A friends brother was a scout dog handler in Vietnam.He had to leave his dog behind and learned the army would destroy it.Or worse give it to the south Vietnamese .I think he still misses it to this day.

We left those awesome dogs behind those ,,,,,probably ate them.
Now we bring them home as police dogs.
 
It's better NOT to know...

If you are apprehensive, even scared or petrified, duty still says that you have to go in and try to keep your mind off of getting killed just to do the job. The dog does his duty w/o question. It's sad when a good dog dies, but good men lose their lives all the time. And often they didn't volunteer for it.
 
I would imagine.
the same as sending a police service dog into a drug house.
The dog is sent in to aid and protect the officers to follow.The dog though loved is less valuable than a police officer or Service person.Life decisions are a bitch and no were are you guaranteed of it being fair.As a civilian and a dog companion keeper ,I would gladly give my life to protect my companion He is is a better soul than I

CASEY 2002-2011
 
Last edited:
A friends brother was a scout dog handler in Vietnam.He had to leave his dog behind and learned the army would destroy it.Or worse give it to the south Vietnamese .I think he still misses it to this day.

Had to leave my partner in country as well, Heineken V001. Air Force policy at the time.
 
Dogs have a much better situation than most military horses did. ( More were draft animals than Calvary mounts, and up until fairly recently in history.

Handler sending dog into highly dangerous situation is parallel to company grade ofc sending human solder into highly risky situation.
 
Last edited:
At times, human soldiers also don't choose. A commander may need to conduct "reconnaisance in force" by sending a unit into an area with unknown enemy strength. The small unit is sent to draw enemy fire and thus get an idea of its strength and location. The soldiers of that small unit might not have any idea of what they are being asked to do. War is hell, and sometimes we have to knowingly sacrifice our troops for a greater payoff later. Sending a dog into danger is very similar, but we have to have a lower threshold of concern for a canine than for a human.

I am a dog lover, and my pets have been loved and valued members of my family. But I never forget that human life trumps animal life. That is, for the humans who matter to me.
 
Over the years we have had a few handlers loose their dogs to age and one to a genetic heart defect. ALL of those officers were badly shaken and distraught when their partners passes, especially when the one with the heart issue passed, it happened "on the job" and they ran lights & sirens to the vet's but were too late. These dogs live with their handlers nearly 24/7 they go home with them, interact with the family, BECOME family and the "It's only a dog" frame of mind really doesn't exist anymore. When the dog passes 'on duty' it's the same as one of your human partners, only you know that the dog was doing what it was trained to do, odds are what it loved to do ... work along side you. I'd be willing to bet the dogs do know what they are walking into. their instincts and senses are so much stronger than ours, but still they do it willingly because they do it for us, THEIR family to keep US safe, it's what they do.

I know of one K9 named Lurch (from the Addams Family) because he was so big. One night a vicious stray came onto the property and acted threatening around the handler's wife. Lurch immediately took off after the intruder, but unfortunately didn't stop once the intruder left the property and crossed the street, and Lurch was hit by a car. Many surgeries later, missing his tail, and half of his bowels and with no real strength in his hind legs Lurch STILL wanted to work and protect his family. He would lay around depressed (you could tell) until the handler would grab his collar and give him an aggressive command, such as "Watch him," "Hold him", or even better "Get him." With no power in his back legs the handler could easily hold Lurch back, but when the exercise was done, you could see a change in Lurch's demeanor, he was excited and you could tell he had fun. Lurch was put down shortly after because of the injuries, but you knew that dog would have knowingly died to save you, which in effect he did ... it just wasn't quick.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top