model 10 or model 15
- Thread starter wendal
- Start date
Register to hide this ad
Yes it is. But both are good guns.
JohnK
US Veteran
I too, think the adjustable sights, are worth it.
I have read COUNTLESS opinions, that adjustable sights, are "fragile" for duty use.
Bull. My opinion.
They give you a vastly improved sight picture, and ARE adjustable for various loads.
I've been carrying adj. sighted revolvers for over fifty years, and I have never damaged one.
I also own several Model 10's, but don't try to shoot 1" groups @ 25 yards with them. Not that you cannot, but they are harder to see, for sure.
I have read COUNTLESS opinions, that adjustable sights, are "fragile" for duty use.
Bull. My opinion.
They give you a vastly improved sight picture, and ARE adjustable for various loads.
I've been carrying adj. sighted revolvers for over fifty years, and I have never damaged one.
I also own several Model 10's, but don't try to shoot 1" groups @ 25 yards with them. Not that you cannot, but they are harder to see, for sure.
Targets Guy
US Veteran
I have never adjusted any adjustable sight; including my 1947 K-22. But it is always good to have the ability to.
I vote for getting one of each.
Model 10-7
how do i print screencertificity.com
Model 15-3
images hostingcertificity.com
I vote for getting one of each.
Model 10-7
how do i print screencertificity.comModel 15-3
images hostingcertificity.comBarrel length and intended use..... IMHO are the key in decision making.
Concealed Carry..... 2" Model 10 round butt
Range or open carry/ woods bumming........ 4" Model 15
Coooool factor..... 2" Model 15 or 3" Model 10
Retro:Mall Ninja/Security Guard.......4" Model 10
Concealed Carry..... 2" Model 10 round butt
Range or open carry/ woods bumming........ 4" Model 15
Coooool factor..... 2" Model 15 or 3" Model 10
Retro:Mall Ninja/Security Guard.......4" Model 10
Last edited:
Inusuit
Member
My vote is for the Model 15. As Targetguy says, I also have rarely adjusted sights on my handguns, the exception being ones I used in competition. I am fortunate to own nice examples of both the Model 10 and 15.
cold blue steel
Member
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2017
- Messages
- 26
- Reaction score
- 11
Get them both!! Seriously if you get one, you will prob want the other one too. I have a 10-6 bull barrel and a 15-3 both 4". The 15 will flat drill one after another, but that 10 sure is fun to shoot as well. Good luck!!
bananaman
Member
Forget money. What do you prefer? I tend to like fixed sight K frames with heavy barrel. Do have both though. Decisions are tough sometimes. Good luck on your hunt! Bob
All humans don't see exactly the same as other humans, conversely they don't all see the sights exactly the same either. Adjustable sights are well worth it. Most of mine have been tweaked just a smidge to the right.
Arik
Member
I have never adjusted sights however, I find it easier to sight. It's more similar to semi autos.
That being said I have both and like both
Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk
That being said I have both and like both
Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk
StakeOut
US Veteran
The 15-6 heavy barrel would be my choice of the 2 models but better yet would be a 4" M66 or M19 with hammer mounted firing pins.
I carried a great shooting 1966 Model 10-6 for 20 years and shot many 1000s of rounds from it without any issues.My eyes shot it and all other fixed sight S&W revolvers a tad to the right of point of aim.
I carried a great shooting 1966 Model 10-6 for 20 years and shot many 1000s of rounds from it without any issues.My eyes shot it and all other fixed sight S&W revolvers a tad to the right of point of aim.
bananaman
Member
Another 1, you may wish to consider, is a 67. It is a stainless 15. I have a no dash. It is my wife's favorite to shoot. Bob
just plain joe
Member
I have always preferred adjustable sighted revolvers. When I first came on the job I carried a Model 15. I never experienced any problems with the sights shifting the point of aim/point of impact. I still have the revolver.
For ME, the sights are easier to pick up under exigent circumstances and/or dim light. I also have two Model 10's and a Model 58 that shoot quite well. But I always return to the Model 15.
Find out what works for you and have at it.
Good luck.
JPJ
For ME, the sights are easier to pick up under exigent circumstances and/or dim light. I also have two Model 10's and a Model 58 that shoot quite well. But I always return to the Model 15.
Find out what works for you and have at it.
Good luck.
JPJ
loeman
Member
Totally agree with the above, espcially Coooool factor. The 2" Md 15 with square butt is indeed a really cool gun.
You sir have obviously never had to enter or exit a patrol car in a hurry for any of a number of reasons. It happens, and I've personally seen many of the rear sight blades missing from adjustable sighted revolvers in the old days when I was a LEO. It happens frequently with the rear sight hitting the car door and it eventually takes it toll on the rear blade.
To the OP,.....for range work or woods walking, the adjustable sighted Model 15 is a great revolver, but for serious work as a duty or self defense weapon, I'd opt for the fixed sighted Model 10 for the reasons stated above. As others have stated, the Model 64 and Model 67 are great guns that will have a great resistance to the elements, and I have several of both models which I enjoy. Either one will serve you, and the purpose should determine which will meet your needs the best. It's your decision, and good luck.......
Offhand, I forget how many Model 10s I have. Mostly 2" snubs, a couple of 4" guns. One Model 15 2" snub. We won't even count the Model 64 that I had rebuilt into a 2" snub. I am extremely fond of the fixed sights on the Model 10s and the M64. I spent years in cowboy action shooting and once you get used to the ease of use of fixed sight revolvers the adjustable sights just seem superfluous.
No gripe against those adjustable sights; most of my other S&W revolvers have them, and I have never adjusted one of them, either!
But I carry a 2" K frame Model 10 or Model 64 for a reason.
The OP doesn't give us barrel lengths in his choice or maybe I missed it. if it's a range gun and something for the grandkids I'd say pick the better looking one.
No gripe against those adjustable sights; most of my other S&W revolvers have them, and I have never adjusted one of them, either!
But I carry a 2" K frame Model 10 or Model 64 for a reason.
The OP doesn't give us barrel lengths in his choice or maybe I missed it. if it's a range gun and something for the grandkids I'd say pick the better looking one.
diegobxr
Member
Can't really go wrong with either one.
M10 = Hand Ejector, Military and Police, being made since 1899 non-stop, an iconic firearm, the quintessential revolver.
M15 = Essentially a M10 with adj. sights. Called the Combat Masterpiece.
Just listen to that... Masterpiece.
You obviously need both. And you have reminded me how much I need an M15 myself.
PS: Don't forget that you also need an M19 - Combat Magnum. (Basically an M15 in .357 Magnum).
M10 = Hand Ejector, Military and Police, being made since 1899 non-stop, an iconic firearm, the quintessential revolver.
M15 = Essentially a M10 with adj. sights. Called the Combat Masterpiece.
Just listen to that... Masterpiece.
You obviously need both. And you have reminded me how much I need an M15 myself.
PS: Don't forget that you also need an M19 - Combat Magnum. (Basically an M15 in .357 Magnum).
Last edited:
- Joined
- Aug 9, 2005
- Messages
- 9,277
- Reaction score
- 11,527
I've been shooting both for decades. Fine guns, no doubt, but I prefer the looks of the M15. S&W sight blades are slightly fragile and a blow at the right point can bend or damage them, though I've only seen this once. If you get used to the rear sight picture on the Model 10, I don't think it's any better or worse than a Model 15s sights.
I believe the Model 10's heavy barrel makes it a bit easier to shoot well. The 15 always seemed a bit light up front to me, but it will certainly shoot as well as the Model 10. The Model 10 will usually shoot heavy bullets to point of aim or close to it.
My personal observations only and I don't expect everyone to agree...
I believe the Model 10's heavy barrel makes it a bit easier to shoot well. The 15 always seemed a bit light up front to me, but it will certainly shoot as well as the Model 10. The Model 10 will usually shoot heavy bullets to point of aim or close to it.
My personal observations only and I don't expect everyone to agree...
