Mod 66-2, 2 1/2” $700 cash rejected

[Fide686]

In my travels yesterday, I checked out a gun shop an hour and a half from home. Nothing in the case looked interesting, so I asked" 'Have any 66 pre-lock 2& a half inch Smith's?"

The owner went in back and came out with a nice dash 2. It had no price so of course I said "It's free?" He said that he would have to look up a price. I gave him a low offer just to see how he would react; no go. I gave him my #, but did not get a call.

The next day, I got $700 with the plan of making him a cash offer. The gun was in good shape, with the only fault was tha the barrel was very very slightly not perfectly indexed.

I offered him $650 cash, which he turned down. I said that I didn't know what he had into it, but gave him a final cash offer of the $700 that I brought. He said that it didn't matter what he had into it, but said he wanted $700 plus tax. So he lost a sale for $56?

I thanked him for his time and left. In the past year or so I made several reloading supplies from his store.

Your thoughts?

 

[Sevens]

My initial thought was that you gave him a junk offer to begin with, one that must have been pretty bad (you didn't share with us just how low it actually was...)

The guy has a gun store. Unless it's only been open three weeks I'll guess he knows what he's doing and he's get his $700+tax eventually.

If you're offended that he didn't accept any of your three offers, that's fine also, certainly your right.

I honestly don't believe there is a whole lot to dissect here.

 

[pmosley]

He thinks you'll be back tomorrow with a full offer.

Sent from my SM-T530NU using Tapatalk

 

[Struckat]

It'll be gone tomorrow.

 

[Eddietruett]

I would think any gun shop should be able to get $700 plus tax for a nice 2.5" Model 66. I'm surprised it wasn't in the case marked $799 to leave him a little negotiating room. I saw several at the last gun show marked $850. Still there when I left too!

 

[Telecaster]

If these are $700, they sure went up in price fast. I thought I overpaid for mine a year ago at $650.

 

[apollo99]

These snubby K & L frames pre-locks are commanding high dollars. $700+ tax seems about right. It's a good thing I have a few of these things lying around, I would hate to have to pay today's prices.

 

[Loyaljeeper]

The 2.5" 66s are bringing insane dollars now. I saw one last week, in a shop that is normally very reasonable, disappear in less than a week for the asking price of $800. It was killing me to know what it brought because I have one. They said they stood firm on the price and the guy came back with a partial trade. I immediately started thinking I could never bring myself to start carrying my near perfect 66 snub.

 

[ImDrRich]

I think you should have paid the $56 and then you would have gotten a great deal. They're not making anymore of them.

 

[G-Mac]

The gun was in good shape, with the only fault was that the barrel was very very slightly not perfectly indexed.

That would have been the deal-breaker for me.

 

[ken158]

You're "it's free" comment did not amuse him and he locked down on you. You will pay more then someone else if you end up buying it. Maybe not, but when I had a part time shop, it worked that way... but maybe that's just me.

 

[kraynky]

I paid $625 for my -1 earlier this year when a friend offered his up for sale. He works at a LGS and knew I like older Smiths. I didn't dicker with him, because I knew if I ever ran across another one locally, it would likely be listed at the $699,or worse. People are hanging on to them more since the freakish "gold rush" we recently went through has settled down some.

You might as well take the $56 bucks back and see if he'll let you keep half of it. Methinks it was in the back because he either didn't really want to sell it, or he's waiting for the next panic buying spree and will then ask $850. It's like land, "they stopped making that too"..

 

[Laketime]

You're "it's free" comment did not amuse him and he locked down on you. You will pay more then someone else if you end up buying it. Maybe not, but when I had a part time shop, it worked that way... but maybe that's just me.

I agree because it is probaly the most used and annoying cliche people love to drop when visiting a retail establishment if something isn't priced.

 

[Dieseltech56]

I have never had good negotiations when dealing with a gun store in their home territory aka the store front. Some places flat out won't budge and some only budge $50 or so from the list price. If you want what you want then you have to pay. If you already have 3 at home then I could understand walking away.

I've got a nickel 19-3 2.5" TH/TT on layaway and I tried to get it for $800 out the door. Wasn't happening, I had to cough up another $35 for that one.

 

[Tom_R]

2.5" 19's and 66's that are pre-lock are strong sellers now.

$750 is the right price, but I am a little surprised he didn't do $700 for you.

The 'free' comment may have budged him in the wrong direction, or maybe he just had a number he was not going to move off of and that was it.

Sometimes a deal just doesn't happen.

 

[CelticSire]

I've bought more than a few guns by asking the seller, "What's your best price?" followed by "You're not going to hurt my feelings, I know you have to make a living". Whatever price they tell me is the price I'm either prepared to pay, or decide it's too much. Either way I thank them for their time, and if it's more than I'm prepared to pay right then, I'll either tell them I'll think about it and get back with them, or tell them I'm not prepared to pay what they're asking. And I always get back in touch, either to let them know I'll take it if the price is still good, or let them know I'm not. 9 times out of 10, when I ask for their best price, it's lower than what I would have offered initially. My daddy always told me, "Son, never be the first one to give a price. Let the other fellow be the one to do it." Pretty good advice that's worked well for me.

 

[dr. mordo]

I typed out a long reply, but ultimately:

1. I think $700 was a fair price, and I wouldn't pay more just because market prices are a bit inflated right now. I paid $600 for a almost mint M19-3 snubbie last year; I might have paid $700, but not $756 to that guy.
2. I don't think I'd go back to that gun store, because the owner's practices bug me. I personally would rather give my money to someone else.

 

[Loyaljeeper]

Yeah, they can be that rediculous in price. https://www.gunbroker.com/item/776963319

 

[Clarke Hammer]

I typed out a long reply, but ultimately:

1. I think $700 was a fair price, and I wouldn't pay more just because market prices are a bit inflated right now. I paid $600 for a almost mint M19-3 snubbie last year; I might have paid $700, but not $756 to that guy.
2. I don't think I'd go back to that gun store, because the owner's practices bug me. I personally would rather give my money to someone else.

Which of the owner's practices bug you? All we know about his practices from the OP is that the owner turned down three offers for his merchandise that he felt were too low. He stated his desired price, which the OP rejected. The OP questioned the owner's willingness to lose a sale over $56 -- another perspective is that the OP lost a purchase over the same $56.

 

[mauiblue]

My approach would be, "What price are you looking for?" when I would have first seen the gun. At that point I would have tried to analyze what was kind of wiggle room I would have in negotiations.

I would have dug deep and just pay the $56 above what I came in with.

Sent from my coconut frond hut using Tapatalk