Miami_JBT
US Veteran
For quite a while now, I have kept desirability and resale value as prerequisites for the purchase of any gun, so I would always go with Colt.
However, the first 1911-type pistol I bought was a Springfield Armory plain matte finish "Mil Spec" 1911 A-1 more than thirty years ago. It has held up incredibly well and has been fired a lot, almost exclusively with cast bullets. Maybe a copy, but it has been about as good a pistol as any Colt I've had, though no better. If I had spent a little more in the beginning, I could have bought a Colt. If I attempt to sell the Springfield gun, it will bring considerably less than a Colt. For these reasons, I'd go with the original.
The Springfields hold their value. Look for what a used Mil-Spec goes for these days. It is crazy.