Lawsuit: Calif. Woman Held for 13 Days After Case of Mistaken Identity

Joined
Sep 6, 2006
Messages
3,707
Reaction score
6,358
Location
KY - 4 Rivers
Lawsuit: Calif. Woman Held for 13 Days After Case of Mistaken Identity
Bethany Farber was stopped at LAX because she had same name as wanted woman

(NEWSER) California woman Bethany Farber is suing the Los Angeles Police Department, saying they wrongfully detained her for 13 days including three days after they allegedly realized they had the wrong Bethany Farber. The 30-year-old aesthetician says her nightmarish experience began in April last year, when she was detained at Los Angeles International Airport as she tried to board a plane to join her family for a vacation in Mexico, the Guardian reports. She says she was told there was a warrant out for her arrest in Texas and TSA agents refused her pleas to double-check their information after she told them she had never even been to Texas. they completely blew me off," Farber tells ABC7. "They said, 'Nope, Bethany Farber, we have you.'"

TSA agents passed Farber to LAX police, who turned her over to the LAPD. She was held without bail at the Lynwood women's jail. Attorney Rodney Biggs says Farber was apparently viewed as a flight risk because she was leaving the country, but authorities failed to check "basic information that Bethany was not the other Farber," Fox 11 reports. "The fact no one checked her middle name, her birth date. No information representing her person," he says. "The woman wanted for property damage in Texas has an "extensive criminal history," Biggs says. "Her fingerprints are in the data base." Farber, whose family hired lawyers in California and Texas as they tried to free her, does not physically resemble the other woman.

Relatives say the Texas prosecutor promised to expedite Farber's release after receiving photos and phone records proving Farber was in California on the day of the crime. Farber, who says her only previous trouble with the law was a speeding ticket when she was 16, is also suing the city and airport police for allegedly violating her civil rights. According to her lawsuit, the stress of her ordeal caused her grandmother to have a stroke that led to her death. She said this week that her time in jail was "traumatic" and she was emotionally scarred by the wrongful arrest and imprisonment. "It could happen to anyone," she said.

Lawsuit: Calif. Woman Held for 13 Days After Case of Mistaken Identity
 
Register to hide this ad
You would think that verifying the identity of someone arrested on a warrant would be routine, let alone when that person is vehemently denying that they are that person named in the warrant.

I guess procedures must be a little different in California than they are here in cornfields and cows country.
 
My brother was a service tech/assembler for a large machine tool company. He traveled around the country and to Europe, Asia and South America.

On two separate occasions he was detained in NY and held for several days as his name was on the FBI No-Fly list. They took their sweet time clearing him of the ID mix up and both times TSA confiscated his tool boxes. He never got them back.
 
You would think that verifying the identity of someone arrested on a warrant would be routine, let alone when that person is vehemently denying that they are that person named in the warrant.

I guess procedures must be a little different in California than they are here in cornfields and cows country.

Maybe part of their criminal reform is to only arrest the innocent while letting the guilty go free.
 
We know there are darn few GUILTY people in prison. LOL

Should be some pretty basic things to verify like photograph, height, weight, SSN, D/O/B., etc.

Yeah, she'll make bank on this one. An insurance company will pony up and they'll just wait for the next one.
 
My brother was a service tech/assembler for a large machine tool company. He traveled around the country and to Europe, Asia and South America.

On two separate occasions he was detained in NY and held for several days as his name was on the FBI No-Fly list. They took their sweet time clearing him of the ID mix up and both times TSA confiscated his tool boxes. He never got them back.

Nothing new, back in early 80's when machine tool tech, got a surprise trip to Peoria to fix a machine. In a rush I packed my socket holder with dic pins, ratchet, dial mic, mag. base and some other tools I figured I needed in my brief case as carry on. Xray of case had some female operator have a cow. Got pulled aside and asked to open case. "They said, looks like you have a bullet clip and a timer in your case". Tried to explain everything to them but they lacked the mental ability to comprehend simple tools. Missed the flight. I simply called our president and told him. Maybe half an hour later I got ok to board the next flight to Chicago from some higher up in the airline. He mentioned they received a phone call straightening things out. When back in shop our president came by saying he called the airline and raised holy ——- telling them if they could not find more intelligent people to work the gate we were changing airlines. Doubt this would fly today, LOL.
 
Just curious, was the trip to Cat?

Nothing new, back in early 80's when machine tool tech, got a surprise trip to Peoria to fix a machine. In a rush I packed my socket holder with dic pins, ratchet, dial mic, mag. base and some other tools I figured I needed in my brief case as carry on. Xray of case had some female operator have a cow. Got pulled aside and asked to open case. "They said, looks like you have a bullet clip and a timer in your case". Tried to explain everything to them but they lacked the mental ability to comprehend simple tools. Missed the flight. I simply called our president and told him. Maybe half an hour later I got ok to board the next flight to Chicago from some higher up in the airline. He mentioned they received a phone call straightening things out. When back in shop our president came by saying he called the airline and raised holy ——- telling them if they could not find more intelligent people to work the gate we were changing airlines. Doubt this would fly today, LOL.
 
She is going to be quite rich as well as her lawyers.
Lazy,Stupid Ignorance on the LEO's parts. Several of them need to be terminated, no excuse this day and age.

Perhaps this illustrates a basic problem with bureaucracies. No one really responsible for anything as long as they just follow the procedures dictated by the top floor bunch.

TSA calls in a "hit" on a passenger based upon their passenger screening protocols. LAPD responds, runs name/DOB/etc through the nationwide system, confirms the existence of a warrant, takes the woman to jail. At booking she is fingerprinted and photographed and the paperwork is forwarded to records & identification for processing. R&I clerk works down to the bottom of the incoming stack, maybe gets everything entered into the system a few days later.

Agency holding the warrant may receive the photos and fingerprints a few days after the arrest. Then their R&I people proceed to work through their incoming stack until everything is entered in their system. Maybe once per shift, or once per day, or once in a while, the next step is comparing everything to the existing records.

Oops, no match. Someone needs to notify LAPD and LASO. What is the protocol for that? Doesn't happen frequently, so management has to review the matter and assign someone to do the follow-up. Better double-check everything, just to be sure, maybe back into an in basket for verification.

Finally, official notification from the originating agency to LA authorities. Such discrepancies aren't all that common, so there will have to be some decisions made on what to do, who should do it, etc. Maybe another day or two to get all the ducks lined up.

Easy enough to say that such incidents should be a high priority for everyone involved. But the reality is that this is just one more bit of information that has to be documented, filed, transmitted, and dealt with along with many thousands of other little bits of information. The administration never considered this sort of thing while building their systems or training their people, so it becomes an exception to be dealt with separately, as time and schedules permit.

Reality really sucks at times. I feel for the lady, and she deserves significant compensation and consideration for her ordeal. Meanwhile, the powers in charge need to re-evaluate every aspect of their procedures and modify everything that failed in such a case. Perfection is the ideal goal, but seldom seen in any human endeavor, particularly in a bureaucracy wherein compliance is the ultimate standard and anyone who raises a potential problem can easily be identified as the problem.

TSA, LAPD, LASO, and probably other entities will pony up some big bucks, all at taxpayer expense, and the world will have a few more millionaires. Whether or not the system is revised, and how effective any revisions might be, will remain to be seen.

I suspect the next time will involve entirely different deficiencies.
 
TSA detained a handcuffed drunk woman in a closed room un seen by supervision in Phoenix. The woman tried to escape the cuffs resulting her suffocation and death.
 
Back
Top