Canon or Nikon?

I'm a Nikon guy... but I think making a decision comes down to both ergonomics and the shooting menus/controls. I always found Nikon bodies held better... but what always really got me where the Canon menus and navigation. Don't know why, just didn't like them.

The problem with really good glass is that it's heavy. I had a ton of high-end glass, and paired myself down to three primes: 35 1.4g, 50 1.4g and 85mm 1.4g. The first and third of these are especially expensive. But even paired down to these three basic (and AWESOME) lenses... I *still* find that they are more often than not too heavy to take with me. Especially on trips. Lately, I have to carry so much stuff on the plane, the the last thing I want is a heavy camera bag (these lenses are heavy!) that I constantly have to worry about once I am in a hotel. I am a serious photography buff... but the last two years, I haven't taken my camera and rig barely anywhere. Too much hassle. I took it to NASCAR two years ago, got AMAZING photos, but boy it was a miserably long day hauling that stuff all over that monster facility. Like most people I don't print many photos at all, so (sadly) the iPhone is becoming a more and more acceptable alternative for the day-to-day stuff.

Consider mirrorless or if you are going to spend the money for expensive glass, maybe a Leica. If you can really shoot, you can get the images from either of these, with a lot more discretion and less back pain.
 
This is HORRIBLE......

Shutter Delay One of the biggest annoyances I have with DSLR is shutter delay. I want the photo when I dipress the shutter button. Not a half second later. I want it now. For fast moving images and those shots that just can't wait, having a shutter that takes the picture after the event has passed is worthless. Airshows, sporting events, nature, etc. don't wait for your camera to make up its mind when it will do what you asked it to do. I want it now. Right now.

This is a HORRIBLE aspect of digital cameras. My little Nikon was better than any other cameras I've had as far as this goes. THAT would be a question I would ask first!
 
I can't really comment on Canon DSLR's because I've never used them.

I'm a Nikon user myself. I started using a D70 about 10 years ago when the sheriff's department bought me one for use on the job. I liked it so well I bought one out of pocket for myself and I have loved them both.

In February I upgraded to a Nikon D5300 and a new Tamron 70-300mm lens. I love the erogonomics of the D5300, and though it has a smaller size than my D70 it is much more featured, including the wi-fi capability to communicate with my iPhone.

Here are a few pictures I've taken lately with the Nikon D5300, and I'm not really that experianced with it yet.


1796986_644063578993082_1032647725_o.jpg


1553336_665070810225692_588243837759989284_o.jpg
 
Last edited:
There is a web site called dpreview go there and you will learn everything you need to know. I use a Nikon D-800 and love it , but Canon is equally good.
 
This thread is relevant to my interests (if I could stop buying revolvers!). I've been getting by with an old Canon G6 and have been thinking of taking the plunge with a DSLR kit.

Bill Bates: Thanks for posting informative info and photos - those two macro shots are amazing!

Matt -
 
Don't know if this is a good deal or not but thought I'd offer it up. Next cycle they'll have a Canon bundle :)

Nikon D3300 DSLR Camera 2 Lens Bundle


That is a very good price for an excellent all around beginners kit. The D3300 is very highly rated for its excellent sensor resolution and high ISO, low light performance. You can also use older, used, relatively inexpensive manual focus Nikon glass on the camera, something the Canon mount cant do with its older glass.

Larry
 
Last edited:
...The camera is just the tool, it's what's behind the lens that counts! ;)

I didn't read the whole thread but there is a nugget for you. This forum has some very capable photogs so I am sure there was a lot of good advice. As to Canon vs. Nikon, both are good if comparing apples and apples. Study both lines carefully and make your choice based on what is best for you. Low cost variable ("zoom") lenses will eventually be a disappointment for you, so don't devote too much consideration to them. Also, consider what camera feels good in your hands. You have to hold the camera still anytime it is not on a tripod so it is just like a pistol - harder to hold still if not comfortable to you.

Honestly, neither of the cameras you mention are "big boys" models. If you possibly can, save a bit more money for your purchase and look to a model 2-3 levels up the performance scale.

My son has a Nikon D90 which I consider a VERY nice camera (unfortunately discontinued) but it is proof to me that you don't have to go top-end to get a superior camera. Sometimes the middle ground is perfectly adequate for what you are doing, but usually the entry level equipment is just that. Sooner or later you will want something better - usually much sooner.

All JMHO, of course, but based on a lot of years of camera-tinkering. Good luck with your purchase.
 
Honestly, neither of the cameras you mention are "big boys" models. If you possibly can, save a bit more money for your purchase and look to a model 2-3 levels up the performance scale.

My son has a Nikon D90 which I consider a VERY nice camera (unfortunately discontinued) but it is proof to me that you don't have to go top-end to get a superior camera. Sometimes the middle ground is perfectly adequate for what you are doing, but usually the entry level equipment is just that. Sooner or later you will want something better - usually much sooner.

All JMHO, of course, but based on a lot of years of camera-tinkering. Good luck with your purchase.

This is so true. It is better to save a little longer and spend your money once. Just moving up one level in camera body with both Canon and Nikon gets you a much more capable and user friendly tool. For Canon that would be a Canon 70D and I think for Nikon it would be the Nikon D7100.
 
Like I said, I don't know his budget or desire or long term goals or capabilities and I was just tossing out something at a decent price point. Where I disagree is jumping in too high until you know your capabilities and your long term interest. Everyone buys differently. Go read some of the Sport threads!!!! I love my Sport :)
 
Thanks to all for this post. Very informative and I will be returning here as I shop for a new Brownie . Really is nice to get some professional advice on something as complex as camera choices.
 
When I first starting using good camera's in the old film days (Kodachrome ruled, then came Velvia), I shopped for a camera. I was told many times that Canon cameras were metal coated plastic, whereas Nikon was plastic coated metal. I worked with some professional photographers then who took aviation photos...from inside the jet. About every one used Nikon because of its ruggedness (pulling 6+ G's and letting go of the camera can be a bad thing in the cockpit!).

I also liked the metal Nikon shutter curtains compared to the fabric of the Canon. I bought Nikon...Nikkormat, FE2, FM2, etc. One thing I liked about Nikon...lenses made 50 years ago still work on cameras from today. Canon has changed things over time and lenses are not backward compatible. THAT made many upset as their glass was now useless. But then along came digital.

I stayed with Nikon as my old lenses still work! My agency uses only Nikon as well, so when shooting crime scenes, I use all Nikon gear. I currently use the D600 or D800. I prefer the D800, but the D600 is a champ. Using 64 GB cards, I can take over 128 GB's worth of 24-36 mega pixel photos. I can save the RAW (or NEF) image on one card, and have J-PEG Fine on the other.

Buy the best you can afford and shop around. Use review sites, but be careful as some have a vested interest in one brand over another.
 
I stayed with Nikon as my old lenses still work!

Similar story here - one my favorite lenses is my almost 50 yr old 55mm/f3.5 micro Nikkor that I bought new back in the late 60's. I use it for a lot of gun photos as well as general macro work. Sure it's manual focusing, but it is still silky smooth and a pleasure to use. You can still buy these old gems today - I've seen some for $50-$75 at times - quite a bargain.

Here's mine:

Image%2020060607_130743-L.jpg
 
photographs don't lie but, Photoshop Does!
 

Attachments

  • BadDay1.jpg
    BadDay1.jpg
    36.4 KB · Views: 20
  • BadDay2.jpg
    BadDay2.jpg
    36.3 KB · Views: 21
  • BadDay3.jpg
    BadDay3.jpg
    39.8 KB · Views: 21
As others have said, hard to go wrong with either Canon or Nikon and that you need to find the right one that fits you and is comfortable for you to handle. Another thing would be to check the interface and see which suits you better. If you don't like the interface and/or it's not comfortable to handle then it doesn't matter how well it works as you won't be totally happy in my opinion.

For me, I love my Canons! Both my brothers have Nikon and they love them. I was initially going to go Nikon when I was going to switch to digital but my 1 brother got a great deal on a used Canon Rebel at the time and gave it to me as my other cameras had died. I've been hooked on Canon ever since. That Rebel went everywhere with me and I learned a LOT using it.

Then I hooked up with my guy and he was all Canon as well so it was a no brainer for me to stick with it when the poor Rebel finally died. I now have a 5D and absolutely love it! This house will stay Canon for a long time with no regrets.:D

Here's some shots with my 5D.

Macro (one of my favorite things to do!)
bee_PR14_0129.jpg


Landscape
landscape_PR_3691.jpg


Low light
other_PR_5768.jpg

ladyspring_PR14_0130.jpg


Hummingbirds in flight (speed!)
Hummingbird_PR12_8104.jpg

hummingbird_PR12_8188.jpg

hummingbird_PR12_8195.jpg
 
Been with Canon for 41 Years!

I can't say anything negative or positive about Nikon as I have never owned one. I started with a Canon FTb in 1973 and moved to an F1 and then into the electronic film series etc. etc. I also shoot a little with my Leica film camera. However, I currently am elated with my 7D. I have a standard zoom for general pics but my all time favorite lens is my S series 100 mm macro. An amazing lens!
 
Oh my goodness...........this is like going to Baskin Robbins, what to choose, what to choose.

I meant to include my budget would be less than $800. Also my idea of a "big boys" camera was a step up from my pocket point and shoot. I never want to buy the cheapest but never want the best either.

Was planning on going out to put my hands on them but weather dictates we stay in.

Thanks guys!!!!!
 
Back
Top