Mitch Rosen OWB leather, Model 5JR. Shield 3" and 4" fit is the same. Kinda like kydex snap/click fit molding with leather comfortability, and it lasts and lasts.
Galco models just squeezes the gun, and molding is ****.
It's fubared. Doubt S&W will do anything warranty related because it has been modified by a bubba mouthbreather.
Bring the pretendo gunsmith company to small claims court. It wont be worth their time fighting it.
Fwiw, you'll have the same result clamping on the rail & torquing the muzzle...
Another vote for the Mitch Rosen mag holder.
The formed fit is superior to other leather products in the price range, and it has a kydex like snap fit especially holsters. Worth another $30ish more to get something comfortable to wear.
In case y'all want to help me get Mitch Rosen on board, please send them some inquiries on the shield plus 4". They've been accumulating a list already of interested customers.
Contact | Mitch Rosen Extraordinary Gunleather