Care of an Aluminum cylinder

pete3240

Member
Joined
Mar 14, 2014
Messages
58
Reaction score
7
Location
Iowa
I have a Mod. 17-8 that I'm told has an Aluminum cylinder. Is there anything special I need to do to clean it? Never had a revolver with this type cylinder so my usual routine when cleaning is to scrub it out with a bronze brush. Thinking this might not be a good idea with Aluminum.

Pete
 
Register to hide this ad
I'd first verify that it is aluminum by checking it with a magnet. If they attract, it's steel. If not, aluminum.
If it is aluminum, I'd call S&W tech support to get their opinion.
 
Andy05,

The cylinder doesn't hold a magnet,
.

TucsonMTB,

Thanks for the thread on aluminum cylinders. Does'not address the cleaning issue. A little background on the gun. I bought it at a local gun show. Took it home, cleaned it up a bit and took it to the range. Shooting CCI SV. After the first cylinder the shells were a little sticky going in and coming out. After the second cylinder full I had to tap the ejector rod to get the cases to come out. Took the gun home and cleaned it out good using a bronze brush. Am running a test to see how many rds. it'll take to get sticky again. No problems after a coupla hundred rounds.

So the problem still is..... How to you clean/maintain an Aluluminum cylinder and how aggressive to you dare get before doing damage to it.

Pete
 
Last edited:
You might try using nylon brushes on the cylinder, after letting it soak with Hoppe's for a few hours. If that works, problem solved. Otherwise I am not sure what to suggest. I have never owned a gun with an aluminum cylinder.
 
So the problem still is..... How to you clean/maintain an Aluminum cylinder and how aggressive to you dare get before doing damage to it.

Pete
Hey Pete!

I know that my wife's 22 revolver collects enough crusty, waxy buildup from between 100 and 150 lubricated rounds from Eley, Aguila, or Fiocchi ammunition that it needs attention. It will go many hundreds of rounds with CCI Mini-Mag ammo that does not seem to have any lubricant applied.

If the bullet lubricant residue is also your issue, you might want to try something that dissolves the wax. Brake cleaner and WD-40 remove it quickly, after which I use conventional gun cleaning lubricants, like WeaponShield. I am not pushing any specific product. Anything that contains a non-polar solvent will work well to remove the wax. That would include most oil based cleaners.

Scrubbing is less of an issue for me with a steel cylinder, but I have to admit to doing almost none and to using a nylon 22 caliber brush most of the time. A good wax solvent does the hard work, in my experience.

As I understand it, the layer of anodizing on aluminum is fairly hard. I do know that, during the process of applying an anodized finish, the clear layer resulting from the electrical anodizing process is dyed to whatever color is desired. So, I would avoid anything containing bleaching agents, like ammonia. Sorry, but that is not based on first hand experience, just normal care of anodized aluminum gear, mostly for bicycling.

Fortunately . . . with any luck, someone who has one will come along with more "real world" experience. At least, I hope so. We have a lot of talented and experienced people here.
 
TucsonMTB,

Thanks for the great reply.

I was thinking of the nylon brush, but, DUH, hadn't thot the bullet lube was the problem. Should have dawned on me since the lot of CCI has an excess amout of lube on it and tends to gum up auto mag.'s till they FTF unless cleaned after every match in our Winter League. Will get/keep a can of brake cleaner on hand.

Pete
 
I have a Mod. 17-8 that I'm told has an Aluminum cylinder. Is there anything special I need to do to clean it? Never had a revolver with this type cylinder so my usual routine when cleaning is to scrub it out with a bronze brush. Thinking this might not be a good idea with Aluminum.

Pete
I just bought a 361c and heard the same thing so I use mineral oil and nylon brushes just to be safe.
 
I have a Mod. 17-8 that I'm told has an Aluminum cylinder. Is there anything special I need to do to clean it? Never had a revolver with this type cylinder so my usual routine when cleaning is to scrub it out with a bronze brush. Thinking this might not be a good idea with Aluminum.

Pete


As mentioned, use a nylon bore brush to clean the chambers. Use a nylon cleaning brush on the cylinder face as well.

I have a 617-2 with the alloy cylinder, so I'm always careful with its cleaning. I wouldn't use anything with any sort of ammonia in the cleaning solution either. Aluminum can gall (for lack of a better word) with certain chemicals.

I was wholly unaware of a 17 having an alloy cylinder! This is why I love this site so.
 
Back
Top