Combat Masterpiece prices

ammodave

Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2010
Messages
303
Reaction score
140
City & State/Province
Niceville, Fl
I'm retired Air Force and my required firearms qualification was always with a Combat Masterpiece which I usually shot very well. I have about a half dozen S&W revolvers from .22 to .44 but no Model 15. I'm hankering to remedy that. What's the going rate for a minty Model 15 (box and paperwork not important)? I see asst conditions on various websites from $500 to over $1K. I'm willing to pay the going rate just don't want to get burned.
 
I am retired Air Force as well. My career field required annual qualification on the Model 15 and I really loved the gun, so while on active duty in 1981, I purchased a Model 15-4 new. It was my first S&W, I have kept it all these years and it is still my favorite. I think you have some good guidance here on price range, so I won't offer any advice. Really depends on the condition.

Gun and Knives.1.webp
 
OP-You mentioned in your post you wanted minty condition. That being so in my opinion you are going to be in $600-$800 range. I value my 15-3 (1974) in that range. 95%+ bluing and grips numbered to the revolver. Shown with the S&W branded lined holster I bought at the same auction 10 years ago. Probably the best .38 special revolver that S&W made.IMG_0093.webp
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't take $700.00 for my 15-3. I couldn't find a suitable replacement for the money.
None of mine are leaving my greedy grasp for that little...The time and fuel spent finding them, the meticulous cleanup afterward and the documentation I put with each means I'll have them a long time before anyone agrees with my values...And that's fine with me because I bought them all because I like them, and with the intention of keeping them...People who think they should be able to buy mine for what they heard their neighbor's cousin's friend bought his at a distant gun show are dreaming...;)...Ben
 
I'm retired Air Force and my required firearms qualification was always with a Combat Masterpiece which I usually shot very well. I have about a half dozen S&W revolvers from .22 to .44 but no Model 15. I'm hankering to remedy that. What's the going rate for a minty Model 15 (box and paperwork not important)? I see asst conditions on various websites from $500 to over $1K. I'm willing to pay the going rate just don't want to get burned.
$ 700. Sounds reasonable
 
I've seen Model 19's billed as "Combat Magnums."
As Truckman pointed out, the names remained when model numbers were added.

e.g., Model 19 Combat Magnum, Model 14 K-38 Masterpiece, Model 15 .38 Combat Masterpiece. Model 34 .22/32 Kit Gun and so on and so on.
 
Here's two that sold yesterday on Sunday at an auction north of me..

First is a 15-3 with nice targets....Hammer price was $350 plus fees

Second is a 15-2....Hammer price on it was $280 plus fees

View attachment 882716

View attachment 882717
Good score. I only own a M10-5. Skinny barrel, square magna grips, fixed sights. By SN shows 1972 production. Paid $175 in 1982, still have it, brought me home as an armed guard, small town Deputy Marshal, later on Deputy Sheriff. Then issued Glock 22, 40 cal.
 
Ex Air Force here. Model 15 was the first center fire revolver I ever shot back in the late 60s. I have two that I acquired in the last few years. One has history and some holster wear. the other is pretty minty. Both were had for under $600 and are wonderful shooters.
 
For me I care more about how they shoot than how they look. My last combat masterpiece I bought ( 4 screw, no model number) came out of a plastic tote full of police trades. Rough on the outside, mechanically perfect and shoots great. When accuracy is the primary consideration I reach for a revolver! I had a battered looking model 10 that I could group tighter at 50 yards than a semi custom 1911.
 
I'm retired Air Force and my required firearms qualification was always with a Combat Masterpiece which I usually shot very well. I have about a half dozen S&W revolvers from .22 to .44 but no Model 15. I'm hankering to remedy that. What's the going rate for a minty Model 15 (box and paperwork not important)? I see asst conditions on various websites from $500 to over $1K. I'm willing to pay the going rate just don't want to get burned.
Get plenty of pics. Know that jus cuz seller says it’s a 95-percent doesn’t mean anything. I bought a 66 no dash off this forum…guy thinning herd…95-percent…. Unfortunately I learned in detail what slow take-up and end shake looks and feels like, AS THE NEW OWNER. Yes, once I send it to Nelson Ford of Phoenix AZ, “Tge Gunsmith” it will be 95-percent and issues remedied. I will be several hundred dollars more invested too. So, buyer beware. Some folks are straight shooters and honest/-some are less knowledgeable or simply prone to the sin of lying…to seller. Pics, know your seller if possible.
 
I agree...I probably should have bought the one with targets, but oh well....I actually never bid on it because I thought it would go higher than that.
You did fine. I paid around $900 for mine which is about 50 years young 🙂. I understand you pecking and scratching like a chicken at the auction sites. Sucumbbed to same behavior last week and found I won the bid ona Winchester 9422 XTR mfg in 1979 with the fancy early year uncheckered stock… the ones with the deep luster (like a Browning Super Grade) and tiger butler wood…Wow, like I need another 22 rifle—a brother to my Marlin 39-A. Need to sell off my CZ 452., YES, in a True 95-percent condition.😊
 
Ex Air Force here. Model 15 was the first center fire revolver I ever shot back in the late 60s. I have two that I acquired in the last few years. One has history and some holster wear. the other is pretty minty. Both were had for under $600 and are wonderful shooters.
I do notice that here in the people’s republic of Vermont there are few vintage smiths around. A lot of polyester auto Blocks, er tge G name. Makes taking a trip to south, west and Midwest a luring thing…so many gun shops with the vintage revolvers g F’d olds in my age bracket and older are selling off. Called Estate sell finds, many times consignments, but o digress.
 
Get plenty of pics. Know that jus cuz seller says it’s a 95-percent doesn’t mean anything. I bought a 66 no dash off this forum…guy thinning herd…95-percent…. Unfortunately I learned in detail what slow take-up and end shake looks and feels like, AS THE NEW OWNER. Yes, once I send it to Nelson Ford of Phoenix AZ, “Tge Gunsmith” it will be 95-percent and issues remedied. I will be several hundred dollars more invested too. So, buyer beware. Some folks are straight shooters and honest/-some are less knowledgeable or simply prone to the sin of lying…to seller. Pics, know your seller if possible.
Welcome to the current world of firearm sellers! You are absolutely on your own looking for a "nice" revolver these days. When you haven't got the firearm in hand for examination you are at the mercy of the seller to give an accurate description of the item. Even if a firearm looks nice in pictures it doesn't mean it is worth a hoot when you get it. I wanted a "nice" Model 17 to go with my Model 14 and I scoured the usual haunts and finally found what I wanted far away in Texas. In pictures it was perfect, it had target trigger and hammer and didn't at all look beat up, but the grips were not original to the pistol. So I spun the wheel and took a chance for $950.00. I was rewarded with a revolver with excess end shake, a maximum width B/C gap and super sticky empty shell extraction.

At that point I was placed into the predicament of what to do with the revolver, so I took it to my local gunsmith for a professional lookover. The biggie for me was the B/C gap being at maximum and the gunsmith verified this. Can't do much to fix that issue and will have to live with it. Everything else was fixable for a price. I took care of the sticky empty issue myself with a cylinder hone.

Would I have bought this $900.00 revolver if it was at a LGS and I could examine it in person? I can't answer that because it did have what I wanted on it. Target hammers and triggers don't grow on trees with Model 17's. At 12 or so yards I can hold an inch with this revolver off a rest. I think that's pretty good for this old man. One day in the near future I will stretch it out to 25 yards and see how it does while keeping my fingers crossed and using good ammunition.

Rick H.
 
Back
Top