Italian Mannlicher Carcano - worth anything?

'Bout five years or so ago I decided I wanted to have a duplicate to the rifle Oswald supposedly used. Don't ask me why I wanted to do this, it was just something I decided to do. Anyway, I picked up the rifle, a recent import with no collector value, not in the best shape, but perfect for what I needed, I think I paid $55 for it. The scope & mount Oswald had on his rifle were a bit tougher to find, it took awhile and I finally found one on ebay, got into a bidding war and had to pay about $175 for the thing; awful to pay that much for a scope that probably isn't worth $5.

I've shot it a few times and, IMO, it is a horrible rifle, bad trigger, the bolt is awkward and not smooth, there just isn't a positive thing I can say about it. Other than its infamous place in history, I can of nothing good to say about the Carcano.
 
They have to be accurate, Lee Harvey Oswald made a shot on a small moving target at 3/4 mile that I can't duplicate as a trained Marine sniper with a Remington 700 in .308!
A couple years ago there was a show on one of the educational or History channels in which they sought to duplicate the feat to see how difficult it would be. The shooter was an marksman from Australia positioned at the same height and shooting thru a window at a mellon of some description on a vehicle moving at the same speed, same distance (not 3/4 mile) using a scoped 6.5. He made it look easy. I'm not saying anybody could do it, but this guy did it time after time without missing.
 
Especially remembering he didn't qualify on the Marine Corps rifle range with an M-1!

I thought Oswald qualified SharpShooter the first time around and Marksman the second time w/the M1 on two different courses...

Anyway,,,I had a near mint condition Carcano long rifle that sold for good money just because of it's condition I guess. The run of the mill Carcano seen at gunshows around here is usually in the $100 or less range if it sells. The safety is a bit tough to operate on those rifles
icon_rolleyes.gif
.

The cartridge itself isn't bad,,just short of a 6.5 Mannlicher Schoenaur in ballistics. There used to be quite alot of Western Cartridge Co FMJ ammo around on clips in generic marked 10rd boxes. That wasn't too expensive for a while, but was many years ago.

I did buy one other Carcano years ago just for the nice double set triggers that someone had installed in the gun. The gun was bubba'd but the triggers were a nice find.

If ammo (and clips) ware as plentiful and cheap as the recent run of 7.62 Russian has been,,the Carcanos would probably be just as popular as the Mosin Nagants. Everyone likes a cheap rifle, they like it even more with cheap ammo.
 
I have a couple in 6.5, and one converted to 8mm.
We enjoy firing the 6.5 carbine, puts on an awesome show when shooting at night.
 
It's a good idea to have any military surplus firearm checked by a competent gunsmith before firing, but overall, a Carcano might well be a safer design than the various Mosins floating around.

Ammo, from Prvi, shouldn't run more than 14 dollars a box. The FNM stuff goes for 10. It's cheaper to feed a Carcano than a .30-06 or .308 these days.
 
I've got a couple of them. They are fun plinkers and as I reload for them, cheap to shoot.

There was an episode of Mythbusters about gun barrels rupturing and peeling back like a banana. One of the guns they tried to blow up was a Carcano. They couldn't get it to let go. If I remember right, they welded up the muzzle and fired it. The only damage was a slightly bulged barrel.
 
Back
Top