.38 Special 5 Screw

Joined
Aug 9, 2012
Messages
3
Reaction score
5
Hi,

I just joined and this is my first post.

I inherited a S&W 6 shot revolver. There are 4 screws on the side plate; the one near the hammer top is only about half on the plate. There is also a screw in front of the trigger guard.

The SN is 284XXX; there are no letters in front. There are no "logos" engraved on either side but "SMITH & WESSON" is in block type on the left side of the barrel. The right side reads "38 S&W Special CTG. The top is stamped "SMITH & WESSON SPRINGFIELD MASS. USA" along with patent dates, the last of which is "SEPT. 14. 09". The barrel measures 6" overall (about 5 3/16" in front of the frame) with a half circle front sight. The rear is a groove in the frame.

The hammer is case hardened. It has squarish wood grips. The number "166" (?) is stamped on the crane and it's recess.

From what I've seen here it is mid '50's or earlier but I don't know what frame it is and the serial number lists have a letter at the front. The condition is very good to excellent (?).

I've tried to anticipate questions but I've likely forgotten something important. I guess I'd like, mainly, to know what I have. If anyone could give a guess at it's approximate value, I would really appreciate it.

Bob (tvme)
 
Register to hide this ad
Without a photo or a better description, it appears to be a S&W Model of 1905, 4th change M&P model, probably WWI-era. Value is highly dependent upon condition and originality (including grips), and that cannot be assessed without some very good photos. There is a fifth screw, as you have noted, ahead of the trigger guard. Does it look something like like this one?
MP400492.jpg
 
Last edited:
First off, welcome to the forum.

It does sound like a Military & Police, Model of 1905, 4th Change. If that's the case, the serial number would date it to about 1917. The number inside the frame recess and on the crane has no significance in identifying or dating the piece.

Absolutely need some photos to be posted to be able to refine this assessment of your revolver, and opine on its value.
 
It is a .38 Military & Police, with the less common round butt grip frame. With no logo on the frame and the style of stocks I would guess it was shipped after 1918 but before 1920. It appears to have its original finish and may be worth $500-600 if so, but an in-person exam may be needed to be certain of this. Hope this is helpful.
 
Again I thank you. It is older and certainly more valuable than I thought. You folks are far more helpful than most I've encountered on the internet.

Bob
 
Everyone will have their own opinion as to value. I would say you could realize $400-500 for it - but not from a gun store or pawn shop. There, maybe half. Best way to know is to get on one of the gun auction sites, such as Gun Broker or Auction Arms and see what prices similar revolvers have sold for (not the asking prices). There were many of these made, so value is not astronomical.
 
That is a very nice M&P with excellent grips, tvme. Murphydog, I was under the impression that the square butt was less common on that model.

Not sure on the relative numbers/percentages, but the square butt models are much more common from this era. The 1899s and 1902s were all RB, then the SB seemed to take over. Now all the factory makes are RB, with few exceptions.
 
That is a very nice M&P with excellent grips, tvme. Murphydog, I was under the impression that the square butt was less common on that model.

I think part of the confusion is caused by a misprint in the SCSW that stated that the square butt guns were more scarce but should have been the opposite.

tvme, welcome to the forum, nice look M&P you have there.
 
Last edited:
Very nice round butt 1905. I agree with the value and dating you have heard from others -- late 'teens, $400-500 to somebody who is looking for one of those. A dealer won't give you anywhere near that.
 
Welcome to the SW Forum. That is a nice revolver you have. I'd keep it and shoot it with target loads. Sonora
 
Back
Top