Miss Fisher's Gold Plated S&W

Skeptic 9c

Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2006
Messages
1,833
Reaction score
5,609
Location
Northeastern Florida
Folks,
A TV show imported from Australia on the Ovation Cable Channel, "Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries" set in 1928 Australia, with the author claiming much authenticity. The lead carries a .38 S&W looks to me like a gold plated Chief's Special. That would be about 25 -30 years off, wouldn't it?

I know it's Australia Mate and probably isn't a real revolver. But what would be a real choice?

It's also a Private Eyeful show and those are non-existent in US TV lately.

Geoff
Who notes the show wasn't as bad as some American attempts recently.
 
Register to hide this ad
It is even a few years off from 2" Terrier production, which would resemble a Chiefs Special. A Detective Special existed at the (fictional time) but I suspect you know the difference between the two visually :).

Most likely...it's what the prop department had available to "arm" Miss Fisher.
 
I'll look for that on YouTube. I don't get the more obscure cable channels.

I think I read that FN-1910 Browning .32's were used by Aussie police back then. South African cops had the Webley 9mm (Browning Long) M-1909 pistol. Those cops who carried in London had the Webley .32 auto.

Police in the various colonies and Commonwealth nations also carried a lot of Webley .38's and the MK IV (commercial series) had come out the year before. A mini-series on BBC that was supposed to be authentic had those MK IV .38's on Kenya police in the 1930's and that jives with photos taken there during the Mau-Mau Emergency in the 1950's. But I saw a pic of one officer wearing a US military .45 auto in the usual US GI rig. Maybe they had some leeway. Author Robert C. Ruark wrote that he saw all sorts of WWII handguns on Kenya settlers then. But that has little to do with what police carried. A British movie made in Kenya in 1956 showed a cop wearing a brown crossdraw flap holster for his Webley MK VI .455.

But what other Commonwealth countries used won't necessarily be what Aussies had.

I think it varied with the state, as now. S&W and Glock .40's seem to be the current rage, replacing Ruger and S&W .38 and .357 revolvers. I think there are seven states, inc. Tasmania, which is an island.

We have Australian members. Maybe one will see this and know the answer.

The most likely snub S&W for a woman there then would probably be the .32 Hand Ejector or the .38 Terrier, if made then. BUT...Colt made snubs popular first, and the Detective Spcl. didn't arrive until 1927. S&W didn't make the M&P snub until 1933. I'd have to look up when snub versions of the .32 HE and the Terrier appeared.

If I was casting guns for that role, I'd choose the Colt .32 auto, in the absence of solid info to the contrary. The 1910 FN .32 would also be in the running, if the prop house had any.

And the pocket model of the Webley MK III .38 or the MK IV would be in the running, too. Keep in mind that these are NOT in the military .455 MK series. The Aussie military had the .455's and some S&W and maybe Colt .455's. We've seen some of the S&W .455's in this forum, with specific Australian military district markings.

Actually, this is an interesting question. I hope one of the Aussie members knows. But my best guess is that the TV gun isn't correct.

Is Miss Fisher even a cop? I seriously doubt that they had female cops then, let alone armed ones. If she's a civilian somehow licensed to carry a handgun, anything then available might be chosen.

If you recall the TV series, The Lost World, filmed in Queensland from 1999-2002, adventuress Marguerite Krux had a hammerless .32 or .38 and the prop house provided different ones. I think I saw a Webley WP, a S&W, AND SOME SORT OF h&r or Iver Johnspn EQUIVALENT. I DOUBT THE LAST, AS SHE WAS GUN SAVVY AND RICH AND WOULD not HAVE HAD A H&R OR iVER Johnson REVOLVER. iN FAN FICTION, I WROTE HER WITH A s&w nEW dEPARTURE .38, WHICH WAS LATER EXCHANGED FoR A m&p .38 WITH FOUR-INCH BARREL AND ROUND BUTT. tHAT SERIES WAS SET FROM 1919-1922. THE MALE HEROES HAD cOLT .45 AUTOS, A cOLT saa .45, AND SOME Webley iv .38'S, WHICH MAY HAVE BEEN STANDING IN FOR mk vi .455'S. Australian PROP HOUSES ARE PROBAbLY SHORT OF GUNS DATING THAT FAR BACK. oN ThE RECENT, "Sea Patrol", CZ 9MM'S OFTEN STOOD IN FOR Browning 9MM'S. I doubt that the Royal Australian Navy really uses the CZ-75 or 85.

Sorry: I type while looking at the keyboard and I tend to hit the cursed Caps Lock. I'd deactivate it if I could. I'm really tired and don't feel like correcting the result.

Anyway, unless an Aussie member knows more, this is probably as good an answer as you'll get. If I find the show, I'm good at noticing what's used. I'll get back to you if I see it. Thanks for the tip. :)

Your posts are good. If I'd remembered, I'd have listed you in that topic about which members' posts we look for, in The Lounge.
 
Last edited:
Movies and TV shows are very rarely accurate in the firearms characters use. How many movies about the Civil War have you seen where the Army officer has a Colt SAA? On Hogan's Heroes Sgt. Schultz was once shown on guard duty with an 1898 Krag slung over his shoulder.
 
She should be carrying an Enfield or Webley. But, who really cares. It's a light hearted detective show and fun to watch.
All the series are available streaming on Netflix.
 
Apparently, in the novels, she packs a semi-auto I am planning to Kindle the first book in the series tonight. Cocaine Blues (1989) aka Death by Misadventure in USofA.
Geoff
Who is a curious fellow and misses the "Private Eyeful" genre on US TV.
 
Apparently, in the novels, she packs a semi-auto..Geoff...misses the "Private Eyeful" genre on US TV.
PBS here in SC started running a Brit series called "Rosemary & Thyme" about two gals that are crime solving gardeners.

So, if semi-auto packing gals with funny accents are your thing...here's Felicity Kendal as Rosemary Boxer.

 
Last edited:
I've gone back four times now to look at the OP's photo
and i can't see a revolver......

Chuck
 
In Geoff's linked photo, the trigger looks to be the later wider "combat" or "ranger" sort But the barrel is still pinned. (I used a magnifying glass.)

Definitely not correct for the period.

I used to have a bank teller from Melbourne. It's interesting to see any Aussie series set anywhere but in Sydney.
 
Back
Top