The best production double action revolver?

GypsmJim said:
When I took my quality training, what is "quality" was stressed over and over. Quality means "good" means "best", and that equates to "meets the customer's requirements ALL of the time.

I might be inclined to list a M19 or a M66 or certainly a M27, and I have more than 1 of each. Fine fit and finish, good accuracy, good trigger, etc, etc. But, to meet the "best" definition it would have to be a Ruger Security Six, SP100 or a Redhawk for sure, because they are build like a brick "***house" and will last almost forever.
Click to expand...

I pretty much agree with the Ruger Six Series being the best guns ever made. If I had to choose only one of my guns to keep it would be a 2 ¾” SS Ruger Speed Six. A close second would be the 2 ¾” SS Ruger Security Six.

Next I would pick my three inch Lew Horton 624 as third best, then my 696 no dash as forth best, and my fifth choice would the the 3 inch model 625.
 
I have owned both in the past and have shot several of both brands. korth is just unreal smooth. the trigger rides on roller bearings so you can guess what that is like, along with the handfitting. nothing else like it.to me, second would be a tedford tuned action python. still own one and shoot it a couple of times a year just to remind myself what American craftsmanship was like and could be again.
 
I am a dedicated S&W fan and owner now. There are a lot of good ideas above like the Reg Mag, or a 27 - if S&W feels it is their best built it is hard to argue with them. Same on the 15, 686, 64 all good choices.

But there is one left out here so far . From my Colt -ing days I would say there is a big group and percentage of revolver guys out there who would agree that the Colt Python should be at or very near the top on any Best Revolver list.

The Python is a Ferrari type handgun. It is totally hand assembled and hand fitted. It polishing and finishing is at the top too. Colt polishers were the top , but they had to be there for a while to polish on a Python.

While the Korth is right up there too I suspect that the Python would win by virtue of much more votes and awareness.

But as for mine - Ill take that Registered Magnum please. ;) And trade you an unfired nickel 27 to boot too.
 
Oddly, as well built as the Korth revolvers are, they may not be any more accurate at distance than a good S&W or Colt. The Freedom Arms revolvers DO have have an excellent accuracy reputation, earned regularly amongst IHMSA shooters. You'd probably feel like you're going backwards. (I just don't like the feel of the SA in my hand, so suffer with DAs.)
 
It depends on your criteria for "best." Do you mean most rugged? Do you mean prettiest? Do you mean most accurate? Do you mean most handwork? Do you mean best action?

My vote for best production revolver would probably have to go to that long discontinued model, the original ".357" Magnum. Hand built, fantastic action, lots of handwork, beautiful hand checkering, super accurate, yet tough enough for police or FBI work, most powerful for its day, etc.

I suppose you could say the same thing these days about the Korth.

The type of handwork present in the ".357" Magnum is not likely to be seen again.
 
I wonder how many million K frame Smith and Wesson revolvers were manufactured and sold in the 20th century?

I wonder how far back it is to second place?
 
Fishinfool said:
Straying from the S&W camp, how about the Korth? From what I have read, completely hand fitted, and probably the most expensive factory revolver made.

Larry
Click to expand...

I've read the same thing.

Freedom Arms would be tough to beat. Not that I could say first hand, they're a bit out of my price range:eek:
 
I think adding 'current' before production in the original question would make it more interesting. My Ruger days are behind me, but the best built DA from that camp was my .454 SRH by far. My Redhawk and SP101 days are thankfully behind me. All of my myriad of SA and DA Ruger examples - even my beloved SRH - were delivered as 'works in progress' - and eventually finished into decent revolvers, save the .32 H&RM models as they had max ID chambers, remedied by new cylinders - and that wasn't 'in the cards'. No, I'll put S&W alone at the top for current production best DA revolvers - MIM parts, IL, two piece barrel and all! My 2 5/8" PC627 UDR is a prime example. My 2 1/8" 632 Pro is no slouch - neither is my 3" 63. JMHO

Stainz
 
686-3, 4 inch barrel

I haven't had experience with some to the guns nominated here, but in my own personal experience and preferences, I have to go with my S&W Model 686-3 with a 4 inch barrel. A close second would be my stainless Ruger Security Six with a 6 inch barrel. However, the Smith wins due to the incredible versatility of the four incher.
 
It's the Ruger Redhawk and the Ruger Security & Police Service Sixes. As far as strength there on the top of the heap. I run stout loads threw them all the time. There are no screws nor side plates to loosen up.

Isn't the S&W model 19 noted for hammering itself apart with the magnum loads?

Now don't attack my N Frames. I like all guns but it's good to have some that can take the magnum load abuse too.

Ruger for very strong well built magnum revolvers. Number 1

S&W for second when it becomes to its history of fine revolvers. The actions on the older combat masterpiece and target masterpiece 38 specials are unmatched even today.

But lubing any new revolver with a rough action with only will smooth it out. My two new s&w m58 & m57 actions and trigger pull we're different. Once lubed with the only paste there exactly the same.

Colt sorry I can't say "quality" and colt together.
 
Last edited:
Original post implied current production, so I'll nominate Elmer's one gun battery, an x29 4".
44 > 357, IMO.
 
shocker said:
Original post implied current production, so I'll nominate Elmer's one gun battery, an x29 4".
44 > 357, IMO.
Click to expand...



I understood current production too.
There are a LOT of Fantastic guns that used to be made, but ones you can go buy NIB?
 
colt_saa said:
Korth is to DA revolvers what Freedom Arms is to SA wheel guns.

Odds are you will not find a couple hundered of our fellow forum members that have fired a Fredom Arms, even fewer have had the chance to shoot a Korth
Click to expand...

As an owner of a single Freedom Arms .454 Casull revolver and many S&W revolvers (but no Registered Magnums), I can say that none of the S&Ws that I own match the FA for build, precision, stoutness, and the sheer feel of quality. Neither do any of my Colts, including a Python. I've never handled a Korth but they are said to be pretty nice....

*edit* Looks like almost everyone is ignoring this sentence in the original post: "The DA equivalent of a Freedom Arms." Either that or they have no idea what an FA revolver is like.
 
Last edited:
Comrad said:
Model 65 4 inch, no question about it. Stock wood grips too.
Click to expand...

After reading everyone's suggestions I find that I have to agree with Comrad, especially if we include "practicality" as part of the criteria for selection as "best." The M65 can do it all, every task described in this thread. That includes "slickest action" with just a little tuning.

My preference would be for a 3" barrel. And I like the .333" wide smooth trigger over the old ribbed tirgger. But, if all I could have from here to eternity is an M65 with a 4" barrel and a ribbed tirgger (M65-1), I would be perfectly satisfied.
 
Best double action? Well, let's see, It needs to be blue. The barrel should be 6 inches long. K frame's about right, but the caliber's not too important. Oh yeah, it's gotta have target /diamond / football stocks on it. The only real variable is whether it's long action or short action. That would depend on how itchy my trigger happens to be.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

C
38 double action third model
Replies
0
Views
226
cjlinek
C
Chrisj357
Double Action with .357 Magnum
2
Replies
30
Views
1K
Doug M.
Doug M.
D
MODEL 625-4 UNUSUAL DOUBLE ACTION
Replies
5
Views
609
Nightowl
Nightowl
mag318
S&W Double Action timing.
Replies
10
Views
684
StrawHat
StrawHat
J
A little production date help please?
Replies
5
Views
352
L-2
L-2

Latest posts

Back
Top