Just picked up my first revolver a couple months ago. 629 .44 mag for hunting. Now im hooked on revolvers and would like to purchase one for everyday carry. Ive narrowed it down to 2 models. both 357mag with 3inch barrels. cant decide between the 686 plus (all stainless with rubber grip) or the 586 L-Comp (blued steel with wood grip and comped barrel). The 586 is a performance center model, and the actions on the PC's I really like. Anybody own either of these? Thoughts? Opinions? Experience?
IMHO, THE 686+ WITH A 3" BARREL IS THE PERFECT REVOLVER FOR EDC. THE DURABILITY AND RESISTANCE TO RUST OF THE STAINLESS GUNS GIVE THE 686 THE EDGE OVER A BLUED GUN, ESP FOR CARRY.....
ANY BLUED GUN WILL EVENTUALLY SHOW HOLSTER WEAR. A BLUED GUN MAY EVEN BEGIN TO RUST DUE TO BODY PERSPIRATION, IF CARRIED IN AN IWB HOLSTER, OR IN A VERY HUMID ENVIRONMENT. HANDLING MARKS, MINOR DINGS, AND SCRATCHES ARE INEVITABLE, ON A WORKING GUN. ALL OF THESE BLEMISHES CAN BE REMOVED, AND THE STAINLESS WEAPON CAN BE KEPT IN A SPARKLING, PRISTINE CONDITION, WITH MINIMAL POLISHING, USING A PRODUCT LIKE MOTHERS MAG WHEEL POLISH, AND AN OLD T-SHIRT.....
IMHO, THE PC GUNS ARE NOT MUCH BETTER THAN REGULAR PRODUCTION GUNS. THE COMPED BARRELS ARE MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING. THERE ARE MANY COMPLAINTS ABOUT THE QUALITY OF PC GUNS ON THIS FORUM. ALL OF THE 686s THAT I HAVE OWNED, OR SHOT, SEEMED TO HAVE VERY NICE TRIGGERS, RIGHT OUT OF THE BOX.......
YOU ARE NOT SADDLED WITH THOSE UGLY RUBBER GRIPS. A GRIP SWAP IS PROBABLY THE MOST POPULAR MODIFICATION THAT IS MADE TO REVOLVERS. S&W HAS FACTORY WOODEN GRIPS FOR SALE, THAT WILL TRANSFORM YOUR GUN INTO A THING OF BEAUTY. THERE IS A PLETHORA OF AFTERMARKET SOURCES FOR WOODEN GRIPS, IF NOTHING FROM S&W CATCHES YOUR EYE.......
BELOW ARE PICS OF MY 686+, WITH A 2/12" BARREL. THIS REVOLVER WORE FACTORY RB COMBAT GRIPS WHEN I PURCHASED IT. THEY DID NOT FIT MY HAND, SO I SWAPPED THEM OUT FOR THESE PC MAGNAS AND A TYLER T......