Shield Plus range report

BigBear437

Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2021
Messages
12
Reaction score
18
Tuesday, I picked up a brand new Shield plus. This is the very basic model, standard sights, no thumb safety. The flush-fit 10 round magazine is worthless to me, as I have huge hands, and most of my other firearms have some sort of rubber grip with finger grooves. I don't have the gun set up as I want it yet, but I wanted to take it to the range, because I'm impatient.

Out of the box, I noted the trigger that has already been discussed in previous posts. I also noted how hard it was to get 13 rounds in the 13 round magazine, but I think (hope) that this loosens up with usage.

One of the other things that I noticed was the magazine, when fully loaded, did not seat properly with the standard loading procedure. I had to hit it really hard at least two more times.

Between the 10 and 15 yard lines, I fired about 45 rounds of aluminum cased 115 grain FMJ that I had left over from an old range session. If I did my job right, the bullets went where I aimed them.

I had a couple of failures to feed and double feeds, especially in the first shot from a fully loaded magazine. Again, I hope that this issue works itself out with use / after I clean and lubricate it.

After the first target, I hung a new target and pushed it all the way out to the 25 yard line. If I would have done my job, I think this gun would have done better. This time, I used 124 grain FMJ that I bought with the gun. Out of the 8 rounds I fired from the 25 yard line, one was off the human target, and three of the other seven went a little high. I may have been looking over the sights, which would have put them higher than I aimed. I then moved the target from the 25 to the 15 and 7, and ran the rest of my rounds through doing failure drills and controlled pairs.

I think Smith got it really right with this one. The Plus fits my 1.0 holsters perfectly, the magazine capacity almost makes it a fighting (as opposed to purely defensive) pistol, and if we do our jobs by sticking to the fundamentals, the bullets will hit what you're aiming at. I had considered getting a M&P 9C due to magazine interchangability with my full-sized M&P9, but I don't think that will be necessary now. I'm a fan, and will like it more once I get some Tritium Fiber Optic sights and a Hand-all grip sleeve on it.

The images attached are from today's range session. Somehow, they saved correctly on my computer, but are uploading as thumbnails, sideways, on here.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_7501.jpg
    IMG_7501.jpg
    88.2 KB · Views: 127
  • IMG_7502.jpg
    IMG_7502.jpg
    80.2 KB · Views: 122
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
I had a failure to feed on the first round out of the 13-round magazine (the pistol was loaded 13+1) on the very first time that I used that magazine. After that, the next nine 13+1s I fired all ran without a hiccup. I was using brass-cased ammo, though, not aluminum, so I don't know if the aluminum cases were a factor in your case.

Yep, a full 13-round magazine doesn't seat easily on a closed slide, but it just took a little pop from the heel of my hand to reliably seat it. Loading on an open slide was never a problem, of course.

I only have 250 300 rounds through it, but so far I'm digging the Shield Plus.
 
Last edited:
The magazine issue does improve with usage. This gun has been everything I had hoped. The Shield was my favorite EDC but I became a capacity ***** (365 then Hellcat). Now the Shield checks all boxes and performs flawlessly. While I shot the other two really well my Shield was slightly more accurate but I opted for capacity. I find the plus extremely accurate at the 10 and in range and carry it with great confidence. The magazine (loading/seating) has been the only complaint and it has improved with range time.
 
I must have hit the jackpot because my plus has not given me any problems yet. All my 13 round mags loaded 13 rounds with no issue and when putting the mag in the gun it slides up and yes you have to seat it, but not with any more force than any of my other high capacity mags. All my rounds so far have feed properly with no double feeds or FTF. I did change my sights to night sights and I now believe I have a CC that fits everything I have been looking for.
 
Shields Up

BigBear437 - Welcome to the S&W Forum.

Thank you for the Range Report and taking the time
for the pictures.

I have been considering the S&W Plus and Glock 43X.
Both appear to be in line to what fits best to me.

We’ll see what the future bears. The Best to you and
your Endeavors.

Welcome and thanks.
 
My new EDC

Had my shield plus to the range twice now. Fired a total of 420 rounds without a single hiccup. Went through 300 winchester 115 gr FMJ, 100 of CCI 147 gr and 20 rounds of Hornady Critical Defense. The 13 round mag now slips in easily but the 10 rd still needs a little extra tap. Have not tried either one with one in the chamber. Do prefer the 13 round mag for a better grip on the gun. My Shield 1.0 has been my favorite for about five years now but with the higher capacity I'm switching to the plus for my go to gun.
 
Last edited:
I have only put 300 through my Shield Plus. About 100 Federal American Eagle 115
And 200, 124 Lawnan. The 124 was noticeably more accurate at 25 feet.
No failure of any type. The full mag was difficult to seat at first but after 2 to 3 magazines problem went away. I too believe I've found my carry semi. However I still have a love affair with revolvers.
 
I must have hit the jackpot because my plus has not given me any problems yet. All my 13 round mags loaded 13 rounds with no issue and when putting the mag in the gun it slides up and yes you have to seat it, but not with any more force than any of my other high capacity mags. All my rounds so far have feed properly with no double feeds or FTF. I did change my sights to night sights and I now believe I have a CC that fits everything I have been looking for.
Same here. I have had no problem at all out of my plus. I keep reading about people having an "issue" seating full mags, while does require a frim press or slap with the heel of my hand it still seats every time. I'm 5'4" and 50+years-old and I can load and seat full mags on an empty chamber. Not sure what others are calling an issue.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top