4046TSW disconnector question

Joined
Nov 23, 2010
Messages
590
Reaction score
756
Hello fellows. My Brinks 4046TSW has a plastic disconnector. I'm shopping for a metal one, but none are listed for this model. Are there other models that use the same disconnector?

Thank you!
Dave
 
Register to hide this ad
I once had to replace a plastic disconnector in a 5906TSW - it came out in three pieces. I'm not sure what happened to cause it. I bought the pistol broken.
 
I love Smith, but plastic working parts just blow my mind. I just don't get it. Oh well. Glad the pistol wasn't being used to defend the owner.
 
FWIW, in an armorer class when the nylon disconnector was first introduced, we were told that it had withstood extended factory endurance testing just as well as the steel part. The factory instructor who explained it said that had meant shooting at least 25K rounds.

Interestingly enough, we were told the common way the nylon disconnectors were sometimes broken was during disassembly & reassembly by inattentive armorers in the traditional double action models. Having to use a pin punch to push the disconnector tail around the drawbar's disconnector tab in the TDA guns required some care and attention to the amount of force used. It's understandable that someone not trained and experienced in installing and removing the disconnector might unintentionally damage one while removing or installing one, as well.

BTW, the disconnectors are installed differently in the TDA & DAO guns. In the TDA guns the drawbar is connected to the trigger first, and then the disconnector is installed, meaning the disconnector tail has to be carefully moved around the installed drawbar's tab during installation. In the DAO guns, the disconnector is installed before the drawbar is connected to the trigger.

There were a couple other advantages to the nylon disconnector.

The tolerances were consistent, for one thing. The older occasional "long tail disconnector" problem, that required careful stoning of the disconnector's tail (bottom) to adjust the length of the part, was no longer needed. In later 3rd gen armorer manuals the problem and corrective action for the older steel part was dropped from the manual, since steel disconnectors had been replaced by nylon ones in current production LE guns.

The other advantage was that the tail's movement running up and down the drawbar's disconnector tab (ramp) was inherently smoother. Nylon has reduced friction against steel, and is 'self-lubricating', so to speak.

Toward the end of what became 3rd gen production, we were told that there had been some discussion at the factory regarding bringing the steel part back ... but not because it was any stronger or more durable in actual shooting. The reason being considered was that the steel part was less likely to be damaged by ham-handed or inattentive armorers. :p :D Didn't happen, though, as the 3rd gen's were discontinued.
 
Last edited:
Thank you, FB. I realize there certainly must have been thought with turning a pretty significant moving part from metal to plastic. I just don't trust it myself. If I couldn't have found a metal one, thank you John, I would have been okay with getting a plastic one even though it would probably be close to the same age as the one in the gun. It might have something to do with my gray hair too, not so much getting tangled while smithing mind you, but the significant mental deficiencies associated with it! :D
 
Thank you, FB. I realize there certainly must have been thought with turning a pretty significant moving part from metal to plastic. I just don't trust it myself. If I couldn't have found a metal one, thank you John, I would have been okay with getting a plastic one even though it would probably be close to the same age as the one in the gun. It might have something to do with my gray hair too, not so much getting tangled while smithing mind you, but the significant mental deficiencies associated with it! :D


No problem. :)

FWIW, I replaced the steel disconnectors in my own 3rd gens with the then-new nylon parts, and have been running them since the end of the 90's. I suspect I may be approaching the end of the service life of one of my aluminum frames (CS45), which I've been shooting since I bought it new in (?) '99, but the nylon disconnector is still running fine. ;) I never kept a log of the total rounds fired, but only an approx running round count for the purpose of remembering to replace recoil springs somewhere between 800-1200rds. That was a lot sooner than the factory recommendation of every 5000rds, but I liked to err on the conservative end of things considering that short recoil spring and the pounding of the .45 caliber in that little gun. :) Simply a personal preference. I suspect I've gone through at least a couple dozen recoil springs since the gun was new. I used to order them 5-10 at a time when the factory was still stocking them. (I did that with almost all of of the recoil springs for my personal 3rd gens, since springs were inexpensive.)
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top