28-2 refinished
- Thread starter bulova
- Start date
It might be a silver color, but a Model 28 is sure as shootin' NOT stainless steel. That's about like saying repainting my car made it brass.
Someone refinished my Model 49 in the 80's with one of the Teflon finishes in silver. It may look Stainless, but it sure isn't!
I suspect the 28 is the same way!
What does it do to the value? Not much as a shooter (maybe improves it over the unrefinished rust ball! But as a collector gun, it has none!!! My 28-2 4" was Mag-na-Ported and tuned up, it is a joyful shooter, but only that.
Ivan
I suspect the 28 is the same way!
What does it do to the value? Not much as a shooter (maybe improves it over the unrefinished rust ball! But as a collector gun, it has none!!! My 28-2 4" was Mag-na-Ported and tuned up, it is a joyful shooter, but only that.
Ivan
sigp220.45
US Veteran
Probably hard chrome. NP3 if you are lucky.
If it is well done, and the price is right, I wouldn't turn my nose up at it.
In the neighborhood of $400 would keep me interested.
If it is well done, and the price is right, I wouldn't turn my nose up at it.
In the neighborhood of $400 would keep me interested.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Jan 19, 2001
- Messages
- 11,830
- Reaction score
- 19,628
- City & State/Province
- In The Woods Of S.C.
Run.... Forrest.........Run!
Bakebfr480
Member
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2017
- Messages
- 1,469
- Reaction score
- 1,212
Looks nickled to me..........too blurry to tell!
Laketime
Member
A lot of guys just couldn't live with that dull finish on the 28 especially on the frame and trigger guard. ( I was one of them ) Model 28,s were the least expensive used N Frames you could buy at one time.Add an all weather Robar finish which looks like stainless was a popular option.
stansdds
Member
The picture does not show it clearly enough, but it's either nickel or chrome plated. If a carbon steel firearm could be converted to stainless, I'd like to meet the person who did it. I have plenty of lead that I would like for them to turn into gold.
As for buying this particular Model 28, if the action is nice and tight, cylinder indexes and locks correctly, the finish is even and looks good, then it is likely a fine, shooter grade Model 28. If the price is right, say around $400, then I'd go for it.
As for buying this particular Model 28, if the action is nice and tight, cylinder indexes and locks correctly, the finish is even and looks good, then it is likely a fine, shooter grade Model 28. If the price is right, say around $400, then I'd go for it.
Art Doc
SWCA Member, Absent Comrade
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2002
- Messages
- 10,446
- Reaction score
- 13,399
- City & State/Province
- The kidney of Dixie.
If you like it and want to shoot it then go ahead. Monetary vale is pretty low.
At least the trigger & hammer were properly left original. My 28 ,(original), in fair/good cosmetic and very good mechanical condition cost he $500.
We not know what the actual finish is. We do not know the mechanical condition. Round count - 500? 50,000? Who refinished it and why? Was it pitted to the bejeebers? Matching or Franken?
Too many unknowns at this point. All we really know is that is is a Highway Patrolman , and it is not in original condition.
We not know what the actual finish is. We do not know the mechanical condition. Round count - 500? 50,000? Who refinished it and why? Was it pitted to the bejeebers? Matching or Franken?
Too many unknowns at this point. All we really know is that is is a Highway Patrolman , and it is not in original condition.
Arquebus357
Member
Looks to me like someone simply polished the carbon steel. Done properly, you can just about duplicate stainless steel. Of course it will have NO rust protection. I would purchase it, for a good price, and rust blue it...assuming I'm correct of course.
I have no use for plated guns.
I have no use for plated guns.
Last edited:
There are a zillion 28’s out there... spend your money on one without issues.
One more thing to think about, is that the front sight is also refinished. The nickel or chrome finish makes for a very difficult to see front sight and as such is difficult to shoot.
Smiths with factory nickel front sights or stainless (like the early 66s) are the same way.
This one would have to be real cheap to develop any interest.
Smiths with factory nickel front sights or stainless (like the early 66s) are the same way.
This one would have to be real cheap to develop any interest.
Bill Bates
Member
If you are just looking for a great shooting N Frame .357 magnum don't walk away to quickly. If it is in good mechanical condition and the finish doesn't completely offend you and you can buy it for a shooter price, why pass on it.
For me that price would be less than $500. If it can be had for $350 to $400 it probably is good buy.
These days any N Frame in good mechanical condition is worth four or five hundred dollars. Will it ever be collectable, no. But sometimes, having a great shooter you can toss in the truck, carry and shoot the heck out without worry about decreasing its value also has a lot value.
Last edited:
bulova ---#18 by Mr Bates sums it up nicely. He laid out the criteria just as I see it.
One thing to add - You need to find out exactly what the finish is. You need that to make a meaningful decision , and I think that there are a few curious parties here too.
What is the finish , What is the asking price?
One thing to add - You need to find out exactly what the finish is. You need that to make a meaningful decision , and I think that there are a few curious parties here too.
What is the finish , What is the asking price?
- Joined
- May 10, 2015
- Messages
- 807
- Reaction score
- 667
We need to know price to give the best advice!
bananaman
Member
The stocks are aftermarket too. If they feel great to you, then that is a plus. If they don't fit you correctly, then more money to shell out. Good luck with your quest! Let us know how you make out. Bob
Gut wants $600. Saw one at a gun show yesterday and they wanted $550 for 4: Highwayman. I think I will pass on the refinished one and look for another one at the next show. Thanks again!!!
Absolutely. I second your decision as $600 is too high IMO.
Good call!
Looks like they removed the blue with vinegar and then buffed it. I'd maybe pay $400 if everything is right. Any little tic's subtract per each. Any more just look elsewhere.
$250 range?... what are you talking about. Std. mod-10 are bring more than that. Hello, 21st century.
hittman77
Member
Standard model 10's with original finish, parts and grips ....... not those subjected to the Bubba treatment.
This is a common N frame with the least desirable barrel length, $15 cheap-o grips and original finish removed ... and .... Lord knows what else. Yes, a $250 parts gun and only then if you really need some parts.
Other people over-paying however, doesn't bother me one bit!
This is a common N frame with the least desirable barrel length, $15 cheap-o grips and original finish removed ... and .... Lord knows what else. Yes, a $250 parts gun and only then if you really need some parts.
Other people over-paying however, doesn't bother me one bit!
Last edited:
