629 vs 686 Day at the range

ridgewalker

Member
Joined
May 18, 2013
Messages
731
Reaction score
516
Location
Western USA
Okay so here is another range report. Had my 6.5 inch barrel 629 and my 6 inch barrel 686 at the range today. Was shooting standing, unsupported, 2 handed, double action at 25 yards. Pictures show 2 pairs of targets. The first target in each pair is the 629 and the second target is the 686. I also shot my little 351C mostly at the 686 target. If you look closely you might see the little holes made by the 22 mag.

I was fortunate to acquire all three of these guns in lightly used condition. 44 magnum a lot of inexperienced people sell after shooting it one time. The 357 I bought from a guy who said he was a 1911 guy. He bought it new less than a year before he sold it to me. He didn't put in the practice to translate his semiauto skills into revolvers. The little 351C I got because the original owner was dry firing it with those aluminum loading practice dummy rounds and aluminum chips were locking the action. I blew it out with cleaner and then oil and compressed air and it works perfectly now.

This was my first time trying Vihta Vouri N320. I loaded 5.2 gr under 148 gr XTreme DEWC for a light 357 mag load and 7.4 gr under XTreme 240 gr for a light 44 magnum load. These were above special level loads. All the rounds fired fine and felt good. It was clean but surprisingly the TiteGroup I wrote about last week was cleaner.

Interestingly the 44 shot a bit more accurately. I find that I am more accurate with bullets that begin with a 4. I believe they are just inherently more accurate.

Sorry all the target pics rotate when I downloaded them. I have to learn how to keep them from rotating.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0959.jpg
    IMG_0959.jpg
    107.1 KB · Views: 216
  • IMG_0960.jpg
    IMG_0960.jpg
    101.9 KB · Views: 167
  • IMG_0963.jpg
    IMG_0963.jpg
    124.8 KB · Views: 175
  • IMG_0964.jpg
    IMG_0964.jpg
    119 KB · Views: 139
  • IMG_0965.jpg
    IMG_0965.jpg
    105.7 KB · Views: 120
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Was shooting standing, unsupported, 2 handed, double action at 25 yards.
It was 25 yards. I would shoot 1 cylinder from 1 gun at one target then a cylinder from the other gun at the other target rotating guns back and forth. I slowed my shooting a bit from last week taking 3 to 4 seconds per shot for a better aim. Again I tried to avoid staging the trigger. I tried for a smooth steady trigger pull.
 
Last edited:
It's impossible to come to any scientific conclusion. You're comparing apples, to cantaloupes, to water melons! Different frame sizes, grips, ballistics, weight of the gun, etc. I think it better demonstrates your capabilities with each revolver, rather than the accuracy of each one. All three are very capable of similar accuracy at that distance. Interesting however.
 
Back
Top