I have a Wright Leather Works Predator hostler for my 9mm Shield. It is an OWB holster that conceals very well. For me, it is a very comfortable holster with an easy draw at 3:30 4 o'clock - YMMV. Now, if you prefer to go with Kydex, I like JM Custom Kydex and I have one of their version 2s OWB (also concealable) for a different handgun. It is comfortable and holds the handgun very tightly in the holster, however, but I don't have the JM Custom Kydex holster for my Shield - but I'm thinking getting one in the future. Holsters, like handguns are very subjective. It all depends upon the firearm owner. Good luck.