An N-Frame (and Gunleather) Ramble

Joined
Feb 20, 2007
Messages
440
Reaction score
637
I had a buddy back in the glory days of the ‘80s and ‘90s who often carried a six-inch barreled S&W Model 29 in a shoulder holster. We both grew up under the influence of the “Dirty Harry” series of films and had a strong affection for the mighty .44; my pal had the wherewithal to live it out, so to speak, by actually acquiring and carrying the sidearm of our favorite Inspector.

And this guy, man, he did it and did it well - he’d slip on a Members Only jacket (I told you it was the glory days) and with his slender build, the 29 just disappeared.

I recall my friend once telling me that sometimes that long-tubed 29 got heavy and that he was considering picking up something “smaller” - like a 4-inch Model 57 in .41 Magnum. The joke was on me, of course, as I didn’t know enough at the time to appreciate that such a .41 wasn’t exactly a great deal smaller than the fabled .44.

Time passed and I lost touch with my Magnum-toting friend, but I eventually found my own path to N-frame fandom via the likes of the Models 27 and 28, with a particular affinity for the five-inch 27 as favored by the late Mr. Skelton among many others. Later, the writings of no less authority than Sheriff Jim Wilson introduced me to Barranti Leather, and I took Mr. Barranti up on his claim of finding “comfortable peace of mind” via his Summer Classic IWB holster. Indeed, I found it to be more than a mere claim; it was reality for me.

Thus I find myself today having quite a fine time carrying a gun like a 5-inch 27 supremely concealed IWB for hours at a time (longest stretch to-date is 17 hours). As I’ve said before, no one is more pleasantly surprised than I am at how comfortable and effective this setup is for an N-frame revolver. Is it for everyone? Is it the most efficient and / or practical solution for concealed carry out there? Maybe; maybe not. But in a world of a LOT of choices, it works very well for me.

Still, there are those times when I recall the wry words of my old pal and start to think of perhaps carrying something a little “smaller” - like a 4-inch Model 28 (ha!) Thus it is that I now seem to swap back and forth between the deep-blued 27 and its less-glossy companion the 28, using an appropriately-sized Summer Classic for either arm.

My amigo, I hope you got that .41 and carry it proudly. And if we again cross paths and you need a holster recommendation, I’ve got one for you. That said, maybe you’ve already discovered one for yourself - I hope you have.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4918.jpg
    IMG_4918.jpg
    80 KB · Views: 66
  • IMG_4920.jpg
    IMG_4920.jpg
    76.9 KB · Views: 52
  • IMG_4922.jpg
    IMG_4922.jpg
    74.5 KB · Views: 51
  • IMG_4924.jpg
    IMG_4924.jpg
    72.1 KB · Views: 44
  • IMG_4925.jpg
    IMG_4925.jpg
    73.2 KB · Views: 49
Register to hide this ad
I had a buddy back in the glory days of the ‘80s and ‘90s who often carried a six-inch barreled S&W Model 29 in a shoulder holster. We both grew up under the influence of the “Dirty Harry” series of films and had a strong affection for the mighty .44; my pal had the wherewithal to live it out, so to speak, by actually acquiring and carrying the sidearm of our favorite Inspector.

And this guy, man, he did it and did it well - he’d slip on a Members Only jacket (I told you it was the glory days) and with his slender build, the 29 just disappeared.

I recall my friend once telling me that sometimes that long-tubed 29 got heavy and that he was considering picking up something “smaller” - like a 4-inch Model 57 in .41 Magnum. The joke was on me, of course, as I didn’t know enough at the time to appreciate that such a .41 wasn’t exactly a great deal smaller than the fabled .44.

Time passed and I lost touch with my Magnum-toting friend, but I eventually found my own path to N-frame fandom via the likes of the Models 27 and 28, with a particular affinity for the five-inch 27 as favored by the late Mr. Skelton among many others. Later, the writings of no less authority than Sheriff Jim Wilson introduced me to Barranti Leather, and I took Mr. Barranti up on his claim of finding “comfortable peace of mind” via his Summer Classic IWB holster. Indeed, I found it to be more than a mere claim; it was reality for me.

Thus I find myself today having quite a fine time carrying a gun like a 5-inch 27 supremely concealed IWB for hours at a time (longest stretch to-date is 17 hours). As I’ve said before, no one is more pleasantly surprised than I am at how comfortable and effective this setup is for an N-frame revolver. Is it for everyone? Is it the most efficient and / or practical solution for concealed carry out there? Maybe; maybe not. But in a world of a LOT of choices, it works very well for me.

Still, there are those times when I recall the wry words of my old pal and start to think of perhaps carrying something a little “smaller” - like a 4-inch Model 28 (ha!) Thus it is that I now seem to swap back and forth between the deep-blued 27 and its less-glossy companion the 28, using an appropriately-sized Summer Classic for either arm.

My amigo, I hope you got that .41 and carry it proudly. And if we again cross paths and you need a holster recommendation, I’ve got one for you. That said, maybe you’ve already discovered one for yourself - I hope you have.

You are certainly on the right track with holsters by Doc Barranti!

As to your friend, the Model 57 is actually a tad heavier than the 29 because the holes drilled in the cylinder and barrel (those parts having substantially the same outer dimensions) are very slightly smaller in the Model 57 (.410 versus .429) leaving correspondingly more steel - not much, but just a little more. So, if concerned about weight, he is better off staying with his Model 29, assuming the same barrel lengths!
 
^^ Makes total sense to me. I had a similar realization (in the opposite direction, I guess?) back when I had a 625 Mountain Gun in .45 ACP. A truly wonderful gun (and one that I now wish I’d held on to), I wondered in my early days with it why it seemed to “kick” so much. It was nothing excessive, mind you, just more than I was expecting. It finally occurred to me that those larger .45-bore holes in the cylinder were removing weight / bulk from from what I was used to dealing with when shooting a Model 27.

That said, I think my friend was being playfully snarky in suggesting that he’d “downsize” to a Model 57 haha…
 
I was also influenced by "Dirty Harry", but in the late 70s when I was out of college and could finally afford to buy a Model 29, they were as scarce as hen's teeth! I did find a brand spankin' new blued 4" Model 57 (in the presentation case), and that was my first ever handgun purchase. I really liked that .41 Magnum, and I carried it around in a Bianchi X15 shoulder holster under a light jacket or sweatshirt. I was fine with the extra couple of ounces of weight of the 57 because it helped with the recoil from my stout hand loads. Don't get me wrong, the Model 29s (and .44 Magnums), in various barrel lengths, are the heart and soul of my modest collection. The 6-1/2" bbl. is my favorite, but it's not easy to carry or conceal.
 
Been down that road myself.
Have owned and carried a 10' TC,couple of Super Black Hawks in 7 1/2' and a 629 Mountain Gun.
Currently down to just one 44 Mag and I am fond of the S&W M69.
Wish they made it in 41,that would be handy.
 
Back
Top